BREATHES THERE A MAN

                         BY CHARLES E. FRITCH

                         ILLUSTRATED BY SMITH

            Someone in the place where Dunlop worked was an
           agent of the World Bureau Investigation. But how
        could they suspect him at a time like this? His tracks
             were covered and tangled until even Julie had
             no knowledge of them. Then the robot came....

           [Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from
                      Rocket Stories, July 1953.
         Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that
         the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]


Arthur Dunlop busied himself over the blueprints as though he had a
deep and sincere interest in them, unmindful of the scurry of sounds in
the office. The incessant clicking of electronic typewriters, muffled
though they were, combined to form a hum of angry bees. Papers shuffled
that were important somehow to the welfare of the State, and men and
women sat and looked at them, checking and rechecking, checking and
rechecking, for it was important that nothing should go wrong, any
place, in even the slightest aspect.

The small square of paper had been dropped on his desk unobtrusively,
and for a brief moment he had stared at it in surprise. Then he covered
it with a casual hand and glanced up in apparent thoughtfulness. A
blonde girl was making her way down the space between rows of metalloid
desks, a bundle of vital-appearing documents in her hands. Arthur
studied the swaying body, as though that were the only thought on his
mind, but the paper burned curiously at his palm.

He returned quickly to his work of checking blueprints, for idleness
even in a trusted employee was looked upon with suspicion. He bent over
the three-dimensional diagram, feigning interest, and slowly opened the
folded square of paper. On it were written the words: "WBI. Careful."
The words leaped up at him in a green ink that would fade in seconds,
leaving no trace.

He crushed the paper in his hand, trying hard not to look around him.
WBI. World Bureau of Investigation. Did they suspect? he wondered. He
thrust the thought from his mind and made a conscious effort to study
the drawing on his desk.

Drawing 2b, one-tenth of the plan for a respirator, newly-designed and
improved, streamlined for the year 2108, Arthur could just imagine the
advertising they'd do on this model. But the other thought crowded it
aside: the underground knew there was a WBI man in the office.

And just why would there be a WBI man here? Routine? Possibly. Yet more
likely, somebody smelled a rat. This was no time for plans to go awry.

He looked up, glancing with apparent disinterest at the faces near
him hovering over their respective desks. They, too, were busy
with blueprints. Part 3d of a new atomic engine. Part 14c of a
three-dimensional television set designed to bring in bigger and better
commercials. Et cetera. Et cetera. For security reasons, no two worked
at the same project.

He scanned their faces, searching for something indefinable, something
that might outwardly betray hidden thoughts. There was Hawkins,
a middle-aged, eagle-faced person, been with the local office of
State Enterprises for more than twenty years--unquestionably loyal
to the government. Merker, a chubby person with shifting eyes behind
thin-lensed glasses; he was okay, for shifting eyes or not, they had
all been checked, even as _he_ had been checked. And Austen, the
newcomer, only twenty-five and fresh from college, a nervous; restless
type of person; he was the most likely suspect for a WBI man, although
some might think it would be too obvious--which might in turn tend to
prove the point.

Arthur shrugged mentally and returned to his work. He stared at the
design of coils and condensers and wires and felt a little sick, which
was strange for he should have become used to it by now. This design,
together with nine others, would form the complete pattern for printing
a mechanism on a thin disc which would be inserted in the watch-like
affair known as a respirator. It was somehow ironic, he thought that he
should be working on it.

His intercom buzzed and he reached to flick on the switch. A
business-like voice said: "Dunlop, this is Samson, can you come in for
a minute?"

"Of course," Arthur said calmly, but he wondered what his superior
wanted. First, the note about a WBI man; now this.

The big door marked "Charles L. Samson, Mgr., Dept. 40" confronted him.
As he neared it, electric eyes probed him, timed his approach, opened
the door automatically.

Charles L. Samson, Mgr., Dept. 40, graying and cleanly mustached, was
intently studying a sheet of paper on which were typewritten several
paragraphs. Arthur drew to a halt before the man's desk, unconsciously
fidgeting mentally and wondering if the item of interest on that paper
concerned him.

The manager carefully put the paper down and raised his eyes.
"Everything okay, Dunlop?"

"Simply great," he answered automatically.

The older man leaned back in his chair. "Dunlop," he said, "you've been
here for some time now, I believe."

"Five years this month," Arthur supplied, trying to put pride in his
voice.

"Precisely," Samson agreed. "And because you have been a loyal and
dependable worker," he smiled blandly, "you'll find a little something
extra in your pay envelope from now on."

Arthur breathed a sudden sigh of relief. So that was it, the automatic
pay increase. It meant no financial gain, of course, since he would
also automatically be put in a higher tax bracket which would just
offset the increase. Pay raises were for "morale" purposes only.

"Thank you, sir," Arthur said, hoping he sounded as though he meant it.

"Quite all right," Samson said, turning once more to his papers.

"Yes, sir." Arthur strode, relieved, from the office.

       *       *       *       *       *

The rest of the workday passed uneventfully and it was time to leave.
The soft hum of preparations testified to that. Plans were folded,
locked securely into desks, and workers filed past probing mechanical
eyes that scanned them for anything hidden. Doors whirred open
electrically, and humanity poured through them into tubecars which
hissed with sickening speed to the helibus terminal.

Arthur flowed into a helibus with the others, and his heart gave a
sudden jump as he saw a familiar blonde form ahead of him. Julie! He
wormed his way forward and sank onto the air-cushion beside her. She
did not look at him. The helibus lurched skyward.

She was staring out the window, at the blue sky and the cloudfaces and
the sun beginning to dip low at the horizon. The building they had
left glowed with the million setting suns reflected from its great bank
of windows. After awhile, her fingers moved restlessly. Arthur Dunlop
watched them idly. The movements were swift, seemingly random but
actually precise and predetermined.

They said: "I couldn't hesitate at your desk; I had to take a chance
with the note."

Arthur glanced complacently about him, stifling a yawn. His fingers
rippled: "Who is the WBI agent?"

"Underground doesn't know--yet," she told him silently. "Meet me
tonight."

"Will I see the leader?" he asked.

"Meet me tonight," was all she would reply.

He nodded, as though to himself, and stared at the signs adorning the
inside of the bus. Names made familiar by television leaped at him.
There was Ronson, Franklin, Stallman, Eliot, names of all kinds to give
the impression of existence to a long-dead free enterprise; all were
government owned, competing to enhance the illusion.

Who was the leader, he wondered, and why the secrecy? Some government
bigwig probably, who kept his secret from all but a few. Well, time
would tell.

He glanced out the window at the countryside rushing below. Trees.
Green fields. The beginnings of the city of small square dwellings. A
man got up, went to the rear of the helibus. After awhile, Arthur rose,
went down the aisle to the exit platform. He paused for a minute, and
then he stepped into space.

The air whirled about him; twin rotors, appearing from his clothing,
churned and scraped the air, lowering him gently through the five
hundred feet to the ground. Overhead, the helibus continued its
prescribed journey, discharging passengers who resembled fluttering
insects. He came to rest gently atop his roof, and the rotors ceased
and folded invisibly beneath his coat.

The moon had risen well into the twilight sky, that moon which only a
few hundred years before had furnished lovers with inspiration. Now,
looking at it, one thought inevitably of the Lunar Prison Colony that
occupied its entire surface, of the persons who had been sentenced to
spend years on its ugly barren wasteland. Inspiration came possibly,
but it was of a different nature.

He descended into the house, into the single room that was bedroom,
living room, parlor. Helen, brunette and beautiful, attired in the
semi-transparent slacks that were the decreed style, rose from the
couch and gave him a wifely peck on the cheek.

"Everything okay?" she asked, not appearing particularly interested.
The standard question.

"Simply great," he said.

He settled into a hard plastic chair, uncomfortable but designed to
improve posture.

       *       *       *       *       *

The television set was blaring: "Nothing could be greater than to have
a respirator made by Fra-a-a-a-nklin!" On the 40-inch screen a happy
couple, Franklin respirators on their happy wrists, were bouncing
happily across a miniature solar system, using planets for stepping
stones.

I must be an atavist, he thought. How can people actually put up with
this stuff. He could not subdue the grimace that rose automatically,
but he managed to turn it into a grin as he saw Helen looking at him
curiously.

"Something funny?"

"Nothing in particular." He couldn't very well tell her he thought a
government-sponsored commercial was amusing. That was the equivalent of
treason, for which the Lunar Prison Colony had been constructed.

Not that Helen wasn't understanding. Their marriage had been lacking in
many things, true, but she was inclined to be fair and broadminded on
most issues which were not controlled. But when it came to things like
the State and its directives, most people got emotionally patriotic. It
was something like trying to discuss religion a century earlier, except
that in the present case arguments could be easily won by sending the
"treasonous" person to the prison satellite. The law made plain what
was right and what was not.

"I was just thinking," he said, hoping to explain the grimace, "about a
fellow at the office. He suggested that we should get a rebate on the
airtax, because we don't utilize all the air we breathe in."

"You reported him, of course."

"Worse than that. We told him if he didn't like it he could stop
breathing. Crime doesn't pay anymore."

"I should hope not," she said, and she seemed perfectly serious.

There was no point in arguing with Helen, so he didn't. She apparently
had little interest in politics other than a layman's desire to see
justice prevail, and if the government wanted to tax the air they
breathed, why--let them; they were taxing everything else.

That's why he found himself drawn irresistibly to Julie; she wasn't a
slave to convention. That's why he liked to meet her in the darkness
of the outside, when the curfew forbade anyone venturing into the
night--at least, that was one reason. She was part of the forbidden
fruit he secretly desired and vowed would have.

A government official's benign face appeared on the television screen
to announce the Super State program. The World Flag materialized,
waving in a studio-inspired breeze, and a chorus chanted: "Super State,
Super State, Simply great is Super Sta-a-ate!"

"Sixty minutes of uninterrupted commercial," Arthur Dunlop thought with
distaste. Plays and songs subtly presented to show that contemporary
living was equivalent to a golden age. He was careful, however, not to
let his face reveal his mind's opinion.

"The airtax man will be around to read the meter tonight," Helen
reminded him.

"Fine," he murmured, but already he was only half-aware of the world
around him as he dozed while appearing outwardly alert.

There was a time, he remembered vaguely, when there were no such
things as respirators, when the air you breathed was free. For twenty
of his thirty-four years he had known that golden era. There were
taxes, of course, but only on the food you ate, the money you earned,
the entertainment you saw, et cetera, almost ad infinitum. Air, it
seemed--much to the government's evident dissatisfaction--was an
untaxable commodity, a luxury which even the poor could enjoy without
restriction.

Then came the war. The war that caused all peoples to finally unite
under one government to insure peace. Arthur Dunlop knew of the war,
for he was a part of it. He fought back to preserve his life, and they
gave him a medal for it, a piece of cloth and metal which indicated
that he was lucky enough to survive. It was another war to make the
world safe for something or other, and he still recalled with a shudder
the Battle of Boston, the Siege of New York, the great topplings of
great cities into greater dust.

To counteract the poisonous by-products of civilized weapons, the
respirators had been developed--small watch-like mechanisms that
enabled the wearers to breathe in practically any atmosphere. After the
war, they had been adapted to a new use.

"What?" Arthur Dunlop said.

Helen was extending a carton marked "6-C." "Mealtime," she declared.

He took the box, another development of the Last War, and opened it.
Standardization was the keynote, he remembered, for in that there is
unity. Standardization of clothing, of living, of eating, of thinking.

He plopped a pill marked "steak" into his mouth, nibbled absently at
the ones labeled "bread" and "potatoes and gravy," and then followed
with a pill called "coffee." It might have been funny had he been able
to view the scene objectively, but the time when he had been able to
do that had long passed. They were the best government-made pills and
tasted not a bit like their labels.

From the television set, an enthusiastic voice declared: "Ronson Rotors
are the best, Try the thousand foot drop test, Be convinced it'll break
your fall, Ronson Rotors are the best of all!"

Furiously, Arthur Dunlop chewed on his pill marked "apple pie."

There was a knock at the door. "Air tax," an authoritative voice
called, and the door slid open to reveal an impassionate face
surrounded by uniform. "Your respirators, please," the face directed in
a monotone. "Monthly check."

Arthur Dunlop extended his wrist, and the man, frowning importantly,
noted several numbers from the respirator dial and wrote them in a
small black book; he carefully examined the part that would tell if
the device had been removed.

Arthur resisted an impulse to ask the man for a refund for the Carbon
Dioxide he had exhaled during the past month to see what reaction
he might get. But the man, eager to get ahead, would welcome the
opportunity to report someone less patriotic than he, and there would
follow an investigation. Investigations were taken as a matter of
course, naturally, and even investigators were being investigated with
confusing regularity. But under the present circumstances, Arthur could
hardly afford the risk. Entirely too much was at stake.

       *       *       *       *       *

"You could use a new respirator," the air tax man said in the tone of a
man who had said this same thing many times before.

"Yes," Arthur agreed mechanically. "What kind would you suggest?"

"What kinds do you like?" the man said testily.

Arthur named the various kinds and the merits professed by each, to
show that he had been attentive to the telecasts. The man, secure in
the knowledge that Arthur was loyal to the cause, left.

Arthur sighed a vague sigh that could mean almost anything and watched
Helen stretch her long limbs, smooth and sensuous beneath their thin
coverings. He wondered what thoughts, if any, were in her mind, but her
lovely face was vacuous and non-committal as she reclined to dutifully
watch the screen as a good citizen should.

       *       *       *       *       *

The evening grew old, and with its aging came the insistence of various
televised personalities that each product cavorting about the screen
was undoubtedly the best possible, and anyone who didn't agree was
most certainly an idiot of the most idiotic sort. Actually, since the
government directed the manufacture of all commodities, it mattered
little which product was bought, so long as they were bought. Finally--

"Time to go to bed," a grandfatherly individual intoned gently from
the set. "Remember: to bed and to rise at a time not late, makes one
healthy and wise for the Super State."

Arthur grimaced at the benign gentleman's countenance, but Helen set
about pushing the buttons that would transform the room into a bedroom.
Tables slid from sight, twin beds appeared, the lights dimmed.

They undressed in the dimness, without conversation, as they had these
many years. It was as though they were separated by miles instead of
only a few feet, each unaware of the other's presence.

"I'm going to grab a fast shower," he told her and headed for the
shower stall. He heard her answering murmur, as he closed the door of
the airtight cubicle. Fingers ran over the dials, and invisible rays
caressed his naked body, cleansing it of impurities with swift silent
radiation.

When he stepped once more into the main room, Helen was lying unmoving
on her bed. The television set was blank, and an almost inaudible
hypnotic hum came from it, soothing, compelling, lulling. He sat on
the edge of the bed, listening in fascination to the sound. Slowly, it
faded, slowly, slowly....

He caught himself starting to doze, and he sat upright on the bed
straining to hear the evasive hum. He shook his head violently to clear
it. He wondered how many persons were aware that the noise was actually
a high-frequency voice-recording which in effect hypnotized persons
into sleep, and then instilled into each one's subconsciousness a
faith in the glories of the government. Yet even when you knew, it was
difficult to resist.

Stealthily, he rose and dressed again in dark silence. He then made
his way across the room to the shower stall, entered, closed the door
securely. A manipulation of the dials, a soft pressure on a portion of
one wall, and a section slid back to reveal a radio apparatus.

Arthur put the microphone to his lips, spoke swiftly into it, making
contact. A furtive voice, crackled and staticky answered in code.
Arthur gave his part of the ritual.

"Right," the voice said, relaxing a bit. "Everything okay?"

"Simply great," Arthur said, putting a smile into the phrase. It was
good to hear George Keating's voice again. "How's everything up there?"

"Not bad. Nobody suspects anything as far as we know. Shipments are
getting a bit slow, but I expect they'll be heavier before long. Ready
to spring it?"

"Yes," Arthur said. "Oh, one thing though," frowning, "the underground
suspects there's a WBI man in my unit."

"Anything further? Have they narrowed him down at all."

"I don't think so. I'm going to a meeting tonight; I managed to talk
Julie into it. If I can, I'll contact you later."

"Right-o."

Arthur closed the circuit and sealed the wall again, turning the dials
to a random location. He opened the door of the cubicle and peered
cautiously into the gloom. He thought he detected a furtive movement,
but it was only Helen turning on the bed.

He crossed the room, noiselessly ascended to the roof and leaped
outward. Blades unfolded to churn the darkness. It was a Stallman
Rotor--their commercials seemed the least offensive--and it deposited
him gently beside his house; just as gently as any Ronson would have
done.

Ahead of him, the stars glittered frostily in the night. He breathed
the crystal air in great intakes of breath, trying not to remember it
was taxed. Lines from Walter Scott leaped unaccountably to his mind:
"Breathes there a man," he thought, "with soul so dead, who never to
himself hath said, 'This is my own, my native land.'" He felt the last
word could be justly changed to "air" to fit this overtaxed era in
which he lived.

The moon was out, and he stopped to stare at it. Across its surface, in
letters of fire, were the words: "Buy Air Bonds, A Solid Investment."
There was little practical need for the ad; pay deductions were
arbitrary. Shaking his head sadly, Arthur Dunlop walked into the night.

Night beckoned, and Arthur Dunlop followed its call. He went willfully,
but he could not have resisted had he wanted to. The streets were
dark, lit only by the moon and the stars, and houses were dark phantoms
rising in the night, their owners lulled to sleep by the omnipresent
television receivers. But he tried not to think of that. He thought
of the cool velvet evening which lay before him, and of the girl who
waited quietly in the shadows of a deserted park.

He thought of that as he walked into the night, and he thought also of
things more serious, and suddenly--

--a voice cried: "Stop!" It was a mechanical voice, tinny, without
emotion. "It is the time of curfew. You are not allowed out. Your name?"

Arthur stood, petrified, and stared at a black robot face before him.
He heard a click, loud in the darkness, and knew that his picture had
been taken.

The sound jarred him from his immobility, and he turned and scampered
into the darkness.

"Stop," the robot commanded, "Stop!" and a shaft of light darted from
its forehead, piercing the darkness, shriveling grass beneath Arthur's
feet. But the ray missed him, and he darted down the street, amid the
pounding echoes of his flight.

After several blocks, he threw himself panting into a doorway and
looked back down the street. Nothing. Silence and moonlight and
darkness, and only his own labored breathing while his chest rose and
fell in unaccustomed gasps.

But they had his picture! In seconds, a giant machine could find a
similar picture in its files, complete with every detail of information
concerning him. They might get him before the work was complete. If he
could only evade them until he could turn this to advantage. He felt in
his pocket for the radioactive silver disc he knew was there.

       *       *       *       *       *

Down the street, a shadow moved, and he held his breath. In a shaft of
moonlight, black metal glinted darkly. With a muffled cry he slipped
from the doorway and flew down the street, trying to still the noise he
made. Behind him, no sounds came to indicate pursuit.

He darted across the street, went into an alley, crossed another
street. Finally, he came to the park. He stopped. Fearfully, he looked
behind him. No one. He walked forward.

The park was a mass of tree and shadow, indistinguishable. Softly, he
called, "Julie." No answer. "Julie."

A gentle movement, and someone disengaged from the shadows, glided to
him. Someone soft and warm--and feminine. He could smell the elusive
taint of her perfume even before she entered his arms.

"You're late," she said.

"I was detained."

She looked sharply at him. "Trouble?"

"I--I don't know. A robot surprised me. He took my picture."

"A robot!" she said in alarm, drawing away from him. "They probably
already know who you are. Were you followed?"

"Part of the way, but I think I dropped him."

"You _think_?" Her tone was worried. "Do you realize you might have led
him here. We can't go to the meeting place now. They'll be searching
for you."

"And they'll find me if I stay here," he said mournfully. "Now, you've
got to take me, Julie. I've got to go someplace."

       *       *       *       *       *

"Where?" she said. "Where can anyone go--except up there?" With a
motion of her head she indicated the moon, hanging like a grim reminder
of the Prison Colony it contained. She shook her head. "I should've
suspected it when that WBI man showed up. Somehow they've gotten wise
to you. Do you realize you've jeopardized our entire position?"

"I didn't mean to--"

"It matters very little whether or not you meant to," Julie said
sharply; "the fact is, you've done it." Her tone softened, "I'm sorry,
Arthur, it's just that--"

"I understand how you feel," Arthur said gently, taking her in his
arms. "Believe me, Julie, everything will turn out all right."

"I hope so," Julie said. "Well, we have to do something; we can't stay
here."

"Take me to the hiding place, Julie," he begged; "we can work out
something from there."

She looked at him briefly, considering the alternatives, her mind torn
between affection for him and fear for the underground's safety. He
knew she was recalling the many plans they had made for when all this
was over, the legal matter of Helen, their home in a world where the
air was free.

"If I stay here they will get me," he reasoned. "At least we have a
chance the other way--if we hurry!"

In sudden determination, she said, "Come on, then."

She took him by the hand and led him deeper into the park. During the
year he had been an unofficial member of the underground, supplying
them with blueprints, he had never seen their headquarters, but he
suspected it was close by, right under the noses of the authorities,
and Julie did not disappoint him. She led him to a stone-block
monument commemorating heroes of the Last War, and effortlessly pushed
aside one of the blocks to reveal the darkness of a tunnel.

"Follow me," she directed and disappeared.

Arthur did, but first he dropped the silver disc a few feet away. When
they were in the tunnel, Julie closed the entrance again and produced a
flashlight. By its beams, they made their way downward.

They walked for perhaps a half-mile, when the tunnel broadened into
what seemed a cavern. Their footsteps echoed from the opposite wall
with a click-click-click, click-click-click.

"The old subway," Julie explained, her voice hollow, and Arthur nodded.
With the coming of the helibus system many years ago, the subways had
been discarded and their entrances sealed and checked periodically. Of
course, they couldn't know about the monument entrance. At least, they
hadn't, Arthur amended, thinking of the silver disc whose emanations
could now be easily picked up by the robots.

"Here we are," Julie said, after awhile, coming to a halt before
a door. She tapped carefully with the flashlight according to a
prearranged signal. The door slid open slightly, emitting a finger of
light from the room's glowtube. A man's face appeared to survey the
corridor briefly, then the door went wide.

They entered a large room and the door slid into place behind them.
Arthur strained his eyes, blinded temporarily by the light. Unfamiliar
faces stared at him, about twenty of them. Men and women of all ages.
He started suddenly. There, grinning pleasantly at him, was Austen, the
young fellow from the office.

"Are we all here?" Julie wanted to know.

"Yes, we were waiting for you," a voice said.

Arthur whirled. "You?"

"Everything okay, Dunlop?" Samson asked, smiling.

"Simply great," he answered, a little weakly.

"What kept you?" Samson asked Julie.

"_He_ was delayed by a robot."

"What?"

Austen was at the door, frowning. "I thought I heard a noise." His
voice was a whisper.

Samson pulled out a gun. He glared at Dunlop. "If they followed you--"

The door gave way with a sudden blast that threw them all to the floor.
In the smoking entrance a robot appeared. With an effort, Samson forced
himself erect and leveled his blaster.

Before he could fire, Arthur leaped at the man, wrenched the weapon
from his fingers. Then the robot was in the room, then another, and
another, their forehead-rays ready for instant use. There was no escape.

"Arthur!" Julie cried hoarsely.

"_There's_ your WBI man," Samson accused.

Arthur smiled crookedly and held on to the blaster in his hand. He did
not look at Julie, for there was silent contempt and shame in her eyes.

       *       *       *       *       *

The trial was short and simple, for justice had ceased to be a
complicated thing and was governed by facts considered in the light of
pre-established premises. To offset any possibility of human error,
a great machine unemotionally sifted and weighed facts presented to
it and arrived at a decision. Either those accused were guilty or
they were not guilty, and obviously they were, so the trial itself
and Arthur's testimony were matters of formality. The prisoners were,
of course, duly convicted and sentenced to life on the Lunar Prison
Colony, where life was rumored to be not long.

However, an unexpected development arose. The Court, it seems, had fed
also into the machine various newly discovered facts concerning Arthur
Dunlop, and the machine, with a figurative eye prefocused on State
security, had arrived at a further pronouncement.

"You are to be commended," the Court said, as spokesman for the
machine, "for your excellent work as a member of the World Bureau
of Investigation. However, there is a little matter of a radio set
concealed in your home--"

Arthur's face went white. Helen, he thought. That movement in the
darkness--she hadn't been asleep! Of course. She was loyal to the
cause, even to the extent of betraying her husband; perhaps she even
suspected about Julie. He almost laughed aloud.

"But that was for emergency use," he pleaded, knowing it would do no
good, "to contact the WBI when necessary."

"That may be," the Court conceded. "However, it was unauthorized, and
it is even possible that its use might be harmful to the State. Until
we can investigate further, you will be sentenced to a temporary term
of one year on the Lunar Prison Colony, after which your case will be
automatically up for review. I understand you applied for Lunar duty.
This will give you an excellent opportunity to become acquainted with
conditions firsthand."

The Court's gavel fell, an archaic but effective symbol of the passing
of judgment. He did not look at the other prisoners who sat gloating
nearby, even in the losing of their cause. Strange, Arthur Dunlop
thought almost unemotionally, the way things had turned out....

       *       *       *       *       *

The Lunar Prison ship came down out of the sky like a gray-metal
coffin, settling with infinite slowness to the dock where the prisoners
waited silently. The airlock opened and a gangplank stretched its
finger towards them. A blond uniformed man strode from the ship, his
Captain's bars glinting in the afternoon sunlight.

The Earthguard came forward, holding out a list of names. "Some
additions to your labor camp, my dear Captain," he said jovially.

"And welcome they'll be," the Captain said, an indefinable glint in his
eyes. "We have a lot of work to accomplish up there."

"So I've heard," the guard said.

The Captain smiled. "You haven't heard the half of it," he said,
winking, and the guard guffawed.

"All right, all right," Samson growled irritably. "If we're going,
let's go."

"Patience, friend," the blond Captain admonished. "Right this way now,
that's right, through the airlock, take your seats as I call them off.
Dunlop, one; Samson, two; Austen, three...."

Arthur filed silently into the spaceship, Samson and Julie and the
others behind him. He took a seat and looked around.

He cried out at what he saw, and then Samson's hands were upon his
neck, squeezing with the fury of a man possessed by one thought. He
felt his breath being cut off, the room darken. They fell into the
aisle. He could hear shouts of vengeance around him, and he thought he
heard Julie's frantic voice telling them to stop. Julie--

The airlock clanged with awful finality, and there was a sickening rush
as the spaceship darted aloft. Uncushioned bodies flew, and Arthur felt
the pressure on his throat ease.

He blinked open his eyes, forced himself erect. The blond Captain was
bending over him. "You okay?"

"Still alive, George," he said, massaging his throat, "but I think we'd
better tell them before I need a new head."

"George?" Julie said, puzzled. "You two know each other?"

"We were in the war together," the Captain said.

Arthur rose unsteadily. "I'd like you people to meet my best friend,
George Keating."

"But--"

"We decided some time ago that Earth is no place for an underground
movement," Arthur said. "There's too much secrecy, too much danger
involved in the slightest movement away from the established pattern.
People are too involved with the Super State idea and the dangers to
their own particular skins." Like my wife, Helen, he thought to himself.

"There's one place, though," George Keating supplied, "where the
inhabitants are in perfect accord with overthrowing the government as
it now exists."

"Where?" Samson asked skeptically.

"Where else," Arthur told him, smiling, "but the Moon, on the prison
colony where people were sent because they didn't like the way
things were turning out politically and otherwise on Earth. It was a
comparatively simple matter to replace the guards with our own group."

"Then," Julie exclaimed, "then you were in on this all the time. It was
part of a plan."

Arthur nodded. "All except Helen's turning me in, which was unexpected
but just as well I suppose. We're almost ready for the ultimatum, and
we wanted this group to aid us, which is why I betrayed you. We could
have whisked you away secretly, but there was greater danger in that
and the disappearance of an individual, much less a group, couldn't
go unnoticed in that society. Besides, this way they'll be more
complacent."

"As I told that guard," Keating added, "we've still got a lot of work
to do, chiefly on the other side of the Moon where Earth can't see--put
the finishing touches on spaceships we've been building, assemble the
weapons and the guided missiles. A lot of work. We may not have to use
them--I hope we don't--but they'll be ready, just in case."

Samson wet his lips. "It's a big project," he said testily.

"Of course," Arthur admitted, smiling. He indicated a porthole. "But
look at Earth down there."

They crowded to see. It was a large green ball, glowing iridescently,
becoming smaller as they approached the prison colony that was not a
prison colony. Julie shrank into Arthur's arms.

"It's beautiful," she said.

Austen said, "Why, it looks fragile, like you could reach out from here
and--and smash it." There was awe and wonder in his voice.

"You can," Keating said, "if necessary." His eyes narrowed. "It's a
perfect target, a sitting duck from the sky. Who owns the Moon controls
Earth."

"I'd like to apologize," Samson said, offering his outstretched hand to
Arthur.

"Me, too," Julie said.

"I'll accept both apologies," Arthur Dunlop said, "but from you, Julie,
I won't settle for a handshake."

Julie took the hint.

"We have a lot of time yet, so we may as well all relax," Keating
announced. "Arthur and I can brief you on the situation as it stands."
He grinned. "If he ever comes up for air!"

       *       *       *       *       *

They laughed the laughter of free men and gazed through the porthole at
their destination. The bright face of the Moon floated towards them.
Behind them, the Earth hung at peace--unsuspecting that anything had
changed.