Produced by Michael Oltz and PG Distributed Proofreaders




The Mental Life of Monkeys and Apes:
  A Study of Ideational Behavior


        ROBERT M. YERKES
       Harvard University




       BEHAVIOR MONOGRAPHS
    Volume 3, Number 1, 1916
        Serial Number 12
    Edited by JOHN B. WATSON
  The Johns Hopkins University


WITH SIX PLATES AND FIVE TEXT FIGURES






CONTENTS

   I. Interests, opportunity and materials

  II. Observational problems and methods

 III. Results of multiple-choice experiments:

    1. Skirrl, _Pithecus irus_
    2. Sobke, _Pithecus rhesus_
    3. Julius, _Pongo pygmaeus_

  IV. Results of supplementary tests of ideational behavior:

    1. Julius, _Pongo pygmaeus_:
        Box stacking experiment
        Box and pole experiment
        Draw-in experiment
        Lock and key test
    2. Skirrl, _Pithecus irus_:
        Box stacking experiment
        Box and pole experiment
        Draw-in experiment
        Hammer and nail test
        Other activities
    3. Sobke, _Pithecus rhesus_:
        Box stacking experiment
        Draw-in experiment
        Box and pole experiment
        Other activities

   V. Miscellaneous observations:

    1. Right- and left-handedness
    2. Instinct and emotion:
        Maternal instinct
        Fear
        Sympathy

  VI. Historical and critical discussion of ideational behavior in
      monkeys and apes:

    1. Evidences of ideation in monkeys
    2. Evidences of ideation in apes

 VII. Provision for the study of the primates and especially the monkeys
      and anthropoid apes

VIII. Bibliography



I

INTERESTS, OPPORTUNITY AND MATERIALS


Two strong interests come to expression in this report: the one in the
study of the adaptive or ideational behavior of the monkeys and the
apes; and the other in adequate and permanent provision for the thorough
study of all aspects of the lives of these animals. The values of these
interests and of the tasks which they have led me to undertake are so
widely recognized by biologists that I need not pause to justify or
define them. I shall, instead, attempt to make a contribution of fact on
the score of each interest.

While recognizing that the task of prospecting for an anthropoid or
primate station may in its outcome prove incomparably more important for
the biological and sociological sciences and for human welfare than my
experimental study of ideational behavior, I give the latter first place
in this report, reserving for the concluding section an account of the
situation regarding our knowledge of the monkeys, apes, and other
primates, and a description of a plan and program for the thorough-going
and long continued study of these organisms in a permanent station or
research institute.

In 1915, a long desired opportunity came to me to devote myself
undividedly to tasks which I have designated above as "prospecting" for
an anthropoid station and experimenting with monkeys and apes. First of
all, the interruption of my academic duties by sabbatical leave gave me
free time. But in addition to this freedom for research, I needed
animals and equipment. These, too, happily, were most satisfactorily
provided, as I shall now describe.

When in 1913, while already myself engaged in seeking the establishment
of an anthropoid station, I heard of the founding of such an institution
at Orotava, Tenerife, the Canary Islands, I immediately made inquiries
of the founder of the station, Doctor Max Rothmann of Berlin, concerning
his plans (Rothmann, 1912).[1] As a result of our correspondence, I was
invited to visit and make use of the facilities of the Orotava station
and to consider with its founder the possibility of coöperative work
instead of the establishing of an American station. This invitation I
gratefully accepted with the expectation of spending the greater part of
the year 1915 on the island of Tenerife. But the outbreak of the war
rendered my plan impracticable, while at the same time destroying all
reasonable ground for hope of profitable coöperation with the Germans in
the study of the anthropoids. In August, 1915, Doctor Rothmann died.
Presumably, the station still exists at Orotava in the interests of
certain psychological and physiological research. So far as I know,
there are as yet no published reports of studies made at this station.
It seems from every point of view desirable that American psychologists
should, without regard to this initial attempt of the Germans to provide
for anthropoid research, further the establishment of a well equipped
American station for the study not only of the anthropoid apes but of
all of the lower primates.

[Footnote 1: See bibliography at end of report.]

In the early months of the war while I was making every effort to obtain
reliable information concerning conditions in the Canary Islands, I
received an urgent invitation from my friend and former student, Doctor
G. V. Hamilton, to make use of his collection of animals and laboratory
at Montecito, California, during my leave of absence from Harvard. This
invitation I most gladly accepted, and in February, 1915, I established
myself in Santa Barbara, in convenient proximity to Doctor Hamilton's
private laboratory where for more than six months I was able to work
uninterruptedly under nearly ideal conditions.

Doctor Hamilton without reserve placed at my disposal his entire
collection of animals, laboratory, and equipment, provided innumerable
conveniences for my work, and in addition, bore the entire expense of my
investigation. I cannot adequately thank him for his kindness nor make
satisfactory acknowledgment here of his generous aid. Thanks to his
sympathetic interest and to the courtesy of the McCormick family on
whose estate the laboratory was located, my work was done under wholly
delightful conditions, and with assistance from Ramon Jimenez and Frank
Van Den Bergh, Jr., which was invaluable. The former aided me most
intelligently in the care of the animals and the construction of
apparatus; and the latter, especially, was of very real service in
connection with many of my experiments.

The collection of animals which Doctor Hamilton placed at my disposal
consisted of ten monkeys and one orang utan. The monkeys represented
either _Pithecus rhesus_ Audebert (_Macacus rhesus_), _Pithecus irus_ F.
Cuvier (_Macacus cynomolgos_), or the hybrid of these two species
(Elliot, 1913). There were two eunuchs, five males, and three females.
All were thoroughly acclimated, having lived in Montecito either from
birth or for several years. The orang utan was a young specimen of
_Pongo pygmaeus_ Hoppius obtained from a San Francisco dealer in
October, 1914 for my use. His age at that time, as judged by his size
and the presence of milk teeth, was not more than five years. So far as
I could discover, he was a perfectly normal, healthy, and active
individual. On June 10, 1915, his weight was thirty-four pounds, his
height thirty-two inches, and his chest girt twenty-three inches. On
August 18 of the same year, the three measurements were thirty-six and
one-half pounds, thirty-three inches, and twenty-five inches.

For the major portion of my experimental work, only three of the eleven
animals were used. A growing male, _P. rhesus_ monkey, known as Sobke; a
mature male, _P. irus_, called Skirrl; and the young orang utan, which
had been named Julius. Plates I and II present these three subjects of
my experiments in characteristically interesting attitudes. In plate I,
figure 1, Julius appears immediately behind the laboratory seated on a
rock, against a background of live oaks. This figure gives one an
excellent idea of the immediate environment of the laboratory. Figure 2
of the same plate is a portrait of Julius taken in the latter part of
August. By reason of the heavy growth of hair, he appeared considerably
older as well as larger at this time than when the photograph for figure
1 was taken. In plate II, figure 3, Julius is shown in the woods in the
attitude of reaching for a banana, while in figure 4 of the same plate
he is represented as walking upright in one of the cages.

Likenesses of Sobke are presented in figures 5 and 6 of plate II. In the
latter of these figures he is shown stretching his mouth, apparently
yawning but actually preparing for an attack on another monkey behind
the wire screen. Figure 7 of this plate indicates Skirrl in an
interesting attitude of attention and with an obvious lack of
self-consciousness. The same monkey is represented again in figures 8
and 9 of plate II, this time in the act of using hammer and saw.


EXPLANATION OF PLATE II


FIGURE 3.--Orang utan, Julius, reaching for banana.

FIGURE 4.--Julius walking across his cage.

FIGURE 5.--_P. rhesus_, Sobke.

FIGURE 6.--Sobke stretching his jaws (yawn?) preparatory to a fight.

FIGURE 7.--_P. irus_, Skirrl.

FIGURE 8.--Skirrl using hammer and nail.

FIGURE 9.--Skirrl using a saw.



All of the animals except the orang utan had been used more or less for
experiments on behavior by Doctor Hamilton, but this prior work in no
way interfered with my own investigation. Doctor Hamilton has
accumulated a large mass of the most valuable and interesting
observations on the behavior of monkeys, and he more thoroughly
understands them than any other observer of whom I have knowledge. Much
to my regret and embarrassment in connection with the present report, he
has thus far published only a small portion of his data (Hamilton, 1911,
1914). In his most recent paper on "A study of sexual tendencies in
monkeys and baboons," he has given important information concerning
several of the monkeys which I have observed. For the convenience of
readers who may make use of both his reports and mine, I am designating
the animals by the names previously given them by Hamilton. The
available and essential information concerning the individuals is
presented below.



_List of animals in collection_

Skirrl. _Pithecus irus_. Adult male.

Sobke. _P. rhesus_. Young adult male.

Gertie. _P. irus-rhesus_. Female. Born November, 1910.

Maud. _P. rhesus_. Young adult female.

Jimmy II. _P. irus_. Adult male.

Scotty. _P. irus_ (?). Adult male.

Tiny. _P. irus-rhesus_. Female. Born August, 1913.

Chatters. _P. irus_. Adult eunuch.

Daddy. _P. irus_. Adult eunuch.

Mutt. _P. irus_. Young adult male. Born August, 1911.

Julius. _Pongo pygmaeus_. Male. Age, 4 years to 5 years.



When I arrived in Santa Barbara, Doctor Hamilton was about to remodel,
or rather reconstruct, his animal cages and laboratory. This gave us
opportunity to adapt both to the special needs of my experiments. The
laboratory was finally located and built in a grove of live oaks. From
the front it is well shown by figure 10 of plate III, and from the rear,
by figure 11. Its location was in every way satisfactory for my work,
and in addition, the spot proved a delightful one in which to spend
one's time.


[Illustration: FIGURE 12.--Ground plan of Montecito laboratory and
cages. Scale 1/120

L, laboratory; C, cages; A, experiment room in which multiple-choice
apparatus was installed; B, E, additional rooms for research; D, store
room and shop; Z, large central cage communicating with the eight
smaller cages 1-8.]


Figure 12 is a ground plan, drawn to scale, of the laboratory and the
adjoining cages, showing the relations of the several rooms of the
laboratory among themselves and to the nine cages. Although the
construction was throughout simple, everything was convenient and so
planned as to expedite my experimental work. The large room A, adjoining
the cages, was used exclusively for an experimental study of ideational
behavior by means of my recently devised multiple-choice method.
Additional, and supplementary, experiments were conducted in the large
cage Z. Room D served as a store-room and work-shop.

The laboratory was forty feet long, twenty-two feet wide, and ten feet
to the plate. Each small cage was six, by six, by twelve feet deep,
while the large compartment into which each of the smaller cages opened
was twenty-four feet long, ten feet wide, and twelve feet deep.



II

OBSERVATIONAL PROBLEMS AND METHODS


My chief observational task in Montecito was the study of ideational
behavior, or of such adaptive behavior in monkeys and apes as
corresponds to the ideational behavior of man. It was my plan to
determine, so far as possible in the time at my disposal, the existence
or absence of ideas and the rôle which they play in the solution of
problems by monkeys and apes. I had in mind the behavioristic form of
the perennial questions: Do these animals think, do they reason, and if
so, what is the nature of these processes as indicated by the
characteristics of their adaptive behavior?

My work, although obviously preliminary and incomplete, differs from
most of the previous studies of the complex behavior of the infrahuman
primates in that I relied chiefly upon a specially devised method and
applied it systematically over a period of several months. The work was
intensive and quantitative instead of more or less incidental, casual,
and qualitative as has usually been the case. Naturally, during the
course of my special study of ideational behavior observations were made
relative to various other aspects of the life of my subjects. Such, for
example, are my notes on the use of the hands, the instincts, the
emotions, and the natural aptitudes of individuals. It is, indeed,
impossible to observe any of the primates without noting most
interesting and illuminating activities. And although the major portion
of my time was spent in hard and monotonous work with my experimental
apparatus, I found time each day to get into intimate touch with the
free activities of my subjects and to observe their social relations and
varied expressions of individuality. As a result of my close
acquaintance with this band of primates, I feel more keenly than ever
before the necessity of taking into account, in connection with all
experimental analyses of behavior, the temperamental characteristics,
experience, and affective peculiarities of individuals.

The light which I have obtained on the general problem of ideation has
come, first, through a method which I have rather inaptly named the
multiple-choice method, and second, and more incidentally, through a
variety of supplementary methods which are described in Section IV of
this report. These supplementary methods are simple tests of ideation
rather than systematic modes of research. They differ from my chief
method, among other respects, in that they have been used by various
investigators during the past ten or fifteen years. It was not my aim to
repeat precisely the observations made by others, but instead to verify
some of them, and more especially, to throw additional light on my main
problem and to further the analysis of complex behavior.

What has been referred to as the multiple-choice method was devised by
me three years ago as a means of obtaining strictly comparable objective
data concerning the problem-solving ability of various types and
conditions of animals. The method was first tried with human subjects in
the Psychopathic Hospital, Boston, with a crude keyboard apparatus
which, however, proved wholly satisfactory as a means of demonstrating
its value. It has since been applied by means of mechanisms especially
adapted to the structure and activities of the organisms, to the study
of the behavior of the crow, pig, rat, and ringdove (Yerkes, 1914;
Coburn and Yerkes, 1915; Yerkes and Coburn, 1915). The method has also
been applied with most gratifying results to the study of the
characteristics of ideational behavior in human defectives,--children,
and adults,--and in subjects afflicted with various forms of mental
disease. It is at present being tried out as a practical test in
connection with vocational guidance and various forms of institutional
examination, such as psychopathic hospital and court examinations.

As no adequate description of the method has yet been published to which
I can here refer, it will be necessary to present its salient
characteristics along with a description of the special form of
apparatus which was found suitable for use with monkeys and apes.

The method is so planned as to enable the observer to present to any
type or condition of organism which he wishes to study any one or all of
a series of problems ranging from the extremely simple to the complex
and difficultly soluble. All of the problems, however, are completely
soluble by an organism of excellent ideational ability. For the human
subject, the solution of the easiest problem of all requires almost no
effort, whereas even moderately difficult problems may require many
repetitions of effort and hours or days of application to the task. In
each case, the solution of the problem depends upon the perception of a
certain constant relation among a series of objects to which the subject
is required to attend and respond. Such relations are, for example,
secondness from one end of the group, middleness, simple alternation of
ends, or progressive movement by constant steps from one end of a group
to the other.

It is possible to present such relational problems by means of
relatively simple reaction-mechanisms. In their essential features, all
of the several types of multiple-choice apparatus designed by the writer
and used either by him or by his students and assistants are the same.
They consist of a series of precisely similar reaction-devices, any one
or all of which may be used in connection with a given observation.
These reaction-mechanisms are so chosen as to be suited to the structure
and action-system of the animal to be studied. For the human being the
mechanism consists of a simple key and the total apparatus is a bank of
keys, with such electrical connections as are necessary to enable the
observer to obtain satisfactory records of the subject's behavior. Let
us suppose the bank of keys, as was actually the case in my first form
of apparatus, to consist of twelve separate reaction-mechanisms; and let
us suppose, further, the constant relation (problem) on the basis of
which the subject is required to react to be that of middleness. It is
evident that in successive trials or experiments the keys must be
presented to the subject in odd groups, the possibilities being groups
of 3, 5, 7, 9, or 11. If for a particular observation the experimenter
wishes to present the first three keys at the left end of the keyboard,
he pushes back the remaining nine keys so that they cannot be operated
and requires the subject to select from the group of three keys the one
which on being pressed causes a signal to appear. It is of course the
clearly understood task of the subject to learn to select the correct
key in the group on first trial. This becomes possible only as the
subject observes the relation of the key which produces the desired
effect to the other keys in the group. On the completion of a subject's
reaction to the group of three keys, a group of seven keys at the
opposite end of the keyboard may, for example, be presented. Similarly,
the subject is required to discover with the minimum number of trials
the correct reaction-mechanism. Thus, time after time, the experimenter
presents a different group of keys so that the subject in no two
successive trials is making use of the same portion of the keyboard. It
is therefore impossible for him to react to spatial relations in the
ordinary sense and manner, and unless he can perceive and appropriately
respond to the particular relation which constitutes the only constant
characteristic of the correct reaction-mechanism for a particular
problem, he cannot solve the problem, or at least cannot solve it
ideationally and on the basis of a small number of observations or
trials.

For the various infrahuman animals whose ideational behavior has been
studied by means of this method, it has been found eminently
satisfactory to use as reaction-mechanisms a series of similar boxes,
each with an entrance and an exit door. An incentive to the selection of
the right box in a particular test is supplied by food, a small quantity
of which is placed in a covered receptacle beyond the exit door of each
of the boxes. Each time an animal enters a wrong box, it is punished for
its mistake by being confined in that box for a certain period, ranging
from five seconds to as much as two minutes with various individuals or
types of organism. This discourages random, hasty, or careless choices.
When the right box is selected, the exit door is immediately raised,
thus uncovering the food, which serves as a reward. After eating the
food thus provided, the animal, according to training, returns to the
starting point and eagerly awaits an opportunity to attempt once more to
find the reward which it has learned to expect. With this form of the
apparatus, the boxes among which choice may be made are indicated by the
raising (opening) of the front door.

Since with various birds and mammals the box form of apparatus had
proved most satisfactory, I planned the primate apparatus along similar
lines, aiming simply to adapt it to the somewhat different motor
equipment and destructive tendencies of the monkeys. I shall now briefly
describe this apparatus as it was constructed and used in the Montecito
laboratory.



EXPLANATION OF PLATE IV

FIGURE 13.--Multiple-choice apparatus, showing observer's bench
   and writing stand.
FIGURE 14.--Apparatus as seen from observer's bench.
FIGURE 15.--Entrances to multiple-choice boxes as seen from
   the response-compartment.
FIGURE 16.--Apparatus as seen from the rear, showing exit
   doors, food receptacles, and covers for same.



The apparatus was built in room A (figure 12), this room having been
especially planned for it with respect to lighting as well as dimensions
and approaches. It was unfortunately impossible to obtain photographs
showing the whole of the apparatus, but it is hoped that the four
partial views of plate IV may aid the reader who is unfamiliar with
previously described similar devices to grasp readily the chief points
of construction. In this plate, figure 13 shows the front of the
complete apparatus, with the alleyway and door by way of which the
experimenter could enter. The investigator's observation-bench and
record-table also appear in this figure, together with weighted cords
used to operate the various doors and the vertically placed levers by
means of which each pair of doors could be locked. Figure 14 is the view
presented to the observer as he stood on the bench or observation stand
of figure 13 and looked over the entire apparatus. Three of the entrance
doors are shown at the right of this figure as raised, whereas the
remainder of the nine entrance doors of the apparatus are closed. Figure
15 is a view of the entrance doors from below the wire roof of the
apparatus. Again, two of the doors are shown as raised, and three
additional ones as closed. The rear of the apparatus appears in figure
16, in which some of the exit doors are closed and others open. In the
latter case, the food receptacles appear, and on the lower part of the
raised doors of the corresponding boxes may be seen metal covers for the
food receptacles projecting at right angles to the doors, while on the
lower edge of each door is an iron staple used to receive a sliding bar
which could be operated from the observer's bench as a means of locking
the doors after they had been closed. The space beyond the exit doors
was used as an alleyway for the return of the animals to the starting
point.

It will be necessary at various points in later descriptions to refer to
these several figures. But further description of them will be more
readily appreciated after a careful examination of the ground plan of
the apparatus presented as figure 17 In accordance with the labelling of
this figure, the experimenter enters the apparatus room through doorway
16, passes thence through doorways 17 and 10 to the large cage Z, from
which he has direct access to the animals and can bring them into the
apparatus. The multiple-choice mechanism proper, consisting of nine
similar boxes (nine were used instead of twelve as a matter of
convenience of construction, not because this smaller number is
otherwise preferable) is labelled F. These boxes are numbered 1 to 9,
beginning at the left. This numbering was adhered to in the recording of
results throughout the investigation. The other important portions of
the apparatus are the runway D, from which the subject at the
experimenter's pleasure could be admitted through doorway 12 to the
large response-chamber E; the alleyways G, H, and I, by way of which
return to the starting point was possible; the observation bench C, with
its approach step 13; and the observer's writing table A.

In the construction of this large apparatus, it was necessary to make
provision for the extremely destructive tendencies of monkeys and
anthropoid apes,--hence the apparent cumbersomeness of certain portions.
It was equally necessary to provide for the protection of the observer
and the prevention of escape of the subjects by completely covering the
apparatus and alleyways with a heavy wire netting.

Each of the eighteen doors of the multiple-choice boxes, and in addition
doors 11, 12, and 15 of the runway D, were operated by the observer from
his bench C by means of weighted window cords which were carried by
pulleys appropriately placed above the apparatus. Each weight was so
chosen as to be just sufficient to hold its door in position after the
experimenter had raised it. For the convenience of the experimenter in
the rapid operation of the twenty-one doors, the weights for the doors
of runway D were painted gray, those for the entrance doors, white, and
those for the exit doors, black.

In each entrance door, as is shown in figure 15 of plate IV, a window
was cut so that the experimenter might watch the animal after it had
entered a given box, and especially note when it left the box after
having received its reward. This window was covered with wire netting.
No such windows were necessary in the exit doors, but to them were
attached heavy galvanized iron flanges which served to cover the food
receptacles. One of these flanges is labelled o in figure 17. The food
receptacles were provided by boring holes in a 2 by 4 inch timber
securely nailed to the floor immediately outside of the exit doors. Into
these holes aluminum cups fitted snugly, and the iron flanges, when the
doors were closed, fitted so closely over the cups that it was
impossible for the animals to obtain food from them.


[Illustration: FIGURE 17.--Ground plan of multiple-choice apparatus in
experiment room A. Scale 1/60

A, record stand; C, bench for observer; B, step as approach to C; D,
alleyway leading to E, response-compartment; F, one of the nine (1-9)
similar multiple-choice boxes; G, H, alleyways leading from boxes to
starting point at D; I, alleyway used by experimenter as approach to
rear of apparatus; W, W, windows; P, alleyway; Z, large cage; 16,
entrance to room A; 17, entrance to apparatus and thence via 10 to
cages; 18, entrance to alleyway 1; 11, 15, entrances to D; 12, entrance
to E; 13, entrance door of box 5; 14, exit door of box 5; o, cover for
food receptacle.]


As originally constructed, no provision was made in the apparatus for
locking the entrance and exit doors of the several boxes when they were
closed. But as two of the subjects after a time learned to open the
doors from either outside or inside the boxes, it became necessary to
introduce locking devices which could be operated by the experimenter
from the observation bench. This was readily accomplished by cutting
holes in the floor, which permitted an iron staple, screwed to the lower
edge of each door, to project through the floor. Through these staples
by means of a lever for each of the nine boxes, the observer was able to
slide a wooden bar, placed beneath the floor of the room, thus locking
or unlocking either the entrance door, the exit door, or both, in the
case of any one of the nine boxes.

Since figure 17 is drawn to scale, it will be needless to give more than
a few of the dimensions of the apparatus. Each of the boxes was 42
inches long, 18 inches wide, and 72 inches deep, inside measurements.
The alleys D, I, and H were 24 inches, and G 30 inches wide, by 6 feet
deep. The doors of the several boxes were 18 inches wide, by 5 feet
high, while those in the alleyways were 24 inches wide by 6 feet high.
The response-compartment E of figure 17 was 14 feet 4 inches, by 8 feet,
by 6 feet in depth. In order that the apparatus might be used with adult
human subjects conveniently, if such use should prove desirable, the
depth throughout was made 6 feet, and it was therefore possible for the
experimenter to walk about erect in it.

The experimental procedure was briefly as follows: A small quantity of
food having been placed in each of the food cups and covered by the
metal flanges on the exit doors, the experimenter raised door 11 of
figure 17 and then opened door 10 and the door of the cage in which the
desired subject was confined. After the latter, in search of food, had
entered the runway D, the experimenter lowered door 11 to keep it in
this runway, and immediately proceeded to set the reaction-mechanisms
for an experiment (trial). Let us suppose that the first setting to be
tried involved all of the nine boxes. Each of the entrance doors would
therefore be raised. Let us further suppose that the right door is
defined as the middle one of the group. With the apparatus properly set,
the experimenter next raises door 12, thus admitting the animal to the
response-compartment E. Any one of the nine boxes may now be entered by
it. But if any except number 5, the middle member of the group, be
entered, the entrance door is immediately lowered and both the exit and
entrance doors locked in position so that the animal is forced to remain
in the box for a stated period, say thirty seconds. At the expiration of
this time the entrance door is raised and the animal allowed to retrace
its steps and make another choice. When the middle box is chosen, the
entrance door is lowered and the exit door immediately raised, thus
uncovering the food, which the animal eats. As a rule, by my monkeys and
ape the reward was eaten in the alleyway G instead of in the
multiple-choice box. As soon as the food has been eaten, the exit door
is lowered by the experimenter, and the animal returns by way of G and H
to runway D, where it awaits its next trial.

As rewards, bananas and peanuts were found very satisfactory, and
although occasionally other foods were supplied in small quantities,
they were on the whole less constantly desired than the former.

Four problems which had previously been presented to other organisms
were in precisely the same form presented to the three primates. These
problems may be described, briefly, by definition of the right reaction
mechanism, thus: problem 1, the first mechanism at the subject's left;
problem 2, the second mechanism at the subject's right (that is, from
the end of the series at the subject's right); problem 3, alternately,
the first mechanism at the subject's left and the first at its right;
problem 4, the middle mechanism of the group.

It was my intention to present these four problems, in order, to each of
the three animals, proceeding with them as rapidly as they were solved.
But as it happened, only one of the three subjects got as far as the
fourth problem. When observations had to be discontinued, Sobke was well
along with the last, or fourth problem; Skirrl was at work at the third
problem; and Julius had failed to solve the second problem.

For each of the problems, a series of ten different settings of the
doors was determined upon in advance. These settings differ from those
employed in a similar investigation with the pig only in that the
numbering of the doors is reversed. In the present apparatus, the boxes
as viewed from the front (entrance) are numbered from the left to the
right end, whereas those of the pig apparatus were numbered from the
right end to the left end.

Below are presented for each of the several problems (1) the numbers of
the settings presented in series; (2) the numbers of the doors open; (3)
the number of doors open in each setting and for the series of ten
settings; and (4) the number of the right door.



PROBLEM 1. First mechanism at left of group

                   Doors                     No. of            No. of
Settings           open                    doors open       right door
 1..................1.2.3......................3..................1
 2..................8.9........................2..................8
 3..................3.4.5.6.7..................5..................3
 4..................7.8.9......................3..................7
 5..................2.3.4.5.6..................5..................2
 6..................6.7.8......................3..................6
 7..................5.6.7......................3..................5
 8..................4.5.6.7.8..................5..................4
 9..................7.8.9......................3..................7
10..................1.2.3......................3..................1
                                              --
                                        Total 35


PROBLEM 2.  Second mechanism from the right end of group

                   Doors                    No. of             No. of
Settings           open                   doors open        right door
 1..................7.8.9......................3..................8
 2..................1.2.3.4....................4..................3
 3..................2.3.4.5.6.7................6..................6
 4..................1.2.3.4.5.6................6..................5
 5..................4.5.6.7.8..................5..................7
 6..................1.2.3......................3..................2
 7..................2.3.4.5....................4..................4
 8..................1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9..........9..................8
 9..................1.2.3.4....................4..................3
10..................3.4.5.6.7.8................6..................7
                                              --
                                        Total 50


PROBLEM 3.  Alternately the first mechanism at the left and the
                    first at the right end of the group

                   Doors                    No. of             No. of
Settings           open                   doors open        right door
 1..................5.6.7......................3..................5
 2..................5.6.7......................3..................7
 3..................1.2.3.4.5.6................6..................1
 4..................1.2.3.4.5.6................6..................6
 5..................4.5.6.7.8..................5..................4
 6..................4.5.6.7.8..................5..................8
 7..................2.3.4.5....................4..................2
 8..................2.3.4.5....................4..................5
 9..................3.4.5.6.7.8.9..............7..................3
10..................3.4.5.6.7.8.9..............7..................9
                                              --
                                        Total 50


PROBLEM 4.  Middle mechanism of the group

                   Doors                    No. of             No. of
Settings           open                   doors open        right door
 1..................2.3.4......................3..................3
 2..................5.6.7.8.9..................5..................7
 3..................1.2.3.4.5.6.7..............7..................4
 4..................7.8.9......................3..................8
 5..................4.5.6.7.8..................5..................6
 6..................1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9..........9..................5
 7..................1.2.3......................3..................2
 8..................2.3.4.5.6..................5..................4
 9..................3.4.5.6.7.8.9..............7..................6
10..................6.7.8......................3..................7
                                              --
                                        Total 50



It was found desirable after a problem had been solved to present a new
and radically different series of settings in order to determine to what
extent the subject had learned to choose the correct door by memorizing
each particular setting. These supplementary observations may be known
as control experiments, and the settings as supplementary settings. In
case of these, as for the original settings, the essential facts are
presented in tabular arrangement.



Settings for Control Experiments

PROBLEM 1.  First at left end

                   Doors                    No. of             No. of
Settings           open                   doors open       right door
 1..................2.3.4......................3..................2
 2..................6.7.8.9....................4..................6
 3..................3.4.5......................3..................3
 4..................4.5.6.7.8.9................6..................4
 5..................6.7.8.9....................4..................6
 6..................1.2.3.4.5..................5..................1
 7..................2.3.4.5.6.7.8..............7..................2
 8..................3.4.5.6.7.8................6..................3
 9..................5.6.7......................3..................5
10..................1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9..........9..................1


PROBLEM 2.  Second from right end

                   Doors                    No. of             No. of
Settings           open                   doors open        right door
 1..................5.6.7.8....................4..................7
 2..................2.3.4.5.6..................5..................5
 3..................1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9..........9..................8
 4..................5.6.7......................3..................6
 5..................1.2.3.4....................4..................3
 6..................4.5.6......................3..................5
 7..................2.3.4.5....................4..................4
 8..................1.2.3......................3..................2
 9..................1.2.3.4.5.6.7..............7..................6
10..................2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9............8..................8


PROBLEM 3.  Alternate left and right ends

                   Doors                    No. of             No. of
Settings            open                  doors open        right door
 1..................5.6........................2..................5
 2..................5.6........................2..................6
 3..................4.5.6.7.8.9................6..................4
 4..................4.5.6.7.8.9................6..................9
 5..................1.2.3.4.5..................5..................1
 6..................1.2.3.4.5..................5..................5
 7..................2.3.4.5.6.7................6..................2
 8..................2.3.4.5.6.7................6..................7
 9..................3.4.5.6.7.8................6..................3
10..................3.4.5.6.7.8................6..................8


PROBLEM 4.  Middle

                   Doors                    No. of             No. of
Settings           open                   doors open        right door
 1..................4.5.6.7.8..................5..................6
 2..................1.2.3......................3..................2
 3..................1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9..........9..................5
 4..................2.3.4.5.6..................5..................4
 5..................6.7.8......................3..................7
 6..................3.4.5.6.7.8.9..............7..................6
 7..................7.8.9......................3..................8
 8..................1.2.3.4.5.6.7..............7..................4
 9..................2.3.4......................3..................3
10..................3.4.5.6.7..................5..................5



It was my aim so far as possible to present to a given subject each day
the ten settings under a given problem in order, without interruption.
If for any reason the series of observations had to be interrupted, it
was resumed at the same point subsequently. Occasionally it was found
desirable or necessary to present only five of the series of ten
settings in succession and then to interrupt observations for an
interval of a few minutes or even several hours. But as a rule it was
possible to present the series of ten settings. All things being
considered, it proved more satisfactory to give only ten trials a day to
each subject. Frequently twenty and rarely thirty trials were given on
the same day. In such cases the series of settings was simply repeated.
The only pause between trials was that necessary for resetting the
entrance doors and replenishing the food which served as a reward for
success.



III

RESULTS OF MULTIPLE-CHOICE EXPERIMENTS


1. Skirrl, _Pithecus irus_

_Problem 1. First at the Left End_


Systematic work with the multiple-choice apparatus and method described
in the previous section was undertaken early in April with Skirrl,
Sobke, and Julius. The results for each of them are now to be presented
with such measure of detail as their importance seems to justify.

Skirrl had previously been used by Doctor Hamilton in an experimental
study of reactive tendencies. He proved so remarkably inefficient in the
work that Doctor Hamilton was led to characterize him as feeble-minded,
and to recommend him to me for further study because of his mental
peculiarities. With me he was from the first frank, aggressive, and
inclined to be savage. It was soon possible for me to go into the large
cage, Z, with him and allow him to take food from my hand. He was
without fear of the experimental apparatus and it proved relatively easy
to accustom him to the routine of the experiment. Throughout the work he
was rather slow, inattentive, and erratic.

Beginning on April 7, I sought to acquaint him with the multiple-choice
apparatus by allowing him to make trips through the several boxes, with
the reward of food each time. Thus, for example, with the entrance and
exit doors of box 7 raised, the monkey was allowed to pass into the
reaction-compartment E and thence through box 7 to the food cup. As soon
as he had finished eating, he was called back to D by the experimenter
and, after a few seconds, allowed, similarly, to make a trip by way of
one of the other boxes. By reason of this preliminary training he soon
came to seek eagerly for the reward of food.

On April 10 the apparatus was painted white in order to increase the
lightness and thus render it easier for the experimenter to observe the
animal's movements, and when on April 12 Skirrl was again introduced to
it for further preliminary training, he utterly refused to enter the
boxes, giving every indication of extreme fear of the white floors and
even of the sides of the boxes. Finally, the attempts to induce him to
enter the boxes had to be given up, and he was returned to his cage
unfed. The following day I was equally unsuccessful in either driving or
tempting him with food into the apparatus. But on April 14 he was so
hungry that he was finally lured in by the use of food. He cautiously
approached the boxes and attempted to climb through on the sides instead
of walking on the floor. It was perfectly evident that he had an
instinctive or an acquired fear of the white surfaces. As the matter was
of prime importance for the success of my work, I inquired of Doctor
Hamilton, and of the men in charge of the cages, for any incident which
might account for this peculiar behavior, and I learned that some three
months earlier, while the animal cages were being whitewashed, Skirrl
had jumped at one of the laborers who was applying a brush to the
framework of one of the cages and had shaken some lime into his eyes. He
was greatly frightened and enraged. Evidently he experienced extreme
discomfort, if not acute pain, and there resulted an association with
whiteness which was quite sufficient to cause him to avoid the freshly
painted apparatus.

Having obtained an adequate explanation of this monkey's peculiar
behavior, I proceeded with my efforts to induce him to work smoothly and
rapidly, and on April 15, by covering the floor with sawdust, I so
diminished the influence of the whiteness as to render the preliminary
training fairly satisfactory. At the end of two more days everything was
going so well that it seemed desirable to begin the regular experiment.

On the morning of April 19, Skirrl was introduced to the apparatus and
given his first series of ten trials on problem 1. This problem demanded
the selection of the first door at the left in any group of open doors.
The procedure was as previously described in that the experimenter
raised the entrance doors of a certain group of boxes, admitted the
animal to the reaction-chamber, punished incorrect choices by confining
the animal for thirty seconds, and rewarded correct choices by raising
the exit door and thus permitting escape and the obtaining of food. The
trials were given in rapid succession, and the total time required for
this first series of ten trials was thirty-five minutes. Skirrl worked
faithfully throughout this interval and exhibited no marked
discouragement. When confined in a box he showed uneasiness and
dissatisfaction by moving about constantly, shaking the doors, and
trying to raise them in order to escape.

For the series of settings used in connection with problem 1, the reader
is referred to page 18. In the first setting, the doors numbered 1, 2,
and 3, were opened. As it happened, the animal when admitted to the
reaction-chamber immediately chose box l. Having received the reward of
food, he was called back to D, and doors 8 and 9 having been raised in
preparation for the next trial, he was again admitted to the
reaction-chamber. This time he quickly chose box 9 and was confined
therein for thirty seconds. On being released, he chose after an
interval of four minutes, box 8, thus completing the trial.

As it is highly important, not only in connection with the present
description of behavior, but also for subsequent comparison of the
reactions of different types of organism in this experiment, to present
the detailed records for each trial, tables have been constructed which
offer in brief space the essential data for every trial in connection
with a given problem.

Table 1 contains the results for Skirrl in problem 1. It is constructed
as follows: the date of a series of trials appears in the first vertical
column; the numbers (and number) of the trials for the series or date
appear in column 2; the following ten columns present respectively the
results of the trials for each of the ten settings. Each number, in
these results, designates a box entered. At the extreme right of the
table are three columns which indicate, first, the number of trials in
which the right box was chosen first, column headed R; and second, the
number of trials in which at least one incorrect choice occurred, column
headed W. In the last column, the daily ratio of these first choices
appears.

Taking the first line of table 1 below the explanatory headings, we note
on April 19 ten trials, numbered 1 to 10, were given to Skirrl. In trial
1, with setting 1, he chose correctly the first time, and the record is
therefore simply 1. In trial 2, setting 2, he incorrectly chose box 9,
the first time. At his next opportunity, he chose box 8, which was the
right one. The record therefore reads 9.8. In trial 3, setting 3, he
chose incorrectly twice before finally selecting the right box. The
record reads 6.7.3, and so on throughout the ten trials which constitute
a series. The summary for this series indicates three right and seven
wrong first choices, that is, three cases in which the right box was
entered first. The ratio of right to wrong first choices is therefore 1
to 2.33. Since the total number of doors open in the ten settings is
thirty-five, and since in each of the ten settings one door is
describable as the right door, the probable ratio, apart from the
effects of training, of right to wrong first choices is 1 to 2.50. It is
evident, therefore, that Skirrl in his first series of trials closely
approximated expectation in the number of mistakes.



TABLE 1

Results for Skirrl, _P. irus_, in Problem 1

========+==========+=========+=========+===========+=============+===========+===========+===========+=============+===========+===========+===+===+========
        |    No.   |   S.1   |   S.2   |    S.3    |     S.4     |    S.5    |    S.6    |    S.7    |     S.8     |    S.9    |   S.10    |   |   | Ratio
Date    |    of    |         |         |           |             |           |           |           |             |           |           | R | W |   of
        |  trials  |  1.2.3  |   8.9   | 3.4.5.6.7 |    7.8.9    | 2.3.4.5.6 |   6.7.8   |   5.6.7   |  4.5.6.7.8  |   7.8.9   |   1.2.3   |   |   | R to W
--------+----------+---------+---------+-----------+-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+-------------+-----------+-----------+---+---+--------
 April  |          |         |         |           |             |           |           |           |             |           |           |   |   |
  19    |   1-  10 | 1       | 9.8     | 6.7.3     | 9.7         | 6.2       | 7.8.6     | {6.7.7.7  | 4           | 7         | 2.3.3.1   | 3 | 7 | 1:2.33
        |          |         |         |           |             |           |           | {6.5      |             |           |           |   |   |
        |          |         |         |           |             |           |           |           |             |           |           |   |   |
  20    |  11-  20 | 3.2.1   | 9.8     | 5.3       | 7           | 4.2       | 8.8.6     | 5         | 8.4         | 7         | 3.1       | 3 | 7 | 1:2.33
  21    |  21-  30 | 3.1     | 8       | 3         | 8.7         | 6.2       | 6         | 5         | 6.4         | 9.7       | 1         | 5 | 5 | 1:1.00
  22    |  31-  40 | 1       | 9.8     | 3         | 7           | 6.2       | 6         | 6.7.5     | 5.8.4       | 9.8.9.8.7 | 2.1       | 4 | 6 | 1:1.50
  23    |  41-  50 | 2.3.1   | 8       | 5.7.3     | 7           | 4.2       | 6         | 5         | 7.8.4       | 7         | 3.1       | 5 | 5 | 1:1.00
  24    |  51-  60 | 1       | 8       | 4.5.7.3   | 9.7         | 5.6.2     | 6         | 6.7.5     | 6.4         | 8.9.7     | 1         | 4 | 6 | 1:1.50
  26    |  61-  70 | 1       | 8       | 6.7.4.7.3 | 7           | 4.5.6.2   | 6         | 5         | 8.4         | 7         | 3.2.3.1   | 6 | 4 | 1: .67
  27    |  71-  80 | 3.1     | 8       | 3         | 9.7         | 4.6.2     | 7.6       | 6.5       | 5.8.4       | 7         | 1         | 4 | 6 | 1:1.50
  28    |  81-  90 | 2.3.1   | 8       | 3         | 7           | 4.5.6.2   | 6         | 5         | 5.8.4       | 7         | 1         | 7 | 3 | 1: .43
  29    |  91- 100 | 1       | 8       | 3         | 9.7         | 6.2       | 6         | 5         | 4           | 7         | 1         | 8 | 2 | 1: .25
  30    | 101- 110 | 1       | 8       | 4.3       | 7           | 5.6.2     | 6         | 5         | 4           | 7         | 2.3.1     | 7 | 3 | 1: .43
  May   |          |         |         |           |             |           |           |           |             |           |           |   |   |
   1    | 111- 120 | 2.3.2.1 | 8       | 3         | 7           | 2         | 6         | 5         | 4           | 7         | 1         | 9 | 1 | 1: .11
   3    | 121- 130 | 1       | 8       | 5.6.3     | 7           | 4.5.2     | 6         | 5         | 4           | 7         | 1         | 8 | 2 | 1: .25
4 and 5 | 131- 140 | 3.2.1   | 8[1]    | 3         | 7           | 2         | 6         | 5         | 4           | 7         | 1         | 9 | 1 | 1: .11
   5    | 141- 150 | 1       | 8       | 4.3       | 7           | 2         | 6         | 5         | 4           | 7         | 1         | 9 | 1 | 1: .11
--------+----------+---------+---------+-----------+-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+-------------+-----------+-----------+---+---+--------
        |          |         |         |           |             |           |           |  2.3.4.5  |             |           | 1.2.3.4.5 |   |   |
        |          |  2.3.4  | 6.7.8.9 |   3.4.5   | 4.5.6.7.8.9 |  6.7.8.9  | 1.2.3.4.5 |   6.7.8   | 3.4.5.6.7.8 |   5.6.7   |  6.7.8.9  |   |   |
        |          +---------+---------+-----------+-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+-------------+-----------+-----------+---+---+--------
   6    |   1-  10 | 2       | 6       | 3         | 4           | 6         | 3.2.1     | 6.2       |  5.6.7.8.3  | 5         | 6.1       | 6 | 4 | 1: .67
========+==========+=========+=========+===========+=============+===========+===========+===========+=============+===========+===========+===+===+========

[Footnote 1: End of series on May 4.]



By reading downward in any particular column of results, one obtains a
description of the changes in the animal's reaction to a particular
setting of the doors. Thus, for instance, in the case of setting 1,
which was presented to the animal in trials numbered 1, 11, 21, and so
on to 141, it is clear from the records that no definite improvement
occurred. But oddly enough, in the case of setting 10, which presented
the same group of open doors, almost all of the reactions are right in
the lower half of the column. For setting 2, it is evident that mistakes
soon disappeared.

Comparison of the data of table 1 indicates that the number of correct
first choices is inversely proportional to the number of doors in use,
while the number of choices made in a given trial is directly
proportional to the number of doors in use.

During the first week of work on this problem, Skirrl improved markedly.
His performance was somewhat irregular and unpredictable, but on the
whole the experiment seemed fairly satisfactory. Cold, cloudy, or rainy
days tended to diminish steadiness and to increase the number of
mistakes. Similarly, absence of hunger was unfavorable to continuous
effort to find the right box.

The period of confinement, as punishment for wrong choices, was
increased from thirty seconds to sixty seconds on April 26. But there is
no satisfactory evidence that this favored the solution of the problem.
Work on May 4 was interrupted by a severe storm, the noise of which so
distracted the monkey that he ceased to work. Consequently, observations
were interrupted on the completion of trial 132, and on May 5, the
series was begun with setting 3. On this date, eighteen trials were
given in succession, and in only one of them did a mistake occur. Since
the ten trials numbered 133 to 142 were correct, Skirrl was considered
to have solved problem 1, and systematic training was discontinued.

On the following day, as a measure of the extent to which the animal had
learned to select the first door at the left no matter what its position
or the number of doors in the group presented, a control series was
given in which the settings differed from the regular series of
settings. These supplementary settings are presented at the bottom of
table 1 together with the records of reaction in ten trials.

Since in only six of these ten control settings was the first choice
correct, it is scarcely fair to insist that the animal was reacting on
the basis of an ideational solution of the problem. Rather, it would
seem that he had learned to react to particular settings. A careful
study of all of the data of response, together with notes on the varied
behavior of the animal during the experiments, justifies the statement
that Skirrl's solution of problem 1 was incomplete and unreliable. It
was highly dependent upon the particular situation, or even the
particular door at the left end of the group, and slightly if at all
dependent upon anything comparable to the human idea of first at the
left of the group.

This particular series of observations has been described and discussed
in some detail in order to make the chief points of method clear. It
will be needless, hereafter, to refer explicitly to many of the
characteristics of reaction or to the important points in the
construction of tables which have been mentioned.

A graphic representation of Skirrl's learning process in problem 1 is
presented in figure 18. The irregularities are most striking, and fairly
indicate the erraticness of the animal. The curve is based upon the data
in next to the last column of table 1, that is, the column presenting
the errors or wrong first choices in each series of trials.

Unquestionably, the form of such a curve of learning should be
considered in connection with the method or methods of selecting the
right box employed by the animal during the course of experimentation.
It appears from an analysis of the behavior of Skirrl in problem 1 that
there developed a single definite and persistent method, namely, that of
going to one box in the group, and in case it happened to be a wrong
one, of choosing, on emergence from it, the next toward the right end of
the group, and so on down the line. Having reached the extreme right
end, the tendency was to follow the side of the reaction-chamber around
to the opposite end and to enter the first box at the left end of the
group, which was, of course, the right one. This method appears, with
certain slight variations, in approximately ninety per cent of the
trials which involved incorrect choices. Thus, in the case of trials 121
to 130, of which eight exhibit right first choices, the remaining two
exhibit the method described above except that the final member at the
right end of the group was in each case omitted.

[Illustration: FIGURE 18.--Error curves of learning for the solution of
problem 1 (first box at left end).]

On the whole, Skirrl's behavior in connection with this problem appears
to indicate a low order of intelligence. He persisted in such stupid
acts as that of turning, after emergence from the right box, toward the
right and passing into the blind alley I, instead of toward the left,
through G and H, to D. In contrast with the other animals, he spent much
time before the closed doors of the boxes, instead of going directly to
the open doors, some one of which marked the box in which the reward of
food could be obtained. It is, moreover, obvious that his responses, as
they appear in table 1, are extremely different from those of a human
being who is capable of bringing the idea of first at the left end to
bear upon the problem in question.


_Problem 2. Second from the Right End_

Following the series of control trials of problem 1 given to Skirrl on
May 6, a period of four days was allowed during which the animal was
merely fed in the boxes each day. This was done in order that he should
partially lose the effects of his previous training to choose the first
box at the left before being presented with the second problem, the
second box from the right.

On May 11 regular experimentation was begun with problem 2. Naturally
the situation presented unusual difficulties to the monkey because of
his previously acquired habit, and on the first day it was possible to
give only five trials, in all except the first of which Skirrl had to be
aided by the experimenter to find the right box. He persistently, as
appears in the first line of records of table 2, entered the first box
at the left. The series was continued on May 13, but with very
unsatisfactory results, since he apparently had been greatly discouraged
by the unusual difficulties previously met. Only four trials could be
given, and in these the showing made was very poor. It is noteworthy,
however, that in trials 6, 7, and 8, May 13, there was no marked
tendency to choose the first box at the left. Thus quickly had the force
of the previous habit been broken.

For problem 2, the total number of open doors in the ten settings is
fifty, as appears from the data on page 18, and as ten of these fifty
open doors may be defined as right ones, the expected ratio of right to
wrong first choices in the absence of previous training is 1 to 4. The
actual ratio for the first series given in problem 2 is 1 to 8, while in
the second series it is 0 to 10.

On the morning of May 13, work was interrupted in the ninth trial by
what seemed at the moment a peculiarly unfortunate accident, but in the
light of later developments, an incident most fruitful of valuable
results.

Skirrl, in trial 9, directly entered box 1. Since this was not the right
box, he was punished by being confined in it for ten seconds. While in
the box he howled and when the entrance door was raised for him to
retrace his steps, he came out with a rush, showing extreme excitement
and either rage or fear, I could not be sure which. At intervals he
uttered loud cries, which I am now able to identify as cries of alarm.
Repeatedly he went to the open door of box 1 and peered in, or peered
down through the hole in the floor which received the staple on the
door. He refused to enter any one of the open boxes and continued, at
intervals of every half minute or so, his cries. For thirty minutes I
waited, hoping to be able to induce him to complete the series of
trials, but in vain. Although it was obvious that he was eager to escape
from the apparatus, he would not enter any of the boxes even when the
exit doors were raised. Instead, he gnawed at the door (12 in fig. 17)
to the alleyway D and attempted to force his way through, instead of
taking the easy and clear route to the alleys, through one of the boxes.
His behavior was most surprising and puzzling. Finally, I gave up the
attempt to complete the series and returned him to his cage by way of
the entrance door to the response-compartment E.

I then entered the apparatus to seek some explanation of the animal's
behavior, and my search was rewarded by the finding of two sharp pointed
nails which protruded for an inch or more in the middle of the floor of
box 1. My assistant, who had been charged with the task of installing
the locks for the several doors, had used nails instead of screws for
attaching staples underneath the floor and had neglected to clinch the
nails. Skirrl, in the dim light of the box, doubtless stepped upon one
of the nails and inflicted a painful, although not serious, injury upon
himself. It was impossible for him to see clearly the source of his
injury. He was greatly frightened and expressed the emotion most
vigorously. His behavior strongly suggested a superstitious dread of
some unseen danger. It may be that the instinctive fear of snakes, so
strong in monkeys, was partly responsible for his response.

The first result of this accident was that more than two weeks were
lost, for it was impossible, during the next few days, to induce the
animal to enter any of the multiple-choice boxes voluntarily. From May
14 to May 24, I labored daily to overcome his newly acquired fear. The
usual procedure was to coax him through one box after another by
standing at the exit door with some tempting morsel of food. After
several days of this treatment, he again trusted himself to the boxes,
although very circumspectly and only when both entrance and exit doors
were raised. Not until May 24 was it possible to resume regular
experimentation, and on that day it was found necessary to indicate the
right box by raising the exit door slightly and then immediately
lowering it. Trials in which this form of aid was given are indicated in
table 2 by a star following the last choice.

Gradually, Skirrl regained his confidence in the apparatus and began to
work more naturally. For a long time he would not stand punishment, and
it was necessary for the experimenter to be very careful in locking the
doors, since the sound of the bar sliding beneath the floor often
frightened and caused him to quit work. Day after day the tendency to
peer through the holes in the floor at the entrance to the boxes
rendered it clear that the animal feared some danger from beneath the
floor. This behavior was so persistent that much time was wasted in the
experiments.

On the last day of May, punishment by confinement for ten seconds in
wrong boxes was introduced, but since this tended to discourage the
monkey, there was substituted for it on June 1 the punishment of forcing
him to work his way out of each wrong box by raising the entrance door
which had been closed behind him. This he could fairly readily do, and
his stay in a box rarely measured more than ten seconds.

As a variation in the mode of procedure, confinement for thirty seconds
was tried on June 5, but it worked unsatisfactorily and had to be
abandoned. During this series, the animal was startled by the sound from
one of the sliding bars under the floor, and in the sixth trial he
refused to work.

As improvement was very slow, varied modes of rewarding and punishing
the animal were tried in the hope of discovering a means of facilitating
the work. Among the former are the use of banana, grapes, peanuts, and
other eagerly sought foods in varying quantities, and in the latter are
included periods of confinement ranging from ten seconds to sixty
seconds. In the end, confinement of about thirty seconds, combined with
a small quantity of food which was much to the monkey's taste, gave most
favorable results.

All this time Skirrl's attention to the task in hand was seldom good. He
was easily diverted and even when extremely hungry, often stopped work
in the middle of an early trial, yawned repeatedly and finally sat down
to wait for release from the apparatus.

The results obtained during the long continued trials with this animal
in problem 2 are presented in table 2, which differs from the previously
described table, first, in that several of the trials are followed by an
asterisk to indicate that aid was given by the experimenter, and second,
in that two additional columns, headed, respectively, R and W, are
presented. These give the right and wrong first choices for each day,
whereas the two columns preceding them give the same data for each
series of ten trials. Similarly, the ratio of right to wrong choices is
presented for each day in table 2, instead of for each series of ten
trials as in table 1.

From the results of table 2, several peculiarly interesting facts
appear. In the first place the influence of the habit of choosing the
first box at the left disappears with surprising suddenness, and in the
second place, there are remarkable contrasts in the results for
different settings as they appear in their respective vertical columns.
Thus, in the case of setting 1, after the first trial mistakes became
relatively infrequent, whereas in setting 6, which involved the same
number of doors, mistakes continued to be the rule until nearly a
thousand trials had been given. The most likely explanation of this
difference is that for some reason the animal avoided box 9.

The _reactive tendencies_, or better, the _methods of reaction_ which
manifested themselves during this long series of observations may be
described as follows: (a) choice of the first box at the left; (b)
random choice with tendency to choose first, a box near the middle of
the group; (c) choice of first box at the right followed by the one next
to it on the left; (d) direct choice of the right box.



TABLE 2

Results for Skirrl, _P. irus_, in Problem 2


========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========
        |    No.    |     S.1      |     S.2      |     S.3      |     S.4      |     S.5      |     S.6      |     S.7      |     S.8      |     S.9      |     S.10     |   |   |   |   | Ratio
  Date  |    of     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |  1.2.3.4.5   |              |              | R | W | R | W |   of
        |  trials   |    7.8.9     |   1.2.3.4    | 2.3.4.5.6.7  | 1.2.3.4.5.6  |  4.5.6.7.8   |    1.2.3     |   2.3.4.5    |   6.7.8.9    |   1.2.3.4    | 3.4.5.6.7.8  |   |   |   |   | R to W
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
  May   |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
 11&13  |    1-   9 | 7.7.9.7.8    | {1.2.2.1.4.1 | {2.3.2.3.2.5 | {4.6.1.4.1.1 | 4.4.7        | 3.1.2        | 4            | 4.1.8        | 1            |              | 1 | 8 | 1 | 8 | 1: 8.00
        |           |              | {2.1.2.1.3   | {2.3.2.5.6   | {2.6.1.6.5   |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   24   |   11-  20 | 8*[1]        | 2.4.3*       | 4.5.6*       | 2.2.5*       | 5.6.6.7*     | 3.1.2        | {5.2.3.5.3.2 | 4.6.8*       | 4.4.3*       | 5.5.6.7*     | 0 |10 | 0 |10 | 0:10.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {3.5.2.4*    |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   25   |   21-  30 | 8*           | 4.4.3*       | 5.6          | {6.6.2.3.4   | 6.7          | 2            | 4            | 5.6.3.8      | 4.4.3        | 6.4.6.8.7    | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              | {6.6.5*      |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   26   |   31-  40 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 4.5          | 6.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 5.8          | 4.3          | 5.3.8.7      | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   27   |   41-  50 | 8            | 4.4.3        | 6            | 5            | 6.8.6.8.7    | 3.3.3.2      | 5.4          | {6.5.4.3     | 4.3          | 5.4.8.7      | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.1.5.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   28   |   51-  60 | 8            | 4.4.3        | 7.6          | 5            | 5.6.7        | 3.3.3.2      | 4            | {5.4.3       | 4.3          | {5.4.3.3.4.5 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {3.6.8       |              | {6.4.3.5.7   |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   29   |   61-  70 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 6.6.5        | 7            | 3.3.3.2      | 5.4          | 7.6.4.7.6.8  | 4.3          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   31   |   71-  80 | 8            | 4.4.4.3      | 6            | 6.5          | 6.8.7        | 3.2          | 5.4          | {6.7.6.4.3   | 4.3          | 6.7          | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
  June  |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.6.3.7.8   |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {6.8.6.5.4   |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    1   |   81-  90 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 5            | {6.5.6.5.8   | 3.1.3.2      | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {5.4.6.4.7   |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |   91- 100 | 9.7.8        | 4.2.4.3      | 7.5.6        | 5            | 6.8.7        | 3.3.1.2      | 5.3.4        | 8            | 4.3          | 6.8.7        | 2 | 8 | 7 |13 | 1: 1.86
    2   |  101- 110 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.8          | 4.3          | 6.8.6.5.7    | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  111- 120 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.3.5.7.6    | {6.2.3.6.4   | 7            | 3.2          | {5.2.3.5.3.2 | 9.6.4.7.8    | {4.1.2       | 6.8.7        | 2 | 8 | 6 |14 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              | {3.6.2.5     |              |              | {3.5.2.3.4   |              | {4.2.3       |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.8.6.3     |   |   |   |   |
    3   |  121- 130 | 8            | 4.4.3        | 6            | 5            | 6.7          | 3.2          | {5.3.2.3     | 8            | 4.2.3        | {5.4.5.8.8   | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.2.5.4     |              |              | {6.3.8.7     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  131- 140 | 8            | 4.3          | 5.7.3.2.6    | 4.5          | 5.7          | 1.3.2        | 5.3.4        | 6.7.8        | 4.2.1.3      | 7            | 2 | 8 | 6 |14 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    4   |  141- 150 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 2            | {5.3.2.3     | 6.8          | 4.1.3        | 5.6.7        | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.5.4       |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  151- 160 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 5            | 6.7          | 2            | 4            | 5.6.7.8      | 4.3          | 5.6.8.7      | 5 | 5 | 8 |12 | 1: 1.50
    5   |  161- 170 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 6.8.7        | 3.2          | 5.3.2.3.5.4  | 8            | 4.3          | 6.7          | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  171- 176 | 8            | 2.4.3        | 7.6          | 6.5*         | 8.7          | 3.2*         |              |              |              |              | 1 | 5 | 3 |13 | 1: 4.33
    7   |  177- 180 |              |              |              |              |              |              | 5.4          | 8            | 4.4.3        | 8.7          | 1 | 3 |   |   |
    "   |  181- 190 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.3.2.5.4    | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 5 | 9 | 1: 1.80
    8   |  191- 200 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  201- 210 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 6.4.6.5      | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 6 |14 | 1: 2.33
    9   |  211- 220 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 8.6.7        | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  221- 230 | 9.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 6.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.6.8        | 4.3          | 7            | 1 | 9 | 3 |17 | 1: 5.67
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   10   |  231- 240 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 6.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | {3.2.3.2.4.3 | 4.3          | 7            | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.5.4.7.8   |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   11   |  241- 250 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.6.5        | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |              12   |  251- 260 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 6.7          | 3.3.2        | 5.4          | {7.6.7.7     | 3            | 3.7*         | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.9.8*      |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |              14   |  261- 270 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | {5.3.4.3     | 3            | {3.3.3.3.4   | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1: 1.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {9.8*        |              | {4.6.4.7*    |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |              15   |  271- 280 | 7.9.8        | 4.2.3        | 3.4.3.7.6    | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 1 | 9 |   |   |
    "   |  281- 290 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 | 4 |16 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |                   |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {4.3.2.3     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   16   |  291- 300 | 7.8          | {4.4.4       | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.3.2        | 5.4          | {6.5.4.3     | 4.3          | 6.7          | 2 | 8 |   |   |
        |           |              | {4.4.3       |              |              |              |              |              | {5.6.7.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               "   |  301- 310 | 8            | 4.4.3        | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.3.2        | 5.5.4        | {7.6.5.4.6   | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 | 5 |15 | 1: 3.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.7.9.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |              17   |  311- 320 | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.6.5        | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.6.7.6.7.8  | 4.3          | 7            | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  321- 330 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 6.7          | 2 | 8 | 4 |16 | 1: 4.00
   18   |  331- 340 | 7.7.8        | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 4 | 6 |   |   |
    "   |  341- 350 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.6.5        | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 | 7 |13 | 1: 1.86
   19   |  351- 360 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 6.5.6.5.7    | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   |  361- 370 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.4.3.6.5    | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 9.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 | 6 |14 | 1: 2.33
   21   |  371- 380 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.8          | 4.3          | 8.7          | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  381- 390 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 6 |14 | 1: 2.33
   22   |  391- 400 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 6.5.4.6.7    | 3.3.3.2      | 5.4          | 6.7.8        | 4.4.3        | 7            | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  401- 410 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 2            | 5.4          | 6.7.7.8      | 3            | 7            | 5 | 5 | 7 |13 | 1: 1.86
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |              23   |  411- 420 | 8            | 4.4.3        | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | {7.6.7.6     | 4.3          | 7            | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.7.8       |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |              24   |  421- 430 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 |   |   |
    "   |  431- 440 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.3.2        | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 5 | 5 |11 | 9 | 1: 0.82
   25   |  441- 450 | 7.8          | 4.4.3        | 7.6          | 6.5          | 6.5.7        | 3.3.2        | 5.5.4        | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
   26   |  451- 460 | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   |  461- 470 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 3 | 7 | 6 |14 | 1: 2.33
   28   |  471- 480 | 8            | 4.4.3        | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 9.8          | 3            | 8.7          | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
   29   |  481- 490 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.7.6        | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
   30   |  491- 500 | 7.9.8        | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   |  501- 510 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.4.3        | 8.7          | 2 | 8 | 5 |15 | 1: 3.00
  July  |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    1   |  511- 520 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               2   |  521- 530 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | {7.6.5.6.5   | 4.4.3        | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.5.6.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               "   |  531- 540 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 7 |13 | 1: 1.86
    3   |  541- 550 | 7.8          | 4.4.3        | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 5.5.7        | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   |  551- 560 | 7.8          | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 7            | 5 | 5 | 8 |12 | 1: 1.50
    5   |  561- 570 | 7.7.8        | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 6.7          | 3.3.2        | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   |  571- 580 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 7 |13 | 1: 1.86
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |                   |           |              |              |              |              | {6.5.4.6.5   |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    6   |  581- 590 | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.6.5        | {5.4.5.4.4   | 2            | 3.4          | 6.5.4.3.7.8  | 3            | 7            | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              | {6.5.6.5.8.7 |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               7   |  591- 600 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.8          | 4.3          | 8.7          | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   |  601- 610 | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 1 | 9 | 4 |16 | 1: 4.00
    8   |  611- 620 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  621- 630 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 9.8          | 4.3          | 8.7          | 1 | 9 |   |   |
    "   |  631- 640 | 8            | 4.4.3        | 7.7.6        | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 4            | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 3 | 7 | 6 |24 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               9   |  641- 650 | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 6.7          | 3.2          | {3.2.5.3     | 7.6.5.4.8    | 3            | 8.7          | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.5.4       |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |                   |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.5.4.3.7   |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   10   |  651- 660 | 7.8          | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | {6.5.4.7.6   | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.4.8       |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |              10   |  661- 670 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 8.7          | 6 | 4 | 9 |11 | 1: 1.22
   12   |  671- 680 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 6.5.4.7.8    | 4.3          | 8.7          | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |              13   |  681- 690 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | {6.5.4       | 3.2          | 4            | 6.7.8        | 3            | {6.5.4.5     | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {6.5.7       |              |              |              |              | {6.5.8.7     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               "   |  691- 700 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 7            | 8 | 2 |12 | 8 | 1: 0.67
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |              14   |  701- 710 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | {6.5.4.5     | 2            | 3.5.4        | 8            | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {4.6.8.7     |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  711- 720 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 5.4          | 6.5.4.8      | 3            | 6.5.7        | 7 | 3 |13 | 7 | 1: 0.54
   15   |  721- 730 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
    "   |  731- 740 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 |11 | 9 | 1: 0.82
   16   |  741- 750 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 4            | 8            | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   |  751- 760 | 7.8          | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 2            | 4            | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 5 | 5 |12 | 8 | 1: 0.67
   17   |  761- 770 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 5            | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4            | 7            | 6 | 4 |   |   |
    "   |  771- 780 | 8            | 2.2.3        | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 | 9 |11 | 1: 1.22
   19   |  781- 790 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 3.4          | 7.6.5.8      | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 |   |   |
    "   |  791- 800 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 6.5.6.7      | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   |  801- 810 | 8            | 2.3          | 6            | 5            | 6.5.7        | 2            | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 |20 |10 | 1: 0.50
   20   |  811- 820 | 7.8          | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 7            | 3.3.2        | 5.4          | 8            | 2.2.3        | 7            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
    "   |  821- 830 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 4            | 8            | 2.3          | 8.7          | 6 | 4 |11 | 9 | 1: 0.82
   21   |  831- 840 | 8            | 3            | 5.4.5.6      | 5            | 7            | 2            | 4            | 6.7.8        | 3            | 8.7          | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   |  841- 850 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 3.2.4        | 8            | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 |14 | 6 | 1: 0.43
   22   |  851- 860 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 3.5.4        | 8            | 3            | 8.7          | 6 | 4 |   |   |
    "   |  861- 870 | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 4            | 8            | 3            | 8.7          | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   |  871- 880 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 2 | 8 |11 |19 | 1: 1.73
   23   |  881- 890 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 8.7          | 4 | 6 |   |   |
    "   |  891- 900 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.3.2        | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 5 | 5 | 9 |11 | 1: 1.22
   24   |  901- 910 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 8.7          | 4 | 6 |   |   |
    "   |  911- 920 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 |11 | 9 | 1: 0.82
   26   |  921- 930 | 7.8          | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 2.2.3        | 8.7          | 4 | 6 |   |   |
    "   |  931- 940 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.5.4        | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 3 | 7 | 7 |13 | 1: 1.86
   27   |  941- 950 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 1: 0.43
   28   |  951- 960 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | 5.4.7        | 2            | 5.5.4        | 8            | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1: 0.67
   29   |  961- 970 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 8.7          | 2            | 4            | 8            | 3            | 7            | 8 | 2 | 8 | 2 | 1: 0.25
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |              30   |  971- 980 | 8            | 3            | 4.3.2.6      | 5            | {6.5.4.6     | 2            | 5.5.4        | 8            | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 1: 0.43
        |           |              |              |              |              | {6.5.7       |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |              31   |  981- 990 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 6.5          | 8.7          | 2            | 4            | 8            | 3            | 7            | 8 | 2 | 8 | 2 | 1: 0.25
 August |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    2   |  991-1000 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 7            | 2            | {2.3.5.3     | 7.6.8        | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 1: 0.43
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.3.3.4     |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               3   | 1001-1010 | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 7            | 2            | 4            | 7.6.5.6.7.8  | 3            | 5.4.3.4.3.7  | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   | 1011-1020 | 8            | 2.3          | 5.6          | 3.2.3.6.5    | 7            | 2            | 5.4          | 9.8          | 2.1.3        | 7            | 4 | 6 |11 | 9 | 1: 0.82
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               4   | 1021-1030 | 7.8          | 3            | 5.4.3.7.6    | 6.5          | {6.5.6       | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | {2.2.4.2     | 8.7          | 2 | 8 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {5.6.7       |              |              |              | {4.2.3       |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               "   | 1031-1040 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 6.4.3.6.5    | 7            | 2            | 3.5.4        | 8            | 2.3          | 8.7          | 5 | 5 | 7 |13 | 1: 1.86
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               5   | 1041-1050 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 2.3.2.6.5    | 8.7          | 2            | 4            | 8            | 2.2.4.3      | {8.8.6.8.4   | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1: 0.67
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.5.8.7     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               6   | 1051-1060 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 4.2.6.5      | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 8.7          | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1: 0.67
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               7   | 1061-1070 | 8            | 3            | 5.4.3.6      | 4.5          | {6.5.6.5     | 2            | 4            | 8            | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 1: 0.43
        |           |              |              |              |              | {4.8.7       |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |               9   | 1071-1080 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 4            | 8            | 3            | 7            |10 | 0 |10 | 0 | 1: 0.00
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |  1.2.3.4.5   |              |              |              |              |              |   1.2.3.4    |   2.3.4.5    |   |   |   |   |
        |           |   5.6.7.8    |  2.3.4.5.6   |   6.7.8.9    |    5.6.7     |    1.2.3.4   |    4.5.6     |   2.3.4.5    |    1.2.3     |    5.6.7     |   6.7.8.9    |   |   |   |   |
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
   10   |    1-  10 | 6.5.7        | 3.2.6.5      | 8            | 6            | 2.4.3        | 5            | 5.4          | 2            | 7.5.2.7.6    | 8            | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1: 1.00
   11   |   11-  20 | 7            | 3.6.5        | 8            | 6            | 3            | 6.5          | 4            | 3.2          | 7.6          | 8            | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1: 0.67
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |                   |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {3.2.3.5.3   |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   12   |   21-  30 | 7            | 2.2.6.5      | 7.8          | 6            | 3            | 5            | {2.5.3.2     | 2            | 6            | 8            | 7 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 1: 0.43
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.3.2.5     |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.5.5.4     |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========

[Footnote 1: First choices correct by reason of aid from the experimenter
are not counted as correct (R) in the summary.]

[Footnote *: Aided by experimenter.]


The method of choosing the first box at the right end and then the one
next to it developed in the case of all except two of the ten settings.
The time of appearance is worth noting. In setting 1, it failed to
appear; in setting 2, it developed early,--after about one hundred
trials; in setting 3, after about one hundred and fifty trials; in
setting 4, after about one hundred and fifty trials; in setting 5, after
about one hundred and seventy trials; in setting 6, after about one
hundred trials; in setting 7, after about fifty trials; in setting 8, it
never developed; in setting 9, after about fifty trials; and in setting
10, it developed very late,--after about four hundred and seventy
trials.

This method of reaction, although inadequate, proved remarkably
persistent, and it is doubtful whether it had been wholly overcome at
the conclusion of the experiment. In the case of the series of trials
given on June 8, numbered 191 to 200, the method used was either that of
the first at the right and then the next, or direct choice of the right
box.

Throughout the trials with this problem, the end boxes, numbers 1 and 9,
were avoided. This is at least partially explained by the fact that they
never existed, and obviously never could appear, in problem 2, as right
boxes. In trials 601 to 610, given on July 7, there occurred partial
return to the formerly established method of choosing the first door at
the right. This relapse was characteristic of what happened during the
many days which intervened between the definite appearance of this habit
and the final solution of the problem.

Especially in connection with such relapses, Skirrl showed extreme
fatigue or ennui and often would refuse to work and simply sit before
the open doors yawning. This happened even when he was extremely hungry
and evidently eager enough for food.

From July 12 on the hunger motive was increased by feeding the monkey
only in the apparatus and by so regulating the amount of food given in
each trial that he should obtain barely enough to keep him in good
physical condition. An increase in the number of correct choices
promptly resulted, and continued until on July 14 the ratio of choices
was 1 to .54. It appeared from these data that a relatively small number
of choices, say not more than ten a day, the rewards in connection with
which supplied the only food received by the animal, yielded most
favorable results.

On July 16, the period of confinement in wrong boxes was increased to
sixty seconds, and it was so continued for a number of days. But in the
end, it became clear that the period of thirty seconds, combined with a
liberal reward in the shape of desired food and a single series of ten
trials per day, was most satisfactory. The detailed data of table 2
indicate that at this time Skirrl was making his choices by memory of
the particular setting.

Skirrl, on July 17 was evidently hungry and eager to locate food, but
seemingly unable to select the right box. In trial 5 (765th) of the
series, he was punished by confinement in box 8. When the doors were
unlocked in order that the entrance door might be raised to release him,
the lock-bar, sliding under the floor, made a slight grating noise, and
the instant the entrance door was opened, he jumped out excitedly. _He
made no outcry, but as soon as he was out of the box, sat down, and
taking up his right hind foot, examined it for a few seconds._ Having
apparently assured himself that nothing serious had happened, he went on
unconcernedly about his task. The presumption is that the sound of the
lock-bar, associated as it was with his painful experience in box 1,
revived the strongly affective experience of stepping on the nail.
Psychologically described, the sound induced an imaginal complex
equivalent to the earlier painful experience. The behavior seems to the
writer a most important bit of evidence of imagery in the monkey.
Finally, on August 9, after ten hundred and seventy trials, Skirrl
succeeded in choosing correctly in the ten trials of a series, and he
was therefore considered to have solved the problem of the second door
from the right end of the group.

On the following day, he was given a control series with the settings
which are presented on page 19 and also at the bottom of table 2. In
this series he chose correctly five times,--in other words, as often
correctly as incorrectly. An analysis of the choices indicates, however,
that two of the five correct choices were made in box 8, which, as it
happened, had proved a peculiarly easy one for him throughout the
training, since from the first he tended to avoid door 9. Consequently,
it is only fair to conclude, from the results for this control series
and for those given on August 11 and 12, that the animal chose not on
the basis of anything remotely resembling a general idea of secondness
from the right end, but instead on the basis of gradually acquired modes
of reaction to the particular settings. This conclusion is strengthened
by the fact that he had failed to learn to react appropriately and
readily to most of the settings of the regular series.

The curve which represents the course of the learning process in this
problem is presented in figure 19. For this and all other curves which
involve more than a single series of observations a day, the method of
construction was as follows: The first series for each day of training
is indicated on the curve by a dot, while the second or third series on
a given day, although space is allowed for them, are not so indicated.
Consequently, the form of the curve is determined chiefly by the first
series per day. The extreme irregularities of this curve are most
interesting and puzzling, as are also the variations in the daily ratios
of right to wrong first choices. Three times in the course of the
training, this ratio rose to 1 to 9, or higher. The causes for such
extreme variations are not easily enumerated, but a few of the most
obvious contributory causes are variations in the weather, especially
cloudiness or fogginess, which rendered the apparatus dark; variations
in the degree of hunger or eagerness for food; differences in the
activities of the animals in the cages outside of the laboratory
(sometimes they were noisy and distracted the subject), and finally,
differences in the physical fitness and attitude of the animal from day
to day.

The more or less incidental behavior in connection with this experiment
more strongly than the statistical results of the work on problem 2
indicate the existence of imagery. That ideas played a part in the
solution of the problem is probable, but at best they functioned very
ineffectively. The small number of methods used in the selection of the
right box, and the slight variations from the chief method, that of
choosing the first box at the right end and then the one next to it,
apparently justify Doctor Hamilton's characterization of this monkey as
defective.


[Illustration: FIGURE 19.--Error curves of learning for the solution of
problem 2 (second box from right end).]


_Problem 3. Alternately First at Left and First at Right_

Following the control series given in connection with problem 1, an
interval of rest lasting from August 12 to August 19 was allowed in
order that Skirrl might in part at least lose the effects of his
training and regain his customary interest in the apparatus by being
allowed to obtain food easily instead of by dint of hard labor,--labor
which was harder by far, apparently, than physical activity because it
demanded of the animal certain mental processes which were either
lacking or but imperfectly functional. The difficultness of the daily
tasks appears to be reliably indicated by the tendency to yawn.

Systematic work on problem 3, which has been defined as alternately the
first door at the left and the first door at the right of the group, was
begun August 19, and for nine days a single series of ten trials per day
was given. Work then had to cease because of the experimenter's return
to Cambridge.

The results of the work on this problem demand but brief analysis and
comment. The expected ratio of one right to four wrong choices per
series appears (see table 3) for the first series of trials, and _this
in spite of the fact that Skirrl had been trained for several weeks to
choose the second door from the right end_. One would ordinarily have
predicted a much larger number of incorrect choices. The right choices
were due to the monkey's strong tendency to go first to the first door
at the right and thence to the one next to it. Indeed in the series
given on August 24; this method was followed without variation. In other
words, in every one of the ten trials Skirrl entered first the box at
the extreme right end of the group. This necessarily resulted in as many
right as wrong first choices. Consequently, the ratio reads 1 to 1. But
the method was not adhered to, and at no time either before or after
that date did he succeed in equalling this achievement. There was, as a
matter of fact, no steady improvement, and so far as one may judge from
the records which were obtained, the course of events in the solution of
this problem would have been similar to those in problem 2.



TABLE 3

Results for Skirrl, _P. irus_, in Problem 3


========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========
 Date   |  No. of   |     S.1      |     S.2      |     S.3      |     S.4      |     S.5      |     S.6      |     S.7      |     S.8      |     S.9      |     S.10     | R | W | R | W |Ratio of
        |  trials   |    5.6.7     |    5.6.7     |  1.2.3.4.5.6 |  1.2.3.4.5.6 |   4.5.6.7.8  |   4.5.6.7.8  |   2.3.4.5    |   2.3.4.5    | 3.4.5.6.7.8.9| 3.4.5.6.7.8.9|   |   |   |   |R to W
________|___________|______________|______________|______________|______________|______________|______________|______________|______________|______________|______________|___|___|___|___|________
August  |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |  {6.5.4.6    |              |              |              |              |              |              |  {8.7.6.5    |   |   |   |   |
  19    |  1- 10    |     7.5      |     6.7      |  {3.2.6.4    |   5.3.6      |  {7.8.7.6    |      8       | 4.3.5.4.5.2  |      5       | 9.8.7.6.4.3  |  {4.5.8.7    | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1:4.00
        |           |              |              |  {3.6.1*     |              |  {8.6.4      |              |              |              |              |  {6.5.9*     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |  {5.4.6.5    |              |  {8.7.6.7    |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
  20    |  11- 20   |    7.6.5     |  {6.5.6.5    |  {4.6.5.3    |  5.3.2.4.6   |  {7.5.8.8    |      8       |  5.4.3.2     |     4.5      | 8.7.6.5.4.3  |  {8.7.6.8.3  | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1:9.00
        |           |              |  {7          |  {2.5.1*     |              |  {7.6.4*     |              |              |              |              |  {7.6.4.3.9  |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |  {6.2.5.6    |              |              |              |  {5.3.5.4    |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
  21    |  21- 30   |  7.6.7.6.5   |      7       |  {5.3.6.5    |  2.5.5.6     |  8.6.5.4     |      8       |  {3.5.3.5    |      5       |  {9.8.7.6    |     8.9      | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1:2.33
        |           |              |              |  {4.3.1*     |              |              |              |  {4.3.2*     |              |  {5.4.3      |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
  23    |  31- 40   |    7.6.5     |    6.5.7     |  {6.4.3.2    |    3.2.6     |  8.7.6.4     |      8       |  5.4.5.3.2   |     5.2      |    8.7.3     |      9       | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1:4.00
        |           |              |              |  {5.6.2.1    |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
  24    |  41- 50   |    7.6.5     |      7       |  {6.2.5      |      6       |  {8.7.8.7    |      8       |    5.3.2     |      5       |  {9.8.7.6    |      9       | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1:1.00
        |           |              |              |  {4.3.1      |              |  {5.7.5.4    |              |              |              |  {5.4.3      |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |  {8.7.3.6    |   |   |   |   |
  25    |  51- 60   |    7.6.5     |    6.5.7     |    5.2.1     |      6       |    8.5.4     |      8       |      2       |     2.5      |  9.8.7.4.3   |  {8.7.5.3    | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1:2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |  {8.7.9*     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
  26    |  61- 70   |    7.6.5     |    6.5.7     |      1       |    2.1.6     |   8.7.6.4    |      8       |      2       |    3.2.5     |  9.8.7.5.3   |  {3.6.8.3    | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1:2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |  {4.7.9      |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |  {8.6.3.3    |   |   |   |   |
  27    |  71- 80   |    7.6.5     |      7       |     2.1      |    1.5.6     |   8.7.6.4    |      8       |      2       |      5       |  9.8.7.6.3   |  {7.5.3.8    | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1:1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |  {3.6.9*     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
  28    |  81- 90   |   7.6.7.5    |      7       |     3.1      |      6       |    8.6.4     |     4.8      |      2       |    2.4.5     |   8.7.4.3    |    3.8.9     | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1:2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========

[Footnote *: Aided by experimenter.]






2. Sobke, _Pithecus rhesus_


_Problem 1. First at the Left End_

Sobke was somewhat afraid of the experimenter when the investigation was
undertaken, and instead of willingly coming out of his cage when the
door was raised, he often had to be coaxed out and lured into the
apparatus with food. Whereas Skirrl was frank and rather aggressive,
Sobke was stealthy in his movements, furtive, and evidently suspicious
of the experimenter as well as of the apparatus. He was perfectly safe
to approach, but would not permit anyone to touch him. After a few days,
he began to take food from the hands of the experimenter.

Preliminary work to acquaint this monkey with the routine of the
experiment was begun on April 13. As in the case of Skirrl, he was lured
into the apparatus and was taught the route through the boxes to the
starting point by being allowed to obtain food once each day in each of
the nine boxes. The procedure was simple. The entrance door and the exit
door of a particular box were raised and the animal admitted to the
reaction-compartment and permitted to pass through the box whose doors
stood open, take its food, and return to the starting point. Sobke very
quickly learned the route perfectly and came to work steadily and
rapidly. After five days of preliminary work of this sort, he was so
thoroughly accustomed to the apparatus that it was evidently desirable
to begin with regular training experiments.

The first series of trials was given on April 19. Both punishment and
reward were employed from the first. The punishment consisted of
confinement for thirty seconds in each wrong box, and the reward of a
small piece of banana, usually not more than a tenth of a medium sized
banana for each correct choice. The total time for the first series of
trials was fourteen minutes. This indicates that Sobke worked rapidly.
My notes record that he worked quickly though shyly, wasted almost no
time, made few errors of choice, and waited quietly during confinement
in the boxes. In this, also, he differed radically from Skirrl who was
restless and always tried to escape from confinement.

Throughout the work on problem 1, punishment and reward were kept
constant. Everything progressed smoothly; there were no such
irregularities of behavior as appeared in the case of Skirrl, and
consequently the description of results is a relatively simple matter.
Sobke invariably chose the end boxes. His performance was in every way
superior to that of Skirrl.

As previously, the detailed results are presented in tabular form (table
4). From this table it appears that, whereas the expected ratio of right
to wrong first choices for this problem is 1 to 2.5, the actual ratio
for Sobke's first series was 1 to .67. This surprisingly good showing is
unquestionably due to his marked tendency to choose the end box of a
group; and this tendency, in turn, may in part be the result of the
preliminary training, for during that only one box was open each time.
But, if the preliminary training were responsible for Sobke's tendency,
it should be noted that it had very different effect upon Skirrl, and,
as will be seen later, upon Julius.

The results for the ten different settings of the doors for problem 1 as
they appear in table 4 are of interest for a number of reasons. In the
first place, the setting 1. 2. 3 appearing twice,--at the beginning of
the series and again at the end--yielded markedly different results in
the two positions. For whereas no mistakes were made in the case of
setting 1, there were fifty per cent of incorrect first choices for
setting 10. Again, satisfactory explanation is impossible. It is
conceivable that fatigue or approaching satiety may have had something
to do with the failures at the end of the series, but as a rule, as is
indicated by settings 1, 2, and 6, if correct choices were made at the
beginning, they continued throughout the day's work.

In this problem, Sobke's improvement was steady and fairly rapid, and in
the eighth series, trials 71 to 80, only correct first choices appear.
Consequently, seventy trials were required for the solution of the
problem. This number is in marked contrast with Skirrl's one hundred and
thirty-two trials.

Immediately following the first perfect series, Sobke was given two
series of control tests on April 28. Conditions were unfavorable, since
the day was stormy and the rain pattering on the sheet-iron roof made a
great din. Nevertheless, he worked steadily and well up to the sixth
trial, which was preceded by a slight delay because of the necessity of
refilling some of the food boxes. After this interruption, wrong choices
occurred in trial 6. And again after trial 9, there was brief
interruption, followed by wrong choices in trial 10. The ratio of right
to wrong choices for this first control series was therefore 1 to .25.



TABLE 4

Results for Sobke, _P. rhesus_, in Problem 1


========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========
        |    No.    |     S.1      |     S.2      |     S.3      |     S.4      |     S.5      |     S.6      |     S.7      |     S.8      |     S.9      |     S.10     |   |   |   |   | Ratio
  Date  |    of     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | R | W | R | W |   of
        |  trials   |    1.2.3     |     8.9      |  3.4.5.6.7   |     7.8.9    |  2.3.4.5.6   |     6.7.8    |     5.6.7    |  4.5.6.7.8   |     7.8.9    |     1.2.3    |   |   |   |   | R to W
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
 April  |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   19   |    1-10   | 1            | 8            | 3            | 9.7          | 6.2          | 6            | 7.5          | 4            | 9.7          | 1            | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1:0.67
   20   |   11-20   | 1            | 8            | 3            | 7            | 2            | 6            | 7.5          | 8.4          | 9.9.7        | 1            | 7 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 1:0.43
   21   |   21-30   | 1            | 8            | 4.3          | 9.7          | 2            | 6            | 5            | 8.4          | 7            | 1            | 7 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 1:0.43
   22   |   31-40   | 1            | 8            | 3            | 7            | 6.2          | 6            | 6.5          | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 7 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 1:0.43
   23   |   41-50   | 1            | 8            | 3            | 7            | 2            | 6            | 5            | 4            | 9.7          | 3.1          | 8 | 2 | 8 | 2 | 1:0.25
   24   |   51-60   | 1            | 8            | 3            | 9.7          | 2            | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 2.1          | 8 | 2 | 8 | 2 | 1:0.25
   26   |   61-70   | 1            | 8            | 3            | 7            | 2            | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1 | 1:0.11
   27   |   71-80   | 1            | 8            | 3            | 7            | 2            | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 1            |10 | 0 |10 | 0 | 1:0.00
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |     2.3.4    |              |              |  1.2.3.4.5   |   |   |   |   |
        |           |    2.3.4     |  6.7.8.9     |    3.4.5     | 4.5.6.7.8.9  |   6.7.8.9    |  1.2.3.4.5   |   5.6.7.8    | 3.4.5.6.7.8  |    5.6.7     |   6.7.8.9    |   |   |   |   |
        |           +--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+   |   |   |   |
   28   |    1-10   | 2            | 6            | 3            | 4            | 6            | 5.4.1        | 2            | 3            | 5            | 5.4.2.1      | 8 | 2 |   |   |
    "   |   11-20   | 2            | 6            | 3            | 4            | 6            | 2.1          | 2            | 3            | 5            | 1            | 9 | 1 |17 | 3 | 1:0.18
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========



Six minutes after completion of the first control series, a second was
given under slightly more favorable conditions, and in this only a
single wrong choice occurred, in that box 2 was first chosen in trial 6
instead of box 1. From the results of these two control series, it is
evident that Sobke's solution of problem 1 is reasonably adequate. He is
easily diverted or disturbed in his work by any unusual circumstances,
but so long as everything goes smoothly, he chooses with ease and
certainty. Whether it is fair to describe the behavior as involving an
idea of the relation of the right box to the other members of the group
would be difficult to decide. I hesitate to infer definite ideation from
the available evidence, but I strongly suspect the presence of images
and relatively ineffective or inadequate ideation.

It is perfectly evident that Sobke is much more intelligent than Skirrl.
In practically every respect, he adapted himself more quickly to the
experimental procedure and progressed more steadily toward the solution
of the problem than did Skirrl. The contrast in the learning processes
of the two monkeys could scarcely be better exhibited than by the curves
of learning which are presented in figure 18. The first, that for Sobke,
is surprisingly regular; the second, that for Skirrl, is quite as
surprisingly irregular. These results correlate perfectly with the
steadiness and predictability of the former's responses and the
irregularity and erraticness of the latter's.


_Problem 2. Second from the Right End_

On the completion of problem 1 Sobke was in perfect condition, as to
health and training, for experimental work. He had come to work quietly,
fairly deliberately, and very steadily. His timidity had diminished and
he would readily come to the experimenter for food, although still he
was somewhat distrustful at times and became timid when anything unusual
occurred in the apparatus.

As preparation for problem 2, a break in regular experimentation
covering four days followed the control series of problem 1. On each of
these four days the monkey was allowed to get food once from each of the
nine boxes, both doors of a given box being open for the trial and all
other doors closed. For this feeding experiment, the doors were opened
in irregular order, and this order was changed from day to day.

Systematic work with problem 2 began on May 3, with punishment of thirty
seconds for mistakes and a liberal reward of food for each success.
Early in the series of trials it was discovered that Sobke was likely to
become discouraged and waste a great deal of time unless certain aid
were given by the experimenter. On this account, after the first two
trials, the method was adopted of punishing the animal by confinement
for the first ten mistakes in a trial, and of then, if need be,
indicating the right box by slightly and momentarily raising the exit
door. Every trial in which aid was thus given by the experimenter is
indicated in table 5 by an asterisk following the last choice. In the
first series of trials for this problem, aid had to be given in seven of
the ten trials, and even so the series occupied seventy-one minutes. It
is possible that had no aid been given, the work might have been
continued successfully with a smaller number of trials than ten per day.
But under the circumstances it seemed wiser to avoid the risk of
discouraging and thus spoiling the animal for use in the experiment. It
should be stated, also, that it proved impossible to adhere to the
period of thirty seconds as punishment in this series. For the majority
of the wrong choices confinement of not more than ten seconds was used.

For the second series, given on May 4, the conditions were unfavorable
in that it was dark and rainy, and the noise of the rain on the roof
frightened Sobke. He refused to work after the fourth trial, and the
series had to be completed on the following day. The total time required
for this series was seventy-eight minutes.

The work on May 6 was distinctly better, and the animal's behavior
indicated, in a number of trials, definite recognition of the right
door. He might, for example, make a number of incorrect choices, then
pause for a few seconds to look steadily at the doors, and having
apparently found some cue, run directly to the right box. No aid from
the experimenter was needed in this series.

On the following day improvement continued and the animal's method of
choosing became definite and fairly precise. He was deliberate, quiet,
and extremely business-like. The time for the series was thirty-one
minutes.

The period of punishment was increased on May 12 to thirty seconds.
Previously, for the greater number of the trials, it had been ten to
fifteen seconds. This increase apparently did not disturb the monkey,
for he continued to work perfectly throughout the series, although
making many mistakes in spite of deliberate choices and the refusal of
certain boxes in each trial.

An interesting and significant incident occurred on May 13 when at the
conclusion of trial 5, Doctor Hamilton came into the experiment room for
a few minutes. Sobke immediately stopped working, and he could not be
induced to make any choices until Doctor Hamilton had left the room.
This well indicates his sensitiveness to his surroundings, and his
inclination to timidity or nervousness even in the presence of
conditions not in themselves startling.

Work was continued thus steadily until May 28 when, because of the
failure of the animal to improve, it seemed wise to increase the period
of confinement as punishment to sixty seconds. In the meantime, it had
sometimes been evident that Sobke was near to the solution of his
problem. He would often make correct choices in three or four trials in
succession and then apparently lose his cue and fail utterly for a
number of trials.

After June 1, in order to hasten the solution of the problem, two series
per day were given. In some instances the second series was given almost
immediately after the first, while in others an interval of an hour or
more intervened. It was further found desirable to give Sobke all of his
food in the apparatus. When the rewards obtained in the several trials
did not satisfy his hunger, additional food was presented, on the
completion of the series of experiments, in one or more of the food
cups. On days marked by unwillingness or refusal to work, very little
food was given. Thus, the eagerness of the monkey to locate the right
box was increased and, as a matter of observation, his deliberateness
and care in choice increased correspondingly. Sixty seconds punishment
was found satisfactory, and it was therefore continued throughout the
work on this problem.

It was evident, on June 9, from the behavior of the monkey as well as
from the score, that the perfect solution of the problem was near at
hand. This fact the experimenter recorded in his daily notes, and sure
enough, on the following day Sobke chose correctly throughout the series
of ten trials. The time for this series was only ten minutes. The
choices were made deliberately and readily.

An analysis of the data of table 5 reveals five methods or reactive
tendencies which appeared more or less definitely in the following
order: (a) Choice of first box at the left, because of experience in
problem 1. This tendency was very quickly suppressed by the requirements
in connection with problem 2. Indeed one of the most significant
differences which I have discovered between the behavior of the primates
and that of other mammals is the time required for the suppression of
such an acquired tendency. The monkey seems to learn almost immediately
that it is not worth while to persist in a tendency which although
previously profitable no longer yields satisfaction, whereas in the
crow, pig, rat, and ring dove, the unprofitable mode of response tends
to persist during a relatively large number of trials. (b) The tendency
to choose, first, a box near the left end of the group, to go from that
to the box at the extreme right end of the group, thence to the one next
in order, which was, of course, the right box. This tendency appears
fairly clearly from May 7th on. (c) The box at the extreme right was
first chosen and then the one next to it. For example, in setting 2, box
4 would be chosen first, then box 3. Or, if this did not occur, the
method previously described under (b) was likely to be employed, as for
example, in setting 8, where such choices as 7.6.5.1.8 appear. (d) In
certain series there appeared a marked preference for a particular box,
usually box 3 (see results for May 24). This was doubtless due in a
measure, if not wholly, to the fact that box 3 was the right box twice
in each series of ten settings. But it should be added that the same is
true of box 7, for which no preference was manifested at any time. (e)
Direct choice of the right box.

The five reactive methods or tendencies enumerated above roughly
appeared in the order named, but there were certain irregularities and
the order as well as the time of appearance varied somewhat from setting
to setting. In general, method c was the most frequently used prior to
the development of method e, the direct choice of the right box.



TABLE 5

Results for Sobke, _P. rhesus_, in Problem 2


========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========
        |    No.    |     S.1      |     S.2      |     S.3      |     S.4      |     S.5      |     S.6      |     S.7      |     S.8      |     S.9      |     S.10     |   |   |   |   | Ratio
  Date  |    of     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |  1.2.3.4.5   |              |              | R | W | R | W |   of
        |  trials   |    7.8.9     |   1.2.3.4    | 2.3.4.5.6.7  | 1.2.3.4.5.6  |  4.5.6.7.8   |     1.2.3    |   2.3.4.5    |   6.7.8.9    |   1.2.3.4    | 3.4.5.6.7.8  |   |   |   |   | R to W
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   May  |           | {7.7.9.7.7   | {1.2.4.1     | {3.2.7.2     | {4.6.1.6     |              | {3.1.3.3     |              |              | {4.1.4.1     | {3.8.3.3     |   |   |   |   |
    3   |    1-10   | {9.7.9.7.9   | {1.4.1.1     | {7.7.7.5     | {1.6.1.1     | 5.8.6.7      | {3.3.1.1     | 3.5.4        | 9.1.8        | {4.1.4.2     | {3.8.6.3     | 0 |10 | 0 |10 | 0:10.00
        |           | {7.9.9.7.8*  | {4.3*        | {2.7.6*      | {1.3.5*      |              | {1.1.2*      |              |              | {1.4.3*      | {8.3.7*      |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              | {4.7.2.7     |              | (8.8.4.8     |              | {5.5.5.5     | {9.5.5.9     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
4 and 5 |   11-20   | (7.9.7.9.9   | 1.4.1.3      | {2.7.3.2     | 1.6.5        | {8.8.4.8     | {3.3.1.1.3   | {5.5.5.3     | {7.1.6.6     | {4.4.4.4     | {8.8.6.8     | 0 |10 | 0 |10 | 0:10.00
        |           | {9.7.7.9.8   |              | {7.2.6*      |              | {4.8.7*      | {3.3.1.2     | {5.5.4*      | {6.5.8*      | {4.4.4.3     | {8.7         |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    6   |   21-30   | 9.7.9.7.8    | 4.3          | 7.2.3.7.6    | {6.3.1.6     | 6.8.7        | 3.1.2        | {5.3.5.3     | {6.9.4.6.1   | {4.1.2.4     | {3.4.5.3     | 0 |10 | 0 |10 | 0:10.00
        |           |              |              |              | {6.2.6.5     |              |              | {2.4         | {7.9.7.8     | {4.2.3       | {8.6.7       |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    7   |   31-40   | 7.9.7.8      | 1.4.3        | 2.7.6        | 3.5          | 4.8.7        | 3.1.2        | 3.2.3.5.4    | 8            | 4.3          | 5.8.3.4.8.7  | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
    8   |   41-50   | 7.9.7.8      | (4.2.4.1.4   | 6            | 5            | 6.5.4.8.7    | {3.1.3.1     | 5.3.5.4      | {7.4.2.1     | {4.2.4.1     | 5.3.8.7      | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              | {4.2.2.4.3   |              |              |              | {3.1.3.2     |              | {9.8         | {4.3         |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.3.5.3     |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   10   |   51-60   | 7.7.8        | 3            | 7.3.2.7.6    | 6.4.6.5      | (6.4.8.5     | 3.1.3.2      | {2.5.3.5     | 5.9.8        | 4.2.4.3      | {6.5.4       | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
        |           |              |              |              |              | {4.8.7       |              | {2.5.4       |              |              | {3.8.7       |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   11   |   61-70   | 7.9.7.8      | 1.4.3        | 4.3.2.7.6    | 6.5          | {5.4.8.6     | 3.2          | 5.4          | 6.5.2.3.1.8  | 3            | 6.5.3.8.7    | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
        |           |              |              |              |              | {5.4.8.7     |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   12   |   71-80   | 7.9.8        | 3            | 7.3.2.7.6    | 6.5          | 5.4.8.7      | 1.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 5.4.3.8.7    | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
   13   |   81-90   | 7.8          | 4.3          | 3.7.6        | 6.5          | 8.7          | 1.3.2        | 2.5.2.5.4    | 7.6.5.9.8    | 3            | 8.7          | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {1.2.1.2.2   |              |   |   |   |   |
   14   |   91-100  | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 5            | 6.5.4.7      | 1.3.2        | 5.4          | 9.8          | {1.4.2.2.1   | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {4.1.4.3     |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   15   |  101-110  | 7.8          | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 5.4.5.7      | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 2.1.3        | 8.8.7        | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   17   |  111-120  | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | {2.1.2.1.2   | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.6.5.1.8    | 3            | 8.7          | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
        |           |              |              |              | {1.3.2.6.5   |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   18   |  121-130  | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.6.5.2.8    | 3            | 8.7          | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.3.2.5.3   |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.5.2.5.3   |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   19   |  131-140  | 8            | 3            | 3.2.6        | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | {5.5.2.5.5   | 7.6.9.8      | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1: 0.67
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {3.2.5.5.3   |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.5.5.4     |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   20   |  141-150  | 7.8          | 3            | 3.2.7.6      | 6.5          | 5.4.7        | 3.2          | 3.2.5.4      | 6.5.4.3.8    | 3            | 7            | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
   21   |  151-160  | 7.8          | 3            | 5.7.5.3.7.6  | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 5.3.5.2.5.4  | 7.6.5.9.8    | 3            | 6.4.3.8.7    | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   22   |  161-170  | 7.8          | 3            | 7.6          | 3.2.6.5      | 7            | 3.2          | {5.2.5.3     | 7.6.5.8      | 3            | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.5.4       |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {3.1.3       |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   24   |  171-180  | 8            | 3            | {3.2.7.5     | {3.6.4       | 8.7          | {1.3.3       | {3.5.4       | 8            | {4.4.2.1     | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              | {7.3.6       | {3.6.5       |              | {3.2         |              |              | {4.3         |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   25   |  181-190  | 7.9.7.9.8    | 3            | 3.7.6        | 5            | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 4.3.8        | 4.3          | 8.7          | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
   26   |  191-200  | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1: 1.00
   27   |  201-210  | 7.9.8        | 3            | 3.2.7.6      | 5            | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 8.7          | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
   28   |  211-220  | 8            | 3            | 3.7.6        | 4.3.2.6.5    | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.6.5.9.8    | 3            | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
   29   |  221-230  | 7.8          | 3            | 5.4.3.7.6    | 6.5          | 7            | 2            | 3.2.5.4      | 7.6.5.8      | 3            | 3.8.7        | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
   31   |  231-240  | 7.7.8        | 3            | 3.7.6        | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 9.8          | 3            | 3.7          | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
  June  |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    1   |  241-250  | 8            | 3            | 5.4.7.6      | 3.2.6.5      | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 8.7          | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  251-260  | 7.9.8        | 3            | 3.7.6        | 5            | 6.5.4.8.7    | 3.2          | 4            | 5.4.3.8      | {4.2.1.4     | 7            | 4 | 6 | 8 |12 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.4.4.3     |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    2   |  261-270  | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 3.2.6.5      | 7            | 3.2          | 3.4          | 8            | 3            | 6.5.3.8.7    | 5 | 5 |   |   |
    "   |  271-280  | 7.8          | 3            | 3.7.6        | 3.6.5        | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.6.5.4.3.8  | 3            | 7            | 4 | 6 | 9 |11 | 1: 1.22
    3   |  281-290  | 7.8          | 3            | 7.6          | 3.6.5        | 8.7          | 3.2          | 4            | 7.8          | 3            | 7            | 4 | 6 |   |   |
    "   |  291-300  | 9.8          | 3            | 3.6          | 4.3.6.5      | 8.7          | 2            | 3.5.4        | 7.6.5.9.8    | 3            | 8.7          | 3 | 7 | 7 |13 | 1: 1.86
    4   |  301-310  | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 3.4.3.6.5    | 8.7          | 2            | 3.2.5.4      | 7.6.5.8      | 3            | 3.8.7        | 4 | 6 |   |   |
    "   |  311-320  | 8            | 3            | 5.4.7.6      | 3.2.6.5      | 7            | 2            | 3.2.5.4      | 8            | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 |11 | 9 | 1: 0.82
    5   |  321-330  | 8            | 3            | 6            | 4.6.5        | 7            | 2            | 3.5.4        | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   |  331-340  | 8            | 3            | 7.4.7.6      | 3.2.4.6.5    | 7            | 3.2          | 3.5.4        | 8            | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 |13 | 7 | 1: 0.54
    7   |  341-350  | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 8.7          | 1.3.1.2      | 3.5.4        | 8            | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 |   |   |
    "   |  351-360  | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 8.7          | 2            | 3.5.4        | 8            | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 |13 | 7 | 1: 0.54
    8   |  361-370  | 7.8          | 3            | 4.7.6        | 3.5          | 8.7          | 2            | 3.4          | 9.8          | 3            | 7            | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |  371-380  | 8            | 3            | 7.6          | 3.4.4.3.5    | 8.7          | 3.2          | 3.4          | 8            | 3            | 7            | 5 | 5 | 9 |11 | 1: 1.22
    9   |  381-390  | 8            | 3            | 6            | 4.2.1.5      | 7            | 2            | 3.4          | 8            | 3            | 8.7          | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   |  391-400  | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 3.4          | 8            | 3            | 7            | 9 | 1 |16 | 4 | 1: 0.25
   10   |  401-410  | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 4            | 8            | 3            | 7            |10 | 0 |10 | 0 | 1: 0.00
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |  1.2.3.4.5   |              |              |              |              |              |   1.2.3.4    |    2.3.4.5   |   |   |   |   |
        |           |    5.6.7.8   |  2.3.4.5.6   |   6.7.8.9    |    5.6.7     |    1.2.3.4   |     4.5.6    |    2.3.4.5   |     1.2.3    |    5.6.7     |    6.7.8.9   |   |   |   |   |
        |           +--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
   11   |    1-10   | 6.7          | 3.5          | 8            | 6            | 3            | 5            | 3.4          | 3.2          | 7.7.2.6      | 8            | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1: 1.00
   12   |   11-20   | 7            | 3.6.6.2.5    | 8            | 6            | 3            | 4.5          | 4            | 2            | 7.6          | 8            | 7 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 1: 0.43
========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========

[Footnote *: Aided by experimenter.]



Examination of table 5 indicates that some of the settings proved very
easy for Sobke; others, extremely difficult. Consequently, the number of
methods which were tried and rejected for a given setting varies from
two to five. Setting 2 proved a fairly simple one, and after the
inhibition of the tendency to choose the first box at the left, the only
definite tendency to appear was that of choosing the first box at the
right, and then the one next to it. After one hundred and thirty trials,
this method suddenly gave place to direct choice of the right box, and
during the following twenty-eight series, no error occurred for this
setting. Setting 4, on the contrary, proved extremely difficult, and a
variety of methods is more or less definitely indicated by the records.

It is needless to lengthen the description by analyzing the data for
each setting, since the reader by carefully scanning the columns of data
in table 5 may observe for himself the various tendencies and their
mutual relations.

Sobke's curve of learning (figure 19) in problem 2, is extremely
irregular, as was that of Skirrl. Similar irregularities appear in the
daily ratios of right to wrong first choices presented in the last
column of table 5. Most of these irregularities were due, I have
discovered, to unfavorable external conditions. Thus, dark rainy days
and disturbing noises outside the laboratory were obviously conditions
of poor work.

On the day following the final and correct series for problem 2, a
control series was given. In this Sobke seemed greatly surprised by the
new situations which presented themselves. Repeatedly he exhibited
impulses to enter the box which would have been the correct one in the
regular series of settings. He frequently inhibited such impulses and
chose correctly, but at other times he reacted quickly and made
mistakes. It was evident from his behavior that he was not guided by
anything like a definite idea of the relation of the right box to the
other members of the group.

In a second control series given on the following day, June 12,
confusion appeared, but less markedly. For the first setting, a correct
choice was made with deliberation. For the second setting, box 3 was
immediately chosen, as should have been the case in the regular series
of settings. Sobke seemed confused when he emerged from this box and had
difficulty in locating the right one. Then followed direct correct
choices for settings 3, 4, and 5. For setting 6, there is recorded a
deliberately made wrong choice, and so on throughout the series, the
choices being characterized by deliberateness and definite search for
the right box. Uncertainty was plainly indicated, and in this the
behavior of the animal differed markedly from that in the concluding
series of the regular experiment.

It seems safe to conclude from the results of these control series that
Sobke has no free idea of the relation of secondness from the right and
is chiefly dependent upon memory of the particular settings for cues
which lead to correct choice.


_Problem 3. Alternately First at Left and First at Right_

For four successive days after the last control series in connection
with problem 2, Sobke was merely fed in the apparatus according to
previous description (p. 43). He exhibited a wonderfully keen appetite
and was well fed during this interval between problems.

The method of experimentation chosen for problem 3 in the light of
previous experience was that of confining the monkey for a short time,
ten to fifteen seconds, in the wrong box, in each of the first ten
mistakes for a given trial, and of then aiding him to find the right box
by the slight and momentary raising of the exit door. Aid proved
necessary in a few of the trials during the first four days. Then he
worked independently. As work progressed it was found possible and also
desirable to increase the period of confinement, and in the end, sixty
seconds proved satisfactory. It was also thought desirable to increase
the number of trials per day from a single series during the early days
to two or even three series from June 29 on. Often three series could be
given in succession without difficulty. During the early trials on this
problem Sobke worked remarkably well, but later his willingness
diminished, evidently because of his failure readily to solve the
problem, and it became extremely difficult to coax him into the
apparatus. On days when he entered only reluctantly and as it seemed
against his will, he was likely to be nervous, erratic, and often slow
in making his choices, but above all he tended to waste time by not
returning to the starting point, preferring rather to loiter in the
alleyways or run back and forth.



TABLE 6

Results for Sobke, _P. rhesus_, in Problem 3


========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========
        |    No.    |     S.1      |     S.2      |     S.3      |     S.4      |     S.5      |     S.6      |     S.7      |     S.8      |     S.9      |     S.10     |   |   |   |   | Ratio
  Date  |    of     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   3.4.5.6    |    3.4.5.6   | R | W | R | W |   of
        |  trials   |    5.6.7     |    5.6.7     | 1.2.3.4.5.6  | 1.2.3.4.5.6  |  4.5.6.7.8   |  4.5.6.7.8   |   2.3.4.5    |   2.3.4.5    |    7.8.9     |     7.8.9    |   |   |   |   | R to W
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
  June  |           |              |              |              | {3.1.2.1     | {7.8.7.8     |              |              |              | {9.8.7.9     |              |   |   |   |   |
   17   |   1--10   | {6.6.7.6     | 5.7          | {4.4.3.5.4   | {4.4.2.1     | {8.8.7.8     | 8            | 2            | 3.2.5        | {8.7.6.9     | 3.8.9        | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1:4.00
        |           | {6.5         |              | {5.4.2.1     | {5.4.6*      | {7.7.4*      |              |              |              | {8.7.3*      |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              | {3.4.2.5     |              | {8.7.7.5     |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   18   |  11--20   | 6.6.6.5      | 5.7          | {4.5.6.4     | 3.1.4.3.6    | {8.8.7.8     | 8            | 3.2          | (3.4.2.4     | 9.8.8.7.3    | 8.6.9        | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1:9.00
        |           |              |              | {2.3.1*      |              | {7.8.4*      |              |              | {4.5         |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              | {3.6.5.4     |              | {8.8.7.7     |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   19   |  21--30   | 6.5          | 7            | {2.5.2.6     | 3.6          | {7.8.8.8     | 8            | 4.3.2        | {3.2.4.2     | {9.8.7.9.7   | 9            | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1:2.33
        |           |              |              | {3.5.1*      |              | {8.4         |              |              | {2.5         | {6.5.4.3     |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | (8.8.8.8     |              |              |              | {9.9.8.9     |              |   |   |   |   |
   21   |  31--40   | 6.5          | 5.6.5.7      | {3.5.4.6     | 2.5.3.6      | {7.8.3.8     | 8            | 4.2          | 2.5          | {9.5.9.9     | 9            | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1:4.00
        |           |              |              | {4.3.5.1     |              | {8.7.4*      |              |              |              | {9.9.3*      |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   22   |  41--50   | 7.6.5        | 6.5.5.7      | 1            | 2.1.3.6      | {8.8.8.8     | 8            | 2            | 2.3.2.2.5    | {9.8.9.8.7   | 9            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1:1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              | {7.8.4       |              |              |              | {6.5.9.3     |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   23   |  51--60   | 5            | 6.5.7        | 1            | {1.2.1.1     | 8.5.4        | 8            | 5.4.2        | 2.4.2.5      | {9.8.4.9     | 9            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1:1.50
        |           |              |              |              | {3.2.6       |              |              |              |              | {7.3         |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   24   |  61--70   | 7.6.5        | 7            | 2.3.1        | 2.1.5.4.2.6  | 8.7.8.4      | 8            | 4.5.4.3.2    | 2.2.4.5      | 9.7.6.8.3    | 9            | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1:2.33
   25   |  71--80   | 6.5          | 5.7          | 3.1          | 6            | 8.5.4        | 8            | 2            | 3.2.5        | 9.8.7.3      | 3.9          | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1:2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   26   |  81--90   | 7.7.6.5      | 6.5.7        | 3.1          | {1.4.1.1     | 8.4          | 8            | 5.4.2        | 2.5          | 9.8.9.6.3    | 9            | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1:4.00
        |           |              |              |              | {5.1.6       |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   28   |  91--100  | 7.6.5        | 7            | 1            | 1.2.4.6      | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 3.2.2.2.5    | 9.8.8.7.9.3  | 9            | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1:1.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   29   | 101--110  | 7.6.5        | 5.7          | 1            | {1.1.5.3     | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 4.2.5        | {9.9.8.9.4   | 9            | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              | {2.1.6       |              |              |              |              | {9.7.6.3     |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   | 111--120  | 6.5          | 6.5.7        | 1            | 2.1.1.3.6    | 8.5.4        | 8            | 2            | 3.2.5        | 9.8.7.6.4.3  | 9            | 4 | 6 | 8 |12 | 1:1.50
   30   | 121--130  | 5            | 6.5.6.5.5.7  | 1            | 3.1.6        | 8.7.6.8.5.4  | 8            | 2            | 4.2.4.2.5    | 9.3          | 9            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
    "   | 131--140  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 2.3.6        | 8.5.6.4      | 8            | 2            | 5            | 9.8.3        | 3.9          | 6 | 4 |11 | 9 | 1:0.82
  July  |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    1   | 141--150  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 1.6          | 8.7.4        | 8            | 2            | 3.2.5        | 9.8.6.9.3    | 9            | 6 | 4 |   |   |
    "   | 151--160  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 2.5.3.6      | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 2.5          | 9.3          | 8.8.7.5.4.9  | 5 | 5 |11 | 9 | 1:0.82
    2   | 161--170  | 6.5          | 7            | 1            | 2.6          | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 3.5          | 9.3          | 9            | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1:1.00
    3   | 171--180  | 6.5          | 7            | 1            | 1.5.6        | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 3.5          | 9.3          | 9            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
    "   | 181--190  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 4.6          | 8.6.4        | 8            | 2            | 5            | 9.8.4.8.5.3  | 9            | 7 | 3 |12 | 8 | 1:0.67
    5   | 191--200  | 6.5          | 5.7          | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 5            | 9.5.3        | 9            | 6 | 4 |   |   |
    "   | 201--210  | 5            | 7            | 6.1          | 2.6          | 8.6.4        | 8            | 5.3.5.4.3.2  | 4.3.5        | 9.7.3        | 9            | 4 | 6 |10 |10 | 1:1.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    6   | 211--220  | 5            | 5.7          | 1            | 2.6          | 8.6.4        | 8            | 2            | 4.3.5        | 9.3          | {5.4.8.3     | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {8.5.4.9     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   | 221--230  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 5.3.6        | 8.6.8.4      | 8            | 4.2          | 3.2.5        | 9.3          | 9            | 5 | 5 | 9 |11 | 1:1.22
    7   | 231--240  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 2.6          | 8.4          | 7.4.8        | 2            | 4.3.5        | 8.3          | 9            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
    "   | 241--250  | 5            | 7            | 2.6.3.5.1    | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 5            | 9.3          | 9            | 7 | 3 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              | {2.6.2.6.4   |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   | 251--260  | 5            | 7            | {6.3.2.6     | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 5            | 9.5.3        | 9            | 7 | 3 |19 |11 | 1:0.58
        |           |              |              | {5.4.3.1     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    8   | 261--270  | 7.5          | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 5.2          | 5            | 8.3          | 8.5.4.9      | 5 | 5 |   |   |
    "   | 271--280  | 5            | 7            | 2.6.4.6.1    | 6            | 8.5.8.4      | 7.4.8        | 5.5.3.5.2    | 5            | 9.3          | 9            | 5 | 5 |10 |10 | 1:1.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    9   | 281--290  | 5            | 5.7          | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 2.5          | 8.3          | {7.3.8.6.8   | 5 | 5 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {4.7.3.9     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   | 291--300  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 5            | 9.3          | 9            | 8 | 2 |   |   |
    "   | 301--310  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 5.2          | 5            | 9.5.3        | 9            | 7 | 3 |20 |10 | 1:0.50
   10   | 311--320  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 7.4.8        | 2            | 5            | 9.3          | 9            | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   | 321--330  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 5.2.6        | 8.7.4        | 8            | 2            | 5            | 9.3          | 9            | 7 | 3 |14 | 6 | 1:0.43
   12   | 331--340  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 5            | 8.3          | 9            | 8 | 2 |   |   |
    "   | 341--350  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 5.2          | 5            | 9.3          | 9            | 7 | 3 |15 | 5 | 1:0.33
   13   | 351--360  | 5            | 5.7          | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 5.2          | 5            | 3            | 9            | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   | 361--370  | 5            | 7            | 6.1          | 6            | 4            | 8            | 5.2          | 3.2.5        | 9.3          | 9            | 6 | 4 |13 | 7 | 1:0.54
   14   | 371--380  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 5            | 3            | 7.4.3.9      | 8 | 2 |   |   |
    "   | 381--390  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 5            | 9.3          | 4.7.3.9      | 7 | 3 |15 | 5 | 1:0.33
   15   | 391--400  | 5            | 5.5.7        | 1            | 3.6          | 8.4          | 8            | 3.2          | 5            | 8.3          | 9            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
    "   | 401--410  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 5            | 7.3          | 6.5.3.9      | 7 | 3 |12 | 8 | 1:0.67
   16   | 411--420  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 5            | 3            | 9            | 9 | 1 |   |   |
    "   | 421--430  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 4            | 8            | 2            | 5            | 3            | 4.7.4.9      | 9 | 1 |   |   |
    "   | 431--440  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 5            | 3            | 5.7.3.9      | 8 | 2 |26 | 4 | 1:0.15
   17   | 441--450  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 4            | 4.8          | 2            | 5            | 4.3          | 3.5.9        | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   | 451--460  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 3.6          | 4            | 5.4.8        | 2            | 5            | 9.3          | 9            | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   | 461--470  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 4            | 8            | 2            | 5            | 3            | 9            |10 | 0 |24 | 6 | 1:0.25
   19   | 471--480  | 5            | 7            | 1            | 6            | 8.4          | 8            | 2            | 5            | 3            | 9            | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1 | 1:0.11
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |      5.6     |     5.6      | 4.5.6.7.8.9  | 4.5.6.7.8.9  |  1.2.3.4.5   |  1.2.3.4.5   | 2.3.4.5.6.7  | 2.3.4.5.6.7  | 3.4.5.6.7.8  | 3.4.5.6.7.8  |   |   |   |   |
        |           +--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
   19   |   1--10   | 5            | 6            | 4            | 9            | 1            | 5            | 3.7.2        | 7            | 3            | 8            | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1 | 1:0.11
========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========

[Footnote *: Aided by experimenter.]



The data of table 6 indicate for this problem only three pronounced
reactive tendencies: (a) As the initial tendency, the choice of the
second box from the right end. This proved surprisingly weak, in view of
the animal's long training on problem 2, and it disappeared quickly. (b)
Choice of the end boxes, and (c) direct choice of the right box.

For this, as for the other problems, extreme differences in method and
in time and degree of success appear for the different settings. Thus,
while settings 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, and 10 proved to be easy, settings 4, 5,
8, and 9 were evidently more difficult.

[Illustration: FIGURE 20.--Error curve of learning for the solution of
problem 3 (alternately the first box at the left end and the first at
the right end) by Sobke.]

From the first this problem promised to be much easier for Sobke than
problem 2, and although the actual number of trials necessary for the
solution is greater by sixty for problem 3 than for problem 2,
comparison of the data of the tables justifies the statement that the
third problem was both easier and more nearly adequately solved than the
second. This is not surprising when the nature of the two problems is
considered, for whereas problem 2 requires choice by perception of the
relationship of secondness from the right end of the group, problem 3
requires, instead, the choice of the end member of the group each time,
with the additional variation of alternation of ends. Now as it happens,
the end member is easily selected by the monkey, and it appears further
that alternation was relatively easy for Sobke to acquire. Consequently,
the combination of end and alternation proved easier than the choice of
the second from the right end of the group.

The above statements are supported by comparison of the curves of
learning. The curve for problem 2, figure 19, is extremely irregular;
that for problem 3, figure 20, much more regular. Similarly, the daily
ratios of right to wrong choices as exhibited in tables 5 and 6 indicate
smaller variations for the third problem than for the second.

Sobke made ten correct first choices in the third series for July 17,
but he was working very uncertainly and it seemed rather a matter of
good luck than good management that he succeeded in presenting this
perfect series: For this reason and also because it did not seem
feasible to have Sunday intervene between the final and perfect regular
series and the control series, an additional regular series was given on
July 19, in which, as the table indicates, a single mistake occurred, in
trial 5. The monkey was working perfectly. The series of trials required
only ten minutes, and it was evident that carelessness and eagerness to
obtain food were chiefly responsible for the mistake.

The control series given on July 19 immediately after the series just
described resulted similarly in one failure and nine successes. The
choices were made easily and with certainty, and the only mistake, that
of setting 7, was apparently due to carelessness.

This excellent showing for the control series wholly justifies the
comparison of problems 2 and 3 as to difficultness, made above. Whereas
in both problems 1 and 2 the control trials caused confusion, in the
case of problem 3, they did not essentially alter the behavior of the
animal. The fact seems to be that for this problem the particular
setting is of relatively little importance; while turning alternately to
the extreme left and the extreme right is of prime importance. That
Sobke had the idea of alternation or of the end box, there seems no more
reason for insisting than that he had the idea of secondness from the
right end in problem 2. It is possible, even probable, that these ideas
existed rather vaguely in his consciousness, but there is obviously no
necessity for insisting that the solution of the problems depended upon
them.


_Problem 4. Middle_

As the available time for the continuation of the experiment was
limited, it was decided to proceed with work on problem 4 immediately
upon the completion of problem 3, and on July 20, the problem of the
middle door was presented to Sobke. Since it was anticipated that this
sudden change would confuse and discourage him greatly, the only form of
punishment administered was the momentary lowering of the entrance door
of the wrong box. As in the previous problem, he was aided after ten
successive wrong choices. As might have been anticipated, he
persistently entered the end boxes of the groups, and this in some
instances probably would have been kept up for many minutes had not the
experimenter lured him into the right box by slightly raising the exit
door. In the first series, he had to be aided in five of the ten trials.
The total time for the series was forty-five minutes, the total number
of choices, eighty-eight. In the second series, he was aided in four of
the trials. The total time required was seventy-two minutes, and the
total number of choices was seventy-six.

Throughout the first series, Sobke worked hard, but with evidently
increasing dissatisfaction. He clung persistently to his acquired
tendency to choose the end boxes, and after each trial he returned less
willingly to the starting point. Up to this time his attitude toward the
experimenter had been perfectly friendly, if not wholly trustful. But
when on July 21 he was brought into the apparatus for the second series,
he exhibited a wholly new form of behavior, for instead of attending
diligently to the open doors and devoting his energies to trying to find
the right box, he instead, after gazing at them for a few seconds,
turned toward the experimenter and jumped for him savagely, throwing
himself against the wire netting with great force. This was repeated a
number of times during the first two or three trials, and it occurred
less frequently later in the series. Since nothing unusual had happened
outside of the experiment room, the suggested explanation of this sudden
change in attitude and behavior is that the monkey resented and blamed
on the experimenter the difficulty which he was having in obtaining
food.

From this time on until the end of my work, Sobke was always savage and
both in and out of the apparatus he was constantly on the watch for an
opportunity to spring upon me. Previously, it had been possible for me
to coax him into the apparatus by offering him food and to return him to
his cage by walking after him. But on and after the twenty-first of
July, it was impossible for me to approach him without extreme risk of
being bitten.

Doctor Hamilton when told of this behavior, reported that several times
monkeys have shown resentment toward him when they were having trouble
in the experiment. I therefore feel fairly confident that I have not
misinterpreted Sobke's behavior. When on July 22 I gave Sobke an
opportunity to enter the apparatus, he refused, and it was impossible to
lure him in with food. Two hours later, having waited meantime for his
breakfast, he entered readily and worked steadily and persistently
through his third series of trials, but in no one of these trials did he
choose correctly. Neither on this day nor the following did he exhibit
resentment while at work. He apparently had regained his affective poise
and was able to attend as formerly to the task of locating his rewards.

During these first three series, although the ratio of right to wrong
choices stood 0 to 10, there occurred a marked reduction in the number
of trials in which aid was necessary as well as in the total number of
choices, and on July 23 correct reactions began to appear. Improvement
during the next hundred trials was steady and fairly rapid, and on July
31, a record of seven right to three wrong trials was obtained. This was
surprising to the experimenter, as well as gratifying, since he was
eager to have the animal complete this problem before work should have
to be discontinued.

Everything went smoothly until August 2, when my assistant, who had been
left in charge of the experimental work for a week, attempted to
increase the number of trials per day to two series. Sobke apparently
was not quite ready for this increase in the amount of his day's labor
and refused to work at the end of the first series. In this series he
did less well than on the previous day. The following day, August 3,
unfortunately and contrary to the wishes of the experimenter, the
laboratory was painted and there was necessarily considerable
disturbance because of the presence of the workmen, and in addition, the
pervasive odor of fresh paint. Sobke chose still less successfully on
this date, and on August 4, he refused to work after the eighth trial.
It is true that during these bad days the total number of choices
steadily diminished while the successes, also, diminished, or at best,
failed to increase. When on August 9, I returned to the laboratory to
take charge, I found that Sobke was no longer trying to solve the
problem as when I had gone away. His attitude had changed in that he had
become indifferent, careless, and obviously discouraged with his task.



TABLE 7

Results for Sobke, _P. rhesus_, in Problem 4


========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========
        |    No.    |     S.1      |     S.2      |     S.3      |     S.4      |     S.5      |     S.6      |     S.7      |     S.8      |     S.9      |     S.10     |   |   |   |   | Ratio
  Date  |    of     |              |              |   1.2.3.4    |              |              |  1.2.3.4.5   |              |              |   3.4.5.6    |              | R | W | R | W |   of
        |  trials   |    2.3.4     |  5.6.7.8.9   |    5.6.7     |    7.8.9     |  4.5.6.7.8   |   6.7.8.9    |    1.2.3     |  2.3.4.5.6   |    7.8.9     |     6.7.8    |   |   |   |   | R to W
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
  July  |           |              | {5.9.5.5     | {1.7.1.3     | {9.7.9.7     |              | {1.9.3.1     |              | {6.3.2.6     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   20   |    1- 10  | 2.4.2.4.3    | {5.9.5.6     | {1.7.1.7     | {7.9.7.9     | {8.4.8.4     | {9.2.9.3     | 3.1.3.2      | {3.6.3.2     | {9.3.4.3     | {8.6.6.8.6   | 0 |10 | 0 |10 | 0:10.00
        |           |              | {5.8.7*      | {1.7.4*      | {7.7.8       | {4.6         | {9.1.5*      |              | {6.3.4*      | {3.9.3.6     | {8.6.8.6.7   |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              | {7.9.7.7     | {4.8.5.5     | {1.4.3.2     |              |              | {3.9.3.8     |              |   |   |   |   |
   21   |   11- 20  | 2.3          | {5.6.5.5     | {1.2.7.1     | {7.9.7.7     | {8.4.8.4     | {8.9.1.9     | 3.1.2        | {6.2.3.2.6   | {4.3.3.5     | 6.7          | 0 |10 | 0 |10 | 0:10.00
        |           |              | {9.5.5.7     | {7.3.7.4     | {9.7.8*      | {5.4.6*      | {1.9.5*      |              | {3.5.2.4     | {3.4.6*      |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {3.7.4.8     |              |   |   |   |   |
   22   |   21- 30  | 2.3          | 5.6.5.6.7    | 1.7.4        | {7.9.7       | 4.7.4.6      | {1.4.6.3     | 3.1.2        | 5.2.6.4      | {4.3.5.8     | 6.6.7        | 0 |10 | 0 |10 | 0:10.00
        |           |              |              |              | {7.7.8       |              | {2.7.5       |              |              | {3.7.6*      |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.4.7.4     |              |   |   |   |   |
   23   |   31- 40  | 2.4.3        | 5.6.8.7      | 1.7.4        | {7.7.7.7     | 4.7.6        | 2.7.5        | 3.1.2        | 6.4          | {7.5.4.3     | 7            | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
        |           |              |              |              | {7.7.8       |              |              |              |              | {7.3.6       |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   24   |   41- 50  | 3            | 5.6.7        | 1.6.4        | 7.7.7.8      | 4.7.6        | {2.7.6.4     | 3.2          | 6.5.4        | 5.3.8.6.6    | 7            | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {2.7.3.8     |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {9.6.5*      |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   26   |   51- 60  | 4.3          | 6.5.7        | 2.7.4        | 7.8          | 6            | {6.4.2.7     | 3.2          | {6.5.3.5.2   | 7.6          | 7            | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {4.8.6.5     |              | {6.5.6.4     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {4.7.3.7     |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   27   |   61- 70  | 3            | 6.5.7        | 2.5.4        | 7.7.8        | 5.7.6        | {4.6.1.4     | 2            | 6.5.4        | 5.7.6        | 6.7          | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {7.3.5       |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   28   |   71- 80  | 3            | 7            | 6.5.4        | 7.8          | 5.4.7.6      | 2.7.6.5      | 2            | 5.5.4        | 7.6          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   29   |   81- 90  | 3            | 6.5.7        | 2.4          | 7.7.8        | 5.4.6        | {2.7.7.6     | 2            | 4            | 5.4.7.6      | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {2.7.6.5     |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   30   |   91-100  | 3            | 7            | 2.6.5.4      | 7.8          | 6            | 5            | 2            | 5.4          | 5.4.6        | 7            | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1: 0.67
   31   |  101-110  | 3            | 7            | 2.4          | 7.8          | 6            | 5            | 2            | 4            | 7.6          | 7            | 7 | 3 | 7 | 3 | 1: 0.43
 August |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    2   |  111-120  | 3            | 7            | 6.5.7.6.4    | 7.8          | 6            | 4.2.7.6.5    | 2            | 6.5.4        | 7.6          | 7            | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1: 1.00
    3   |  121-130  | 3            | 6.5.7        | 7.6.5.4      | 7.8          | 7.6          | 5            | 2            | 6.5.4        | 7.6          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    4   |  131-140  | 3            | 7            | 6.5.7.6.4    | 7.8          | 6            | {2.7.6.4     | 2            | 6.4          | 3.5.4.6      | 7            | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1: 1.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {8.7.6.5     |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           | {2.4.4.4     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    5   |  141-150  | {2.4.4.2     | 6.5.7        | {2.7.6.7     | 8            | 7.6          | {2.8.7.6     | 3.2          | 6.4          | 7.6          | 8.7          | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
        |           | {4.3*        |              | {5.4         |              |              | {8.6.5       |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    6   |  151-160  | 2.4.4.3      | 7            | 2.6.5.4      | 7.8          | 7.6          | 7.6.5        | 2            | 6.4          | 6            | 7            | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           | {4.4.2.4     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  161-170  | {4.2.4.2     | 7            | 6.5.4        | 7.8          | 7.6          | 7.6.5        | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.6          | 7            | 2 | 8 | 6 |14 | 1: 2.33
        |           | {4.4.3       |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    7   |  171-180  | 4.3          | 7            | 6.5.4        | 8            | 7.6          | 5            | 2            | 6.5.4        | 7.6          | 7            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  181-190  | {4.2.4.4     | 7            | 7.6.5.4      | 7.8          | 6            | 6.5          | 2            | 6.5.4        | 7.6          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 9 |11 | 1: 1.22
        |           | {2.4.3       |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    9   |  191-200  | 3            | 7            | 5.4          | 8            | 8.7.6        | 6.5          | 2            | 6.5.4        | 7.6          | 8.7          | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   10   |  201-210  | 3            | 7            | 2.5.4        | 7.8          | 7.6          | {2.8.7.6     | 2            | 6.5.4        | 7.6          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {8.7.6.5     |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   11   |  211-220  | 3            | 7            | 6.5.4        | 7.8          | 6            | {7.6.4.3     | 2            | 6.5.4        | 7.6          | 7            | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1: 1.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {2.7.6.5     |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   12   |  221-230  | 3            | 7            | 2.4          | 7.8          | 6            | 7.6.5        | 2            | 6.5.4        | 8.7.6        | 7            | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1: 1.00
   19   |  231-240  | 3            | 7            | 2.4          | 7.8          | 6            | 5            | 2            | 6.4          | 8.7.6        | 7            | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1: 0.67
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   20   |  241-250  | 3            | 7            | 5.4          | 8            | 7.6          | {2.4.1.2.7   | 3.2          | 6.4          | 7.6          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {8.7.6.5     |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   21   |  251-260  | 3            | 7            | 6.5.4        | 7.8          | {7.4.5.4     | {6.4.3.2     | 2            | 6.5.4        | 8.7.6        | 7            | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              | {8.7.6       | {7.6.5       |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   23   |  261-270  | 3            | 7            | 6.5.4        | 7.8          | 6            | 6.5          | 2            | 6.5.4        | 7.6          | 7            | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1: 1.00
   24   |  271-280  | 3            | 7            | 6.4          | 7.8          | 7.6          | 2.5          | 2            | 4            | 7.4.3.8.7.6  | 7            | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1: 1.00
   25   |  281-290  | 3            | 7            | 2.5.4        | 8            | 7.6          | 5            | 2            | 6.4          | 7.6          | 7            | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1: 0.67
   26   |  291-300  | 3            | 7            | 6.5.4        | 8            | 7.6          | 7.6.5        | 2            | 6.5.4        | 7.6          | 7            | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1: 1.00
   27   |  301-310  | 3            | 7            | 2.6.5.4      | 8            | 7.6          | 5            | 2            | 6.5.4        | 7.5.4.9.8.6  | 7            | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1: 0.67
   28   |  311-320  | 3            | 7            | 2.5.4        | 8            | 6            | 9.8.7.5      | 2            | 3.4          | 8.6          | 7            | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1: 0.67
========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========

[Footnote *: Aided by experimenter.]



I immediately set about reinstating the former attitude by lessening the
number of trials and the punishment, and by increasing the value of the
reward, but my best efforts, continuing up to August 28, failed markedly
to improve the condition. The number of correct choices did somewhat
increase, but at no time did the animal attain the degree of success
which he had achieved as early as July 31 in the eleventh series of
trials.

During the last two weeks of experimentation, all possible efforts were
put forth to discover the best combination of rewards and punishments.
Punishment was varied from 0 to confinement of sixty seconds, and many
kinds of food in different amounts were tried as rewards, but in spite
of everything Sobke failed to improve markedly. From time to time,
notably on August 12 and 21, he exhibited peculiarly strong resentment
toward me and repeatedly attempted to attack me.

The outcome of my experiments with problem 4 is peculiarly interesting
in that it indicates the importance of a favorable attitude toward the
work and the extreme risk from disturbing or discouraging conditions. It
seems not improbable that had the work progressed without change in
experimenter, or method of procedure, and above all without the
disturbance of the painting, Sobke might have solved problem 4 within a
few days. This is by no means certain, however, for in problems 2 and 3
the ratio of right to wrong choices instead of increasing steadily
increased very irregularly.

The detailed results for this problem are given in table 7. Reactive
tendencies which appear are: (a) persistent choice of the end boxes
followed, subsequently, by (b) the tendency to locate the middle box
directly. This proved fairly easy when the number of boxes involved was
only three as in settings 1, 4, 7, and 10. Setting 4 was most difficult
of all, because box 9 was avoided or ignored. When the number of open
boxes was as great as five, as in settings 2 and 8, the task was
obviously more difficult, but whereas success in setting 2 appeared
early, in setting 8 it failed to appear during the course of
experimentation. For the settings 3, 6, and 9, involving either seven or
nine open boxes, the direct choice of the middle box was next to
impossible, and Sobke tended to choose, first of all, a particular box
toward one end of the series, for example, box 2, in setting 3, and box
7 in setting 9. To the experimenter, as he watched the animal's
behavior, it looked as though effort each time were being made to locate
the middle member of the group. This appeared relatively easy for groups
of three boxes, extremely difficult for as many as five boxes, and
almost impossible for seven or nine.


3. Julius, _Pongo pygmaeus_

_Problem 1. First at the Left End_

The orang utan, Julius, was gentle, docile, and friendly with the
experimenter throughout the period of investigation. He at no time
showed inclination to bite and could be handled safely. As contrasted
with Skirrl and even with Sobke, he adapted himself to the
multiple-choice apparatus very promptly, and only slight effort on the
part of the observer was necessary to prepare him, by preliminary
trials, for the regular experiments. But in order to facilitate work, he
was familiarized with the apparatus by means of regular route training
and feeding in the several boxes from April 5 to April 9.

On April 10 the apparatus was painted white as has been stated
previously, and on the following Monday, April 12, Julius when again
introduced to it gave no indications of fear, uneasiness, or dislike,
but worked as formerly, making his round trips quickly and eagerly
entering any box which happened to be open, in order to obtain the
reward of food.

The regular experimentation was undertaken on April 13, and the results
of the first series of trials with Julius are sharply contrasted with
those obtained with the monkeys in that fewer choices were necessary.
Instead of the expected ratio of right to wrong first choices, 1 to 2.5,
the orang utan gave a ratio of 1 to 1. An additional markedly different
result from that obtained with the monkeys is indicated below in the
total time required for a series of trials. As examples, the data for
the first, second, fifth, and tenth series are presented.



TIME FOR SERIES OF TRIALS

        1st series  2nd series  5th series  10th series
Skirrl  35 min.     20 min.     14 min.     10 min.
Sobke   14  "       17  "       10  "        9  " (8th series)
Julius  12  "       11  "       14  "        9  "



It is also noteworthy that Julius in the presence of visitors or under
other unusual conditions worked steadily and well, whereas the monkeys,
and especially Sobke, tended to be distracted and often refused to work
at all.

Almost from the beginning of his work on problem l, Julius began to
develop the tendency to enter immediately the open door nearest the
starting point. In case the group of open doors lay to the right of the
middle of the apparatus, this method naturally yielded success; whereas
if the group included doors to the left of the middle, it resulted in
failure. Obviously it was a most unsatisfactory method, and although it
enabled him to make more right than wrong first choices, it prevented
him from increasing the number of right choices, and as table 1
indicates, it maintained the ratio of 1 right to .67 wrong first choices
for eight successive days.

On April 23 a break occurred in which the number of correct choices was
reduced from six to five. Julius worked very rapidly and with almost no
hesitation in choosing. My notes record "he seems to miss the point
wholly. It is doubtful whether the punishment is sufficiently severe."
At this time he was being punished by thirty seconds confinement in each
wrong box, the interval having been held fairly steadily from the first
series of experiments. On April 26 it was increased to sixty seconds, in
an effort to break him of the habit of choosing the "nearest" door. But
he became extremely restless under the longer confinement and tried his
best to raise the entrance and exit doors. Since there was at this time
no mechanism for locking them when closed, it was difficult for the
experimenter to prevent him from escaping by way of the entrance door or
from raising the exit door sufficiently to obtain the food. Indeed, the
longer confinement worked so unsatisfactorily that on the following day
I substituted for it the punishment of forcing him to raise the entrance
door of the wrong box in order to escape for a new choice. He was
rewarded with food in the alleyway H, beside door 15 (figure 17), only
when he chose correctly on first attempt.

This method discouraged him extremely and proved wasteful of time.
Consequently, in a second series on the same date return was made to the
former method, and he was rewarded with food whenever he found the right
box. But on April 28, the two methods were again employed, the first in
the initial series and the second in a final series of trials. The
animal's persistent attempts to raise the doors gave the experimenter so
much trouble that on April 29 barbed wire was nailed over the windows of
the entrance doors with the hope that it might prevent him from working
at them. But he quickly learned to place his fingers between the barbs
and raise the doors as effectively as ever.

On April 30 the reward of food was given only when the first choice was
that of the right box and in that event it was placed in the alleyway H
as stated above.

As it seemed absolutely essential to break the unprofitable habit of
choosing the nearest door, on May 3 a new series of settings was
presented, in which only the doors to the left of the middle of the row
of nine boxes were used as right doors. That is, in this new series,
doors 1 to 4 occur as right doors; 5 to 9 do not. As punishment for
wrong choices on this date, Julius was confined in the wrong box from
one to five minutes. It was difficult to keep him in, but by means of
cords which had been attached to the doors, this was successfully
accomplished. Yet another and slightly different series of settings was
employed on May 4, and this, proving satisfactory, was continued in use
until the end of the experiment, with punishment ranging from sixty to
one hundred and twenty seconds for each mistake.

Naturally the modification of settings introduced May 3 greatly
increased the proportion of wrong first choices. Indeed, as appears in
table 8, the ratio of right to wrong immediately changed from 1:0.67 to
1:4.00. Between May 3 and May 10, no steady and consistent improvement
in method or in the number of correct first choices occurred, and on the
last named date, Julius chose correctly only three times in his ten
trials. At this time there was, as my notes record, no satisfactory
indication of progress, and the status of the experiment seemed
extremely unsatisfactory in as much as in spite of the experimenter's
best efforts to break up the habit of choosing the nearest door, the
orang utan still persisted, to a considerable extent, in the use of this
method. The only encouraging feature of the results was an evident
tendency to choose somewhat nearer the left end of a group than
previously.




TABLE 8

Results for Orang utan in Problem 1

========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========
        |    No.    |     S.1      |     S.2      |     S.3      |     S.4      |     S.5      |     S.6      |     S.7      |     S.8      |     S.9      |     S.10     |   |   |   |   | Ratio
  Date  |    of     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | R | W | R | W |   of
        |  trials   |    1.2.3     |     8.9      |  3.4.5.6.7   |    7.8.9     |  2.3.4.5.6   |    6.7.8     |    5.6.7     |  4.5.6.7.8   |    7.8.9     |     1.2.3    |   |   |   |   | R to W
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
 April  |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   13   |    1- 10  | 3.1          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.2         | 7.6          | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1:1.00
   14   |   11- 20  | 3.2.1        | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.4.2       | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1:0.67
   15   |   21- 30  | 3.2.1        | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.5.5.2     | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1:0.67
   16   |   31- 40  | 3.1          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.2         | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.2.1        | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1:0.67
   17   |   41- 50  | 3.2.1        | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.2         | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1:0.67
   19   |   51- 60  | 3.1          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.2         | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1:0.67
   20   |   61- 70  | 2.1          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  5.3.2       | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1:0.67
   21   |   71- 80  | 3.1          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  5.4.3.2     | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.2.1        | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1:0.67
   22   |   81- 90  | 3.1          | 8            | 5.3          | 7            |  6.3.2       | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.2.1        | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1:0.67
   23   |   91-100  | 3.2.1        | 8            | 5.3          | 7            |  4.3.2       | 6            | 5            | 5.4          | 7            | 3.2.1        | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1:1.00
   24   |  101-110  | 3.2.1        | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.3.2       | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 6 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 1:0.67
   26   |  111-120  | 3.1          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.3.2       | 6            | 5            | 5.4          | 7            | 3.1          | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1:1.00
   27   |  121-130  | 3.2.1        | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.3.2       | 6            | 6.5          | 5.8.6.4      | 7            | 3.3.3.1      | 4 | 6 |   |   |
    "   |  131-140  | 3.1          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.3.2       | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.2.1        | 6 | 4 |10 |10 | 1:1.00
   28   |  141-150  | 3.2.1        | 8            | 3            | 7            |  5.4.2       | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   |  151-160  | 3.1          | 8            | 3            | 7            |  3.2         | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.2.1        | 7 | 3 |14 | 6 | 1:0.43
   29   |  161-170  | 3.1          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.3.2       | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.2.1        | 6 | 4 |   |   |
    "   |  171-180  | 3.2.1        | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.2         | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.2.1        | 6 | 4 |12 | 8 | 1:0.67
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   30   |  181-190  | 3.1          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | {4.5.6.4     | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 6 | 4 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {5.6.4.2     |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  191-200  | 3.1          | 8            | 4.5.6.7.3    | 7            |  4.5.3.2     | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.2.1        | 6 | 4 |12 | 8 | 1:0.67
   May  |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    1   |  201-210  | 3.1          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  3.2         | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 6 | 4 |   |   |
    "   |  211-220  | 3.2.1        | 8            | 4.3          | 7            |  4.2         | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 3.1          | 6 | 4 |12 | 8 | 1:0.67
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |   2.3.4.5    |              |              |              |              |              |              |    2.3.4.5   |   |   |   |   |
        |           |    1.2.3     |  3.4.5.6.7   |    6.7.8     |    1.2.3     |  3.4.5.6.7   | 4.5.6.7.8.9  |   2.3.4.5    |     1.2.3    | 4.5.6.7.8.9  |    6.7.8.9   |   |   |   |   |
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
    3   |  221-230  | 3.1          | 4.3          | 4.2          | 3.1          | 4.3          | 4            | 4.3.2        | 3.1          | 4            | 4.3.2        | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1:4.00
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |   2.3.4.5    |   4.5.6.7    |              |              |              |              |   2.3.4.5    |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |    1.2.3     |  3.4.5.6.7   |    6.7.8     |     8.9      |   2.3.4.5    |   3.4.5.6    |    1.2.3     |  4.5.6.7.8   |   6.7.8.9    |     1.2.3    |   |   |   |   |
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
    4   |  231-240  | 3.2.1        | 4.3          | 4.2          | 4            | 4.3.2        | 4.3          | 3.2.1        | 4            | 3.2          | 3.2.1        | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1:4.00
    5   |  241-250  | 2.1          | 3            | 3.2          | 4            | 3.2          | 4.3          | 3.2.1        | 4            | 3.2          | 3.2.1        | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1:2.33
    6   |  251-260  | 2.1          | 3            | 2            | 4            | 3.2          | 3            | 2.1          | 4            | 3.2          | 2.1          | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 1:1.00
    7   |  261-270  | 2.1          | 3            | 3.2          | 4            | 3.2          | 3            | 2.1          | 4            | 4.2          | 2.1          | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1:1.50
    8   |  271-280  | 2.1          | 4.3          | 4.3.2        | 4            | 3.2          | 4.3          | 3.1          | 4            | 3.2          | 2.1          | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1:4.00
   10   |  281-290  | 1            | 4.3          | 4.2          | 4            | 3.2          | 4.3          | 2.1          | 4            | 3.2          | 2.1          | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1:2.33
   11   |  291-300  | 1            | 3            | 2            | 4            | 2            | 3            | 1            | 4            | 2            | 1            |10 | 0 |10 | 0 | 1:0.00
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |    1.2.3     |     8.9      |  3.4.5.6.7   |    7.8.9     |  2.3.4.5.6   |    6.7.8     |    5.6.7     |  4.5.6.7.8   |     7.8.9    |     1.2.3    |   |   |   |   |
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
   12   |  301-310  | 1            | 8            | 3            | 7            | 2            | 6            | 5            | 4            | 7            | 1            |10 | 0 |10 | 0 | 1:0.00
========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========



A series of correct first choices was obtained on May 11, greatly to the
surprise of the experimenter, for no indication had previously appeared
of this approaching solution of the problem. It seemed possible,
however, that the successes were accidental, and it was anticipated that
in a control series Julius would again make mistakes. But on the
following day, May 12, the presentation of the original series of ten
settings, which, of course, differed radically from the settings used
from May 4 to May 11 was responded to promptly, readily, and without a
single mistake. Julius had solved his problem suddenly and, in all
probability, ideationally.

Only three reactive tendencies or methods appeared during Julius's work
on this problem: (a) choice of the open door nearest to the starting
point (sometimes the adjacent boxes were entered); (b) a tendency to
avoid the "nearest" door and select instead one further toward the left
end of the group; (c) direct choice of the first door on the left.

The curve of learning plotted from the daily wrong choices and presented
in figure 18, had it been obtained with a human subject, would
undoubtedly be described as an ideational, and possibly even as a
rational curve; for its sudden drop from near the maximum to the base
line strongly suggests, if it does not actually prove, insight.

Never before has a curve of learning like this been obtained from an
infrahuman animal. I feel wholly justified in concluding from the
evidences at hand, which have been presented as adequately as is
possible without going into minutely detailed description, that the
orang utan solved this simple problem ideationally. As a matter of fact,
for the solution he required about four times the number of trials which
Sobke required and twice as many as were necessary for Skirrl. Were we
to measure the intelligence of these three animals by the number of
trials needed in problem 1, Sobke clearly would rank first, Skirrl
second, and Julius last of all. But other facts clearly indicate that
Julius is far superior to the monkeys in intelligence. We therefore must
conclude that _where very different methods of learning appear, the
number of trials is not a safe criterion of intelligence._ The
importance of this conclusion for comparative and genetic psychology
needs no emphasis.


_Problem 2. Second from the Right End_

Julius was given four days' rest before being presented with problem 2.
He was occasionally fed in the apparatus, but regular continuation of
training was not necessary to keep him in good form. During this rest
interval, locks were attached to the doors of the apparatus so that the
experimenter by moving a lever directly in front of him could fasten
either one or both of the doors of a given box by a single movement. On
May 13 Julius was given opportunity to obtain food from each of the
boxes in turn, and trial of the locks was made in order to familiarize
him with the new situation. He very quickly discovered that the doors
could not be raised when closed, and after two days of preliminary work,
he practically abandoned his formerly persistent efforts to open them.
The locks worked satisfactorily from a mechanical point of view as well
as from that of the adaptation of the animal to the modified situation.

Problem 2 was regularly presented for the first time on May 17, on which
day a single series was given. The period of punishment adopted was
twenty seconds, and for each successful choice a small piece of banana
was given as a reward. After the first trial in this series, in which
Julius repeatedly entered the first box at the left, that is box 7,
there was but slight tendency to reënter the first box at the left of
the group. Instead, Julius developed the method of moving box by box
toward the right end of the group. The choices were made promptly, and
their systematic character enabled the animal to obtain his reward
fairly quickly, in spite of the large number of mistakes.

In the second series, the orang utan developed the interesting trick of
quickly dodging out of the wrong box before the experimenter could lower
the door behind him. This he did only after having been punished for
many wrong choices to the point of discouragement. The trick was easily
broken up by the sudden lowering of the entrance door as soon as he had
passed under it.

There appeared on May 21 an unfavorable physical condition which
manifested itself, first of all through the eyes which appeared dull and
bloodshot. On the following day they were inflamed and the lids nearly
closed. Julius refused to eat, and experimentation was impossible. Until
June 2 careful treatment and regulation of diet was necessary. He passed
through what at the time seemed a rather startling condition, but
rapidly regained his usual good health, and on June 3, although somewhat
weak and listless, he again worked fairly steadily.

Since it was now possible to lock the doors and confine the animal for
any desired period, on June 5 the interval of punishment was made sixty
seconds, and a liberal quantity of banana, beet, or carrot was offered
as reward. No increase in the number of successful choices appeared, and
Julius showed discouragement. Sawdust had been strewn on the floor, and
in the intervals between trials as well as during confinement in wrong
boxes, he took to playing with the sawdust. He would take it up in one
hand and pour it from hand to hand until all had slipped through his
fingers, then he would scrape together another handful and go through
the same process. Often he became so intent on this form of amusement
that even when the exit door was raised, he would not immediately go to
get the food.

The reactive tendencies which appeared in the work on problem 2 will now
be presented in order, since I shall have to refer to them repeatedly,
and the list will be more useful to the reader at this point than at the
conclusion of the presentation of daily results. The following is not an
exhaustive list but includes only the most important and conspicuous
tendencies or methods together with the dates on which they were most
apparent.

(a) May 17, choice of first box at left of group or near it, then the
next in order, and so on, until the second from the right was reached.
This method with irregularities and certain definite skipping was used
at various times, sometimes over periods of several days, during the
course of the work.

(b) June 3, preference for number 3 and number 4 developed immediately
after the orang utan's illness and when he was working rather
listlessly.

On June 9 and 10, the original tendency (a) reappeared and persisted for
a number of series.

(c) June 14, a tendency to choose the box at or near the right end of a
group, and then the one next to it. In connection with this tendency,
which of course required only two choices in any given trial, interest
in playing with the sawdust on the floor developed.

Again on June 21, the animal returned to the use of tendency (a).

(d) June 29, movement to box at right end of group, hesitation before
it, and turning through a complete circle so that the second box from
the right was faced. This, the correct box, was often promptly entered.
This method, if persisted in, would obviously have yielded solution of
the problem.

(e) July 5, approach to and pretense to enter the box next to the right
end (right one), and then choice of some other box. This _feint_ is
peculiarly interesting, and its origin and persistence are difficult to
account for.

(f) In connection with the tendency to pretend that he was going to
enter the second box from the right end, Julius developed also the
tendency to turn around in front of the box at the right end, starting
sometimes to back into it, and then to enter, instead, the box second
from the end.

(g) July, 6 and 7, a fairly definite tendency to take the one next in
order or, instead, to go directly to the right box.

(h) July 10, direct first choices without approach to other boxes
appeared for the first time on this date.

For this problem, it proved impossible to establish and maintain uniform
conditions of experimentation. Instead, because of the failure of the
animal to improve and the tendency to discouragement, both punishment
and reward had to be altered from time to time, and other and more
radical changes were occasionally made in the experimental procedure.
Below for the sake of condensed and consecutive presentation, the most
important conditions from day to day are arranged in tabular form:



CONDITIONS OF EXPERIMENT FROM DAY To DAY FOR PROBLEM 2

Date                     Punishment                   Reward

May  17  ............. 20 sec. confinement ........ Food in right box for each
                         (Aid after 10 trials)        trial

 "   18 to 21 ........ 30 sec. confinement ........ Food (banana) in right box
                                                      for each trial

 "   22 to June 2 .... Illness, no experiments

June 3 ............... 15 sec. confinement ........ Food (banana) in right box
                                                      for each trial

 "   4 ............... 30  "        " ............. Food (banana) in right box
                                                      for each trial

 "   5-10 ............ 60  "        " ............. Beet, carrot and loquat, in
                                                      addition to banana

 "   11 .............. 10 to 30 sec. confinement .. Beet, carrot and loquat, in
                                                      addition to banana

 "   12 to 15 ........ 60 sec. confinement ........ Beet, carrot and loquat, in
                                                      addition to banana

 "   16 .............. 60  "        " ............. Banana and sweet corn--former
                                                      preferred

 "   17 (1st series).  60 sec. confinement ........ Food (banana, as in early
                                                      series)

 "   17 (2nd series).  No confinement in wrong box; Food only for correct first
                         but instead, return to       choices
                         starting point by way of
                         alleys

 "   18 to 22 ........ No confinement in wrong box; Food only for correct first
                         but instead, return to       choices
                         starting point by way of
                         alleys

 "   22 (2nd series).  No punishment; allowed to    Food for each trial
                         enter boxes until right
                         one was found
 "   23 .............. Return to starting point.
                         After five wrong choices
                         of a given box the animal
                         was held for 60 secs. in
                         one of the boxes and was
                         then released by way of
                         the exit door and rewarded
                         when the right one was
                         chosen

 "   23 (2nd series).  No punishment .............. Reward for each trial

 "   24 (1st series).  Return to starting point. .. Food only for correct first
                                                      choices

 "   24 (2nd series).  No punishment .............. Reward for each trial

 "   25-30 ........... Same as on 24th ............

July 1 (1st series).   No punishment ..............   "     "   "     "

 "   1 (2nd series).   Return to starting point ... Reward only for correct first
                                                      choices
 "   2-8 ............. Same as on July 1 ..........

 "   8 (2nd series).   No punishment .............. Reward for each trial

 "   8 (3rd series).   Return to starting point ... Reward only for correct first
                                                      choices

 "   9-10 ............ Same as for July 8 (3rd series)

 "   10 (2nd series).  Momentary confinement in ..... Reward for each correct choice
                         wrong boxes

 "   12 .............. Return to starting point ..... Reward for correct first choice

 "   12 (2nd series).  30 sec. confinement .......... Reward for each correct choice

 "   12 (3rd series).  5   "        " ...............    "    "   "      "      "

 "   13 .............. 30  "        " ...............    "    "   "      "      "

 "   14-17 ........... Return to starting point ..... Reward for correct first choices

 "   17 (2nd series).  60 sec. confinement .......... Reward for each correct choice

 "   19 .............. 30  "        " ...............    "    "   "      "      "

 "   20-26 ........... 10  "        " ...............    "    "   "      "      "

 "   27-30 ........... Right box indicated by slight  Reward in each right box
                         raising of exit door
                         momentarily.
                         No punishment

 "   30 (2nd series).  Return to starting point ..... Reward for correct first choices

 "   31 ..............    "   "     "       "   .....    "    "     "      "      "

 "   31 (2nd series)
       to Aug. 10 .... 10 to 60 sec. confinement .... Reward for each correct choice

Aug. 10 (2nd series).  Threatened with whip .........    "    "   "      "       "

 "   11 (1st series).      "        "   " ...........    "    "   "      "       "

 "   11 (2nd series).  10 sec. confinement ..........    "    "   "      "       "

 "   12 .............. Threatened with whip .........    "    "   "      "       "

 "   12 (2nd series).  10 sec. confinement ..........    "    "   "      "       "

 "   19 .............. 10  "        " ...............    "    "   "      "       "

 "   19 (2nd series).  Threatened with whip .........    "    "   "      "       "




With the above reactive tendencies and modifications of method in mind
we may continue our description of results. On June 9 there developed a
tendency to increase the magnitude of the original error by choosing
nearer the left end of the groups. This is odd, since one would
naturally suppose that an animal as intelligent as the orang utan would
tend to avoid the general region in which success was never obtained and
to focus attention on the right, as contrasted with the wrong end of
each group. _It obviously contradicts the law of the gradual elimination
of use less activities._ In other words, it is wholly at variance with
the principle of trial and error exhibited by many infrahuman organisms.
Julius, although making many mistakes, worked diligently and, for the
most part, fairly rapidly. The day's work proved most important because
of the change in method and also because of the appearance of
hesitation, the rejection of certain boxes, and the definite choice of
others. My notes record "this is a most important day for Julius in
problem 2;" but subsequent results do not clearly justify this prophecy.

The method of choosing the first box at the left and then of moving down
the line until the right one was reached was so consistently followed
that during a number of days it was possible for me to predict almost
every choice. Indeed, to satisfy my curiosity in this matter during a
number of series I guessed in advance the box which would be chosen. The
percentages of correct guesses ranged from ninety to one hundred. June
10, for example, yielded two series for which the ratio of right to
wrong first choices was 0 to 10, and in which the method described above
was used consistently throughout.

It was inevitable that punishment by confinement and the discouragement
resulting therefrom should interfere with the regularity of work and
make it extremely difficult to obtain strictly comparable results from
series to series and from day to day. The data for this problem, as
presented in table 9, have values quite different from those for the
monkeys, chiefly because of the more variable conditions of observation.

It was occasionally noted that the disintegration of a definite method
and the disappearance of the tendency on which it depended occurred
rather suddenly. Frequently it happened that having used an inadequate
method fairly persistently on a given day, the animal would on the
following day exhibit a wholly different method. Even over night a new
method might develop. In the monkeys, although there was occasionally
something comparable with this, it was by no means so evident.



TABLE 9

Results for Orang utan in Problem 2


========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========
        |    No.    |     S.1      |     S.2      |     S.3      |     S.4      |     S.5      |     S.6      |     S.7      |     S.8      |     S.9      |     S.10     |   |   |   |   | Ratio
  Date  |    of     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |  1.2.3.4.5   |              |              | R | W | R | W |   of
        |  trials   |    7.8.9     |   1.2.3.4    | 2.3.4.5.6.7  | 1.2.3.4.5.6  |  4.5.6.7.8   |    1.2.3     |   2.3.4.5    |   6.7.8.9    |   1.2.3.4    | 3.4.5.6.7.8  |   |   |   |   | R to W
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   May  |           | {7.7.7.7     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   17   |    1-  10 | {7.7.7.7     | 1.1.3        | 2.4.6        | 2.3.4.5      | 4.5.7        | 3.2          | 2.3.4        | {2.3.4.5     | 1.2.3        | 3.4.5.6.7    | 0 |10 | 0 |10 | 0:10.00
        |           | {7.7.8       |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.7.8       |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {4.5.6.8     |   |   |   |   |
   18   |   11-  20 | 7.8          | 1.3          | 3.4.5.6      | 2.4.5        | 4.5.6.7      | 2            | 2.3.4        | {2.3.4.5     | 1.2.3        | {8.8.8.3     | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.7.8       |              | {4.5.6.7     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              | {2.4.7.7.2   |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.3.4.5     |   |   |   |   |
   19   |   21-  30 |  7.8         | 1.3          | {5.7.7.2     | 5            | 4.6.8.4.7    | 1.2          | 2.3.4        | 5.8          | 3            | {6.8.4.5     | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              | {3.2.4.6     |              |              |              |              |              |              | {3.5.6.7     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   20   |   31-  40 | {7.9.7.7     | 3            | 4.5.6        | 4.5          | 5.6.7        | 2            | 4            | 5.6.7.8      | 3            | 5.6.7        | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           | {9.7.8       |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   21   |   41-  50 | 7.8          | 3            | 3.4.5.6      | 4.5          | 4.5.6.7      | 2            | 3.4          | 4.5.6.8      | 3            | 4.5.6.7      | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
  June  |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    3   |   51-  60 | 7.8          | 3            | 4.5.6        | 3.4.5        | 4.5.6.7      | 3.1.2        | 3.4          | {3.7.9.7     | 3            | 4.5.6.7      | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {9.7.6.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    4   |   61-  70 | 7.8          | 3            | 4.5.6        | 4.5          | 4.5.6.7      | 3.3.1.2      | 4            | 4.5.6.7.8    | 3            | 4.5.6.7      | 3 | 7 | 3 | 7 | 1: 2.33
    5   |   71-  80 | 7.9.7.8      | 3            | 3.4.5.6      | 3.6.3.4.5    | 4.7          | 3.1.2        | 4            | 3.4.5.6.7.8  | 3            | 4.5.6.7      | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   |   81-  90 | 7.8          | 3            | 3.4.5.6      | 3.4.5        | 4.5.6.7      | 2            | 3.4          | 3.4.5.6.7.8  | 2.3          | 4.5.6.7      | 2 | 8 | 5 |15 | 1: 3.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    7   |   91- 100 | 7.8          | 3            | 4.5.6        | 4.5          | 4.5.6.7      | 1.2          | 3.4          | {3.4.5.6     | 2.3          | {3.4.5.6     | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {7.8         |              | {8.5.6.7     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    8   |  101- 110 | 7.8          | 3            | 4.5.6        | 4.5          | 4.5.6.7      | 2            | 3.4          | 4.5.6.7.8    | 3            | 4.5.6.7      | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   |  111- 120 | 7.8          | 3            | 4.5.6        | 3.4.5        | 5.6.7        | 2            | 5.5.2.3.4    | 4.5.6.7.8    | 4.4.1.2.3    | 4.5.6.7      | 2 | 8 | 5 |15 | 1: 3.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    9   |  121- 130 | 7.8          | 2.3          | 4.5.6        | 4.5          | 4.5.6.7      | 2            | 3.4          | {2.3.4.5     | 1.2.3        | 3.4.5.6.7    | 1 | 9 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.7.8       |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  131- 140 | 7.8          | 1.2.3        | 2.3.4.5.6    | 5            | 4.5.6.7      | 1.2          | 2.3.4        | 6.7.8        | 2.3          | 3.4.5.6.7    | 1 | 9 | 2 |18 | 1: 9.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   10   |  141- 150 | 7.8          | 1.2.3        | 2.3.4.5.6    | 1.2.3.4.5    | 4.5.6.7      | 1.2          | 2.3.4        | {1.2.3.4     | 1.2.3        | 3.4.5.6.7    | 0 |10 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.6.7.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  151- 160 | 7.8          | 1.2.3        | 2.3.4.5.6    | 1.2.3.4.5    | 4.5.6.7      | 1.2          | 2.3.4        | {1.2.3.4     | 1.2.3        | 3.4.5.6.7    | 0 |10 | 0 |10 | 0:10.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.6.7.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   11   |  161- 170 | 8            | {4.1.2.4.1   | 2.3.4.5.6    | 5            | 6.7          | {3.1.3.1     | 5.2.3.4      | 2.6.7.8      | 4.1.2.3      | 8.5.6.7      | 2 | 8 |   |   |
        |           |              | {4.1.4.1.3   |              |              |              | {3.1.2       |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  171- 180 | 9.7.8        | 4.3          | 5.6          | 4.5          | 7            | 3.1.2        | 5.4          | 8            | 4.2.3        | 7            | 3 | 7 | 5 |15 | 1: 3.00
   12   |  181- 190 | 7.9.7.9.8    | 1.2.3        | 3.4.5.6      | 6.4.5        | 5.6.7        | 2            | 5.3.4        | 7.8          | 4.1.2.3      | 4.5.6.7      | 1 | 9 | 1 | 9 | 1: 9.00
   14   |  191- 200 | 9.8          | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 6.7.8        | 4.2.3        | 7            | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  201- 210 | 8            | 2.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.1.2        | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 | 5 |15 | 1: 3.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   15   |  211- 220 | {7.9.7.9     | 4.2.3        | 6            | 5            | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 9.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           | {7.9.8       |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  221- 230 | 9.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 5.6.7        | 1.2          | 2.3.4        | 3.4.5.6.7.8  | 4.3          | 7            | 1 | 9 | 4 |16 | 1: 4.00
   16   |  231- 240 | 7.9.8        | 3            | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 2            | 5.4          | 5.6.7.8      | 4.1.4.3      | 8.7          | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  241- 250 | 9.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 6.7.8        | 4.3          | 6.7          | 1 | 9 | 3 |17 | 1: 5.67
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   17   |  251- 260 | 9.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | {6.5.4.6     | 3.2          | 5.4          | 6.5.6.7.8    | 3            | 5.6.7        | 1 | 9 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {5.4.5.7     |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {6.6.6.5.6   |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {5.5.5.6.6   |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  261- 270 | {9.7.7.7     | 4.4.4.4.3    | 6            | 5            | {6.6.6.6.6   | {3.3.3.3     | 4            | {4.5.4.5.4   | 3            | {5.5.5.5     | 4 | 6 | 5 |15 | 1: 3.00
        |           | {7.7.7.8     |              |              |              | {6.5.4.5     | {3.3.2       |              | {5.6.7.8     |              | {5.5.8.7     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {6.5.5.4     |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {4.5.6.7     |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   18   |  271- 280 | {7.7.7.7     | 4.4.4.4.3    | 5.5.5.5.6    | 5            | {5.5.5.6     | {3.3.3.      | 4            | {4.6.5.6     | 4.4.3        | 5.6.4.7      | 2 | 8 | 2 | 8 | 1: 4.00
        |           | {7.7.8       |              |              |              | {5.5.6       | {3.3.2       |              | {6.7.4.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           | {7.7.7.9     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   19   |  281- 290 | {9.9.9.7     | {4.4.4       | {5.7.7       | 5            | 5.7          | {3.3.3.3     | 4            | 5.8          | {4.4.4.4     | {6.5.6.5     | 2 | 8 |   |   |
        |           | {7.7.8       | {4.4.3       | {7.4.6       |              |              | {3.3.2       |              |              | {4.4.3       | {5.5.7       |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  291- 300 | 7.7.7.7.8    | 4.4.4.4.3    | 5.5.6        | 5            | {5.6.6.5.6   | 3.3.2        | {5.5.5.5     | 5.6.8        | 4.4.3        | 6.6.6.7      | 1 | 9 | 3 |17 | 1: 5.67
        |           |              |              |              |              | {6.6.6.7     |              | {3.4         |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.6.6.6.7   |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   21   |  301- 310 | 7.7.8        | 4.4.3        | 5.6          | 5            | {6.6.6.5     | {3.3.3.3     | 5.5.5.2.4    | {3.4.3.5.5   | {4.2.2.4     | 5.3.7        | 1 | 9 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {5.6.5.7     | {3.2         |              | {1.1.2.4.7   | {4.3         |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.3.2.2.8   |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  311- 320 | {7.7.7.7     | 1.1.1.2.3    | {5.5.4.2     | 1.1.6.5      | 4.6.7        | 1.3.2        | {2.2.2.2     | {1.1.2.3     | {2.2.2.4     | {6.3.3.8     | 0 |10 | 1 |19 | 1:19.00
        |           | {7.7.8       |              | {2.5.6       |              |              |              | {2.2.3.4     | {6.6.6.8     | {2.3         | {4.8.7       |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   22   |  321- 330 | 7.8          | {2.4.2.1.4   | 6            | 5            | 6.6.8.7      | 3.2          | 5.5.3.3.4    | 3.3.7.7.8    | 4.4.4.2.3    | 6.7          | 2 | 8 |   |   |
        |           |              | {4.4.4.3     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  331- 340 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 5            | 6.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 6.7.8        | 3            | 5.6.7        | 4 | 6 | 6 |14 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   23   |  341- 350 | 7.8          | 4.2.4.3      | 6            | 5            | 6.7          | {3.3.3.1     | 5.5.4        | {7.5.4.3     | 4.4.4.3      | {6.6.3.6     | 2 | 8 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {3.3.3.2     |              | {6.7.7.8     |              | {8.6.8.7     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  351- 360 | 7.8          | 4.4.3        | 6            | 6.5          | 6.7          | 3.3.2        | 5.4          | {6.7.6.5     | 4.3          | 5.6.7        | 1 | 9 | 3 |17 | 1: 5.67
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {7.6.8       |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   24   |  361- 370 | 7.8          | 4.4.2.3      | 7.7.6        | 6.6.4.5      | 7            | {3.3.3.3     | 5.4          | 8            | 4.4.3        | 5.6.7        | 2 | 8 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {3.3.2       |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  371- 380 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.6.8        | 4.3          | 7            | 4 | 6 | 6 |14 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   25   |  381- 390 | 8            | 4.4.3        | 7.7.7.6      | {6.6.6.6     | 8.6.7        | 3.1.2        | 5.3.5.4      | 8            | 3            | 7            | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              | {6.4.6.5     |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  391- 400 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 5            | 6.5.8.7      | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 8.7          | 5 | 5 | 9 |11 | 1: 1.22
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   26   |  401- 410 | 9.9.9.8      | 3            | {7.7.7.7.3   | {6.6.6.6     | 8.8.8.7      | 3.2          | {5.5.5.5     | 7.8          | {4.4.4.4     | 6.6.8.8.7    | 1 | 9 |   |   |
        |           |              |              | {3.7.7.6     | {6.6.5       |              |              | {5.5.4       |              | {4.4.3       |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  411- 420 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 8.7          | 3 | 7 | 4 |16 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   28   |  421- 430 | 8            | {4.4.4.4     | 7.6          | {6.6.3.6     | 7            | {3.3.3.3     | 5.5.5.4      | 9.7.7.5.8    | 4.4.4.3      | 8.7          | 2 | 8 |   |   |
        |           |              | {4.4.3       |              | {6.6.6.5     |              | {3.3.2       |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  431- 440 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {7.6.5.4     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  441- 450 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | {3.2.1.5     | 4.3          | 7            | 2 | 8 | 8 |22 | 1: 2.75
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {7.9.8       |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   29   |  451- 460 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 6.6.6.5      | 8.6.7        | {3.3.3.3     | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {3.3.2       |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  461- 470 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 5            | 8.7          | 3.2          | 3.2.3.4      | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 4 | 6 |   |   |
    "   |  471- 480 | 8            | 4.4.3        | 7.7.6        | 6.6.5        | 7            | 2            | 5.5.5.5.5.4  | 7.8          | 4.4.3        | 7            | 4 | 6 |13 |17 | 1: 1.31
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   30   |  481- 490 | 8            | {4.4.4.4     | 7.7.6        | 6.6.6.5      | 8.6.6.5.7    | {3.1.3.3     | 5.5.5.4      | 8            | 4.4.4.3      | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           |              | {4.4.3       |              |              |              | {3.3.3.2     |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  491- 500 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.7.7.6      | 6.6.5        | 8.8.7        | 3.3.3.3.2    | 5.4          | {9.9.7.4     | 3            | 8.8.7        | 2 | 8 | 5 |15 | 1: 3.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {9.6.8       |              |              |   |   |   |   |
  July  |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    1   |  501- 510 | 9.7.9.8      | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 8.6.7        | 3.3.2        | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  511- 520 | {9.7.7.7     | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.4.5        | 7            | 3.2          | 4            | 8            | 4.4.4.3      | 8.6.5.6.7    | 3 | 7 | 6 |14 | 1: 2.33
        |           | {7.9.8       |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    2   |  521- 530 | 9.8          | 3            | 7.5.7.6      | 6.4.5        | 8.7          | 2            | 4            | 8            | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  531- 540 | 9.9.7.8      | 3            | 7.4.6        | 5            | 6.6.7        | 3.3.2        | 3.4          | 7.3.5.4.8    | 4.3          | {8.8.6.5     | 2 | 8 | 8 |12 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {4.5.7       |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    3   |  541- 550 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | {6.6.6.6     | 6.8.7        | 3.3.3.2      | 5.5.4        | 9.6.9.6.8    | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              | {6.6.5       |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  551- 560 | 9.9.7.8      | 4.3          | 6            | 5            | 8.6.5.7      | {3.3.3.3     | 5.4          | {7.6.5.7     | 3            | 7            | 4 | 6 | 7 |13 | 1: 1.86
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {3.2         |              | {9.7.9.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    5   |  561- 570 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | {8.8.8.8     | {3.3.3.3     | 5.5.5.5.4    | 8            | 4.4.4.3      | 8.8.8.8.7    | 2 | 8 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {8.8.7       | {3.3.3.2     |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  571- 580 | 9.8          | 4.4.4.3      | 6            | 6.5          | 8.8.7        | {3.3.3.3.3   | {5.5.5.5.5   | 7.6.8        | 4.4.3        | 7            | 2 | 8 | 4 |16 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              | {3.3.3.2     | {5.5.5.4     |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    6   |  581- 590 | 9.8          | 4.3          | 7.7.6        | 6.6.5        | 7            | 2            | 5.4          | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   |  591- 600 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 4.5          | 6.6.6.7      | 2            | 5.3.5.4      | 8            | 4.4.3        | 8.8.8.7      | 5 | 5 | 8 |12 | 1: 1.50
    7   |  601- 610 | 8            | 1.3          | 6            | 5            | 6.5.7        | 2            | 5.4          | 5.6.6.6.7.8  | 4.3          | 7            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  611- 620 | {9.7.7.7.9   | 3            | 6            | 5            | 6.5.6.5.7    | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.9.7.9.8    | {4.4.4.4     | 8.7          | 3 | 7 | 8 |12 | 1: 1.50
        |           | {7.7.7.8     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {4.4.4.3     |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    8   |  621- 630 | {9.9.9.7.9   | 4.3          | 6            | 6.6.6.5      | {8.8.8.8     | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.6.8        | 3            | 7            | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           | {9.9.8       |              |              |              | {5.6.5.7     |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {7.6.5.7     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  631- 640 | 9.8          | 3            | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 4            | {6.5.4.6     | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {9.7.9.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  641- 650 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 4            | 7.9.6.7.9.8  | 3            | 8.6.8.7      | 8 | 2 |17 |13 | 1: 0.76
    9   |  651- 660 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 4            | 7.6.7.6.8    | 3            | 8.6.8.8.4.7  | 8 | 2 |   |   |
    "   |  661- 670 | 9.9.8        | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.6.7.6.8    | 4.3          | 5.6.8        | 3 | 7 |11 | 9 | 1: 0.82
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   10   |  671- 680 | 9.8          | 3            | 5.4.5.6      | 5            | 6.4.8.6.7    | 3.2          | {3.5.3.2.3   | {7.6.5.6     | 3            | 5.4.3.7      | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.3.5.2.4   | {5.8         |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  681- 690 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 6.8.7        | 7 | 3 |10 |10 | 1: 1.00
   12   |  691- 700 | 7.8          | 3            | 5.6          | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 3.4          | 7.7.7.7.8    | 4.2.2.3      | 8.7          | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  701- 710 | 9.8          | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | {7.6.5.4.3   | 3            | 8.7          | 2 | 8 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.1.4.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  711- 720 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | {7.6.5.4.3   | 3            | {6.5.4.3.6   | 4 | 6 | 9 |21 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.5.9.8     |              | {5.4.3.8.7   |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   13   |  721- 730 | 7.8          | 4.3          | 6            | 4.3.6.5      | 4.6.5.4.7    | 2            | 4            | {6.5.4.3     | 3            | {5.4.3.6     | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {2.1.8       |              | {8.7         |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {4.7.5.4     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   14   |  731- 740 | 8            | 3            | 5.5.6        | 5            | {5.6.5.5     | 3.2          | 4            | {7.7.4.6     | 3            | 4.6.7        | 5 | 5 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {8.8.7       |              |              | {5.6.8       |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.4.5.5.4   |              | {4.4.4.5.5   |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  741- 750 | 8            | 3            | 5.6          | 5            | {6.5.6.6     | 2            | 4            | {5.6.4.4.4   | 3            | {5.4.8.8.4   | 6 | 4 |11 | 9 | 1: 0.82
        |           |              |              |              |              | {6.8.4.7     |              |              | {7.6.8       |              | {5.5.6.4.7   |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   15   |  751- 760 | 7.7.9.7.8    | 3            | 6            | 5            | 6.6.7        | 2            | 4            | 6.6.8        | 3            | {6.6.6.8     | 6 | 4 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.6.7       |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.4.6.6.5   |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  761- 770 | 8            | 3            | 5.6          | 5            | 6.6.6.6.7    | 2            | 3.4          | 5.4.7.8      | 3            | {5.3.5.8.5   | 5 | 5 |11 | 9 | 1: 0.82
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {5.5.7       |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {4.6.7.6.9   |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   16   |  771- 780 | 7.7.7.8      | 3            | 6            | 4.5          | 5.7          | 2            | 3.4          | {7.7.5.5     | 3            | (5.6.8.5     | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.6.6.8     |              | {3.7         |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.6.7.2     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  781- 790 | 7.8          | 3            | {4.5.4.3     | {4.6.4.4     | {4.4.6.8     | 2            | 3.4          | {3.4.4.4     | 3            | 6.7          | 3 | 7 | 7 |13 | 1: 1.86
        |           |              |              | {2.6         | {1.4.3.5     | {5.7         |              |              | {9.9.8       |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   17   |  791- 800 | 7.8          | 2.3          | 6            | {4.4.4.3.6   | 4.8.4.6.7    | 2            | 4            | {5.7.6.6.1   | 3            | 5.7          | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              | {2.4.2.5     |              |              |              | {7.4.4.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              | {2.4.4.4.2   |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  801- 810 | 7.8          | {4.2.4.1.4   | 5.7.6        | 5            | 5.7          | 2            | 3.5.5.4      | 6.8          | {2.4.4.2     | 6.8.7        | 2 | 8 | 6 |14 | 1: 2.33
        |           |              | {2.4.3       |              |              |              |              |              |              | {4.2.4 3     |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   19   |  811- 820 | 7.9.7.8      | 2.4.2.4.3    | 5.7.6        | 3.6.4.6.5    | 7            | 2            | 3.5.4        | 6.8          | 4.4.3        | 6.8.7        | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  821- 830 | 7.8          | 2.4.4.3      | 6            | 4.6.6.6.5    | 6.8.7        | 2            | 3.5.5.5.4    | 6.8          | 2.4.3        | 6.5.7        | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  831- 840 | 7.9.8        | 2.4.4.2.4.3  | 7.6          | 5            | 7            | 2            | 4            | 7.6.4.6.8    | 2.4.3        | 6.8.7        | 4 | 6 | 8 |22 | 1: 2.75
   20   |  841- 850 | 7.8          | 3            | 5.7.6        | 4.6.5        | 6.8.7        | 2            | 3.5.4        | 3.5.8        | 2.4.3        | 6.8.6.8.7    | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   |  851- 860 | 8            | 2.4.3        | 6            | 3.6.5        | 5.7          | 2            | 2.5.4        | 4.7.8        | 2.4.3        | 4.4.6.7      | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   |  861- 870 | 7.8          | 2.4.3        | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 2.4          | 6.8          | 2.4.3        | 4.7          | 4 | 6 | 9 |21 | 1: 2.33
   21   |  871- 880 | 7.9.8        | 2.4.3        | 5.7.6        | {4.6.4.6     | 4.6.7        | 2            | 3.5.3.5.4    | 5.7.8        | 2.4.3        | 5.7          | 1 | 9 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              | {3.2.4.5     |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  881- 890 | 7.8          | 2.4.2.3      | 3.5.7.6      | 3.4.6.4.6.5  | 4.6.5.6.7    | 2            | 4            | 6.8          | 3            | 4.6.5.7      | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  891- 900 | 7.8          | 2.4.3        | 5.7.6        | 4.5          | 5.7          | 3.3.3.2      | 4            | {4.6.5.7.6   | 2.4.3        | 5.7          | 1 | 9 | 5 |25 | 1: 5.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {4.2.4.8     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   22   |  901- 910 | 7.8          | 2.4.3        | 5.7.6        | 4.6.5        | 6.8.7        | 2            | 2.5.4        | 5.6.8        | 2.3          | 6.7          | 1 | 9 |   |   |
    "   |  911- 920 | 7.8          | 2.3          | 5.6          | 4.5          | 5.7          | 2            | 3.4          | 4.6.8        | 2.3          | 5.6.7        | 1 | 9 | 2 |18 | 1: 9.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   23   |  921- 930 | 7.8          | 2.3          | {3.2.4.4     | 5            | 4.6.5.6.7    | 2            | 3.2.4        | 5.4.6.8      | 2.3          | {4.5.4.3.5   | 2 | 8 |   |   |
        |           |              |              | {5.6         |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.5.6.7     |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   23   |  931- 940 | 7.9.7.8      | 3            | 5.4.6        | 5            | 5.7          | 2            | 4            | 6.7.8        | 3            | 6.8.7        | 5 | 5 |   |   |
    "   |  941- 950 | 7.8          | 3            | 5.6          | 4.6.5        | 7            | 2            | 3.5.4        | 5.6.8        | 2.3          | 6.7          | 3 | 7 |10 |20 | 1: 2.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   24   |  951- 960 | 7.8          | 2.3          | {2.7.7.4     | 4.6.5        | 5.7          | 2            | 4            | 4.6.8        | 3            | 6.8.7        | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           |              |              | {5.7.4.6     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  961- 970 | 7.9.7.8      | 3            | 6            | 5            | (6.8.6.8     | 2            | 5.5.3.4      | 7.8          | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 | 9 |11 | 1: 1.22
        |           |              |              |              |              | {6.7         |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              | {4.2.6.4     |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   26   |  971- 980 | 7.9.7.8      | 3            | 6            | {6.4.6.4     | 7            | 2            | 4            | 6.8          | 3            | 6.8.7        | 6 | 4 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              | {6.1.5       |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  981- 990 | 7.9.7.8      | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 4            | 7.6.8        | 3            | 6.8.7        | 7 | 3 |   |   |
        |  991-1000 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 5            | 6.8.5.7      | 2            | 4            | 6.8          | 4.2.3        | 6.5.7        | 5 | 5 |18 |12 | 1: 0.67
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
     In |trials 1001| to 1100 the  | right door   |was indicated | by being     |raised before | the choice   | was made.    |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
   30   | 1101-1110 | 8            | 4.3          | 7.6          | 6.6.5        | 7            | 2            | 5.4          | {7.7.7.7.7   | 3            | 6.6.7        | 4 | 6 | 4 | 6 | 1: 1.50
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {7.6.6.7.8   |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {7.7.6.7     |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   31   | 1111-1120 | 7.7.8        | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 6.7          | 3.3.2        | 4            | {7.6.6.7     | 4.4.4.3      | 7            | 4 | 6 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              | {6.6.8*      |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   | 1121-1130 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 8.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.8          | 3            | 7            | 4 | 6 | 8 |12 | 1: 1.50
 August |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    2   | 1131-1140 | 8            | 4.4.3        | 6            | 5            | 7            | 3.3.3.2      | 4            | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 6 | 4 |   |   |
    "   | 1141-1150 | 7.8          | 4.4.3        | 7.6          | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 4.3          | 7            | 3 | 7 | 9 |11 | 1: 1.22
    3   | 1151-1160 | 7.9.8        | 4.3          | 7.6          | 5            | 6.7          | 2            | 5.4          | 7.6.7.8      | 4.3          | 6.7          | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   | 1161-1170 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 5.4          | 7.8          | 4.3          | 7            | 6 | 4 | 8 |12 | 1: 1.50
    4   | 1171-1180 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 6.7          | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.8          | 4.3          | 6.5.6.7      | 2 | 8 |   |   |
    "   | 1181-1190 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 3.3.2        | 4            | 7.8          | 3            | 7            | 8 | 2 |10 |10 | 1: 1.00
    5   | 1191-1200 | 7.8          | 4.4.3        | 6            | 5            | 6.7          | 3.3.3.2      | 4            | 6.7.8        | 3            | 7            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
        | 1201-1210 | 8            | 4.3          | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 7.8          | 3            | 7            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
    "   | 1211-1220 | 7.8          | 3            | 7.6.5        | 5            | 7            | 2            | 4            | 7.7.6.7.8    | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 |17 |13 | 1: 0.76
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    6   | 1221-1230 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | {6.5.6.6     | 2            | 4            | {5.6.5.7     | 3            | 6.8.6.7      | 7 | 3 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              | {5.6.5.7     |              |              | {9.7.8       |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   | 1231-1240 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 4.5          | 7            | 2            | 4            | 6.7.8        | 3            | 6.7          | 6 | 4 |13 | 7 | 1: 0.54
    7   | 1241-1250 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 4            | 8            | 3            | 8.7          | 8 | 2 |   |   |
    "   | 1251-1260 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 6.5          | 7            | 3.2          | 5.4          | 8            | 3            | 7            | 7 | 3 |   |   |
    "   | 1261-1270 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 5.3.4        | 8            | 3            | 7            | 8 | 2 |23 | 7 | 1: 0.30
    9   | 1271-1280 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 2            | 5.4          | 9.7.8        | 3            | 7            | 8 | 2 |   |   |
    "   | 1281-1290 | 8            | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 4            | 7.8          | 3            | 7            | 8 | 2 |16 | 4 | 1: 0.25
   10   | 1291-1300 | 7.8          | 3            | 7.6          | 5            | 6.7          | 3.2          | 4            | 6.7.8        | 3            | 7            | 5 | 5 |   |   |
    "   | 1301-1310 | 7.8          | 4.3          | 5.6          | 4.5          | 6.7          | 2            | 4            | 6.8          | 3            | 6.8.7        | 3 | 7 |   |   |
    "   | 1311-1320 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 5            | 5.7          | 2            | 4            | 5.7.8        | 3            | 4.6.8.7      | 6 | 4 |14 |16 | 1: 1.14
   11   | 1321-1330 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 5            | 6.7          | 3.2          | 4            | 4.6.7.8      | 2.3          | 5.7          | 4 | 6 |   |   |
    "   | 1331-1340 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 4.5          | 6.7          | 2            | 4            | 6.7.8        | 3            | 7            | 6 | 4 |10 |10 | 1: 1.00
   12   | 1341-1350 | 9.8          | 3            | 6            | 5            | 6.7          | 2            | 4            | 6.7.8        | 3            | 6.7          | 6 | 4 |   |   |
    "   | 1351-1360 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 5            | 6.7          | 2            | 4            | 7.8          | 3            | 6.7          | 6 | 4 |12 | 8 | 1: 0.67
   19   | 1361-1370 | 7.8          | 3            | 6            | 5            | 6.7          | 2            | 4            | 6.7.8        | 3            | 6.7          | 6 | 4 |   |   |
        | 1371-1380 | 9.8          | 3            | 6            | 5            | 7            | 3.2          | 4            | 7.9.8        | 3            | 6.8.7        | 6 | 4 |12 | 8 | 1: 0.67
========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========

[Footnote *: Aided by experimenter.]



After two hundred and fifty trials on problem 2 had been given Julius,
it seemed desirable to introduce a radical change in method in order to
stimulate him to maximal effort. It was therefore decided to force him
to make a round trip through the apparatus in connection with each
choice, and to let this forced labor serve, in the place of confinement,
as punishment for mistakes. This new method yielded peculiar and
characteristic results. They differ from those previously obtained
largely because of the orang utan's remarkably strong tendency to
reenter the box through which he had just passed. This occurred so
persistently, as may be seen in table 9 (June 17, second series, June
18, etc.), that a further modification of method was introduced in that
after the same wrong box had been entered five times in succession, the
experimenter on the next choice of the box confined the animal for a
stated interval, say sixty seconds, in it, and then allowed it to escape
by way of the exit door and choose repeatedly until it finally located
the right box. Were it not for this particular feature of the method,
the number of choices recorded after June 17 would unquestionably be
very much greater than the table indicates.

The new method proved a severe test of the orang utan's patience and
perseverance, for he had to work much harder than formerly for his
reward, and often became much fatigued before completing the regular
series of ten trials. Early in the use of this method, he developed the
habit of rolling around from exit door to starting point by a series of
somersaults. When especially discouraged he would often bump his head
against the floor so hard that I could hear the dull thud. As has been
noted, I found it desirable to vary the procedure repeatedly. It proved
especially interesting to give one series per day with the round trip as
punishment and another series with confinement as punishment.

Day after day, as the experiment progressed, slight or great
fluctuations of the ratios of right to wrong choices appeared, but
without consistent improvement. There was, to be sure, as the last
column of table 9 shows, a radical improvement during the first six
hundred and fifty trials, for the number of right choices per series
increased from 0 to 8. But, as the observations were continued from day
to day, it became more and more evident that the animal was merely
passing from tendency to tendency--method to method--mixing tendencies,
and occasionally developing new ones, without approach to the solution
of the problem. This fact would have led me to discontinue the work much
earlier than I actually did had it not been for the peculiarity of the
results obtained with problem 1. It seemed not improbable that at any
time Julius might succeed in perfectly solving this problem over night
precisely as he had solved the first problem.

A curiously interesting bit of behavior appeared for the first time on
June 29. Julius had gone to the first box at the right end of the group,
and instead of entering, he had wheeled around toward his right, and
turning a complete circle, faced the right box, which he promptly
entered. Subsequently, the tendency developed and the method was used
with increasing frequency. On June 30, it appeared in the first series,
four times, in the second series, six times; on July 1, in the first
series, three times, and in the second series, four times; on July 2, in
the first series, five times, and in the second series, nine times. It
was indeed only by accident that the animal failed to fulfill the
technical requirement for perfect solution of the problem in this
series. Yet, had he done so, his subsequent trials would doubtless have
revealed the lack of any other idea than that of turning completely
around before entering a box.

This odd bit of behavior proved peculiarly interesting and significant
in that the tendency to turn became dissociated from the position (in
front of the first box at the right end of the group) in connection with
which it originally developed. After a few days, Julius would enter the
reaction-chamber and instead of proceeding directly to the right end of
the group, would stop suddenly wherever he happened to be, turn toward
his right in a complete circle, and hasten into the box nearest to him
which, as often as not, proved to be the wrong one. Thus the idea of
turning completely about, which had it continued its association with
the idea of facing the first box at the right, would have yielded
success, instead became useless because of its dissociation. That the
orang utan is capable of using free ideas seems clear enough in the
light of this behavior. That he proved incapable of getting the idea of
second from the right end is as clearly shown by the detailed results of
table 9,--the fruits of weeks of experimenting.

Certain other interesting tricks developed in Julius's behavior. Thus,
on July 5, there appeared the tendency to move as though about to enter
the right box (feint), then to stop suddenly and promptly enter another
box, which was, of course, a wrong one. The reason for the development
of this tendency could not be discovered, but in connection with it,
there appeared another tendency which possibly can be explained. Julius
took to backing into the chosen box so that he could face the
experimenter. He would then, after a period of hesitation, come out and
promptly enter one of the other boxes. This tendency was apparently due
to the fact that during one or two series the experimenter growled at
the orang utan every time he made a mistake. The growl startled him and
caused him to look around. He evidently felt the need of keeping his
eyes on the experimenter,--Hence the backing into the open box. The
tendency disappeared shortly after the experimenter gave up the use of
the growl as a method of punishing the animal for what were suspected to
be careless choices.

Curiously enough, it was not until July 10 that direct choice of the
right box was made at all frequently. Previously, selection of it had
been made almost invariably after approach to other boxes. But in the
second series for July 10 there was an extraordinary improvement in
method. This developed in the presence of two visitors, and it is
therefore all the more surprising. The choices were made not only
directly, but with decision and evident certainty that was quite at
variance with the previous behavior of the animal.

All the while through variation of methods, I was seeking to discover
the best means of holding the orang utan to his maximum effort and care
in attempting to select the right box. One day it would seem as though
forcing him to make round trips with rewards only for correct first
choices proved most satisfactory, and the next it might seem equally
clear that punishment by confinement for thirty seconds or sixty
seconds, with reward for correct choice in every trial, yielded better
results. In the end I had to admit that no best method had been
demonstrated and that I had failed to develop conditions which served to
compel the animal's attention to the problem and to lead him to work
without discouragement. There were, it is true, days on which it seemed
practically certain that the problem would be solved, but as it turned
out, Julius never succeeded in choosing correctly--throughout a series
of ten trials.

As a last resort, in order to make perfectly sure that the orang utan
was doing his best, I decided to introduce corporal punishment in a mild
form. For this purpose, I placed my assistant in charge of the apparatus
and the series of trials, and stationed myself in one corner of the
reaction-chamber with a whip in my hand. Whenever Julius entered a wrong
box, I approached him with the whip and struck at him, being careful not
to injure him and rarely striking him at all, for the threat was more
effective than a blow. He was extremely afraid of the whip and would
begin to whine and attempt to get out of the way as soon as he saw it.

This method was introduced on August 10, but no improvement resulted,
and in the end there was no reason to consider it more satisfactory than
the other procedures. I am now wholly convinced that Julius did his best
to choose correctly in the majority of the numerous series which were
given him in connection with problem 2.

From trials 1001 to 1100, a radical departure from the previous methods
was introduced in that the right box was indicated to the animal by the
slight and momentary raising of its exit door. Of course no records of
the choices for this group of one hundred trials appear in table 9, for
the simple reason that the animal inevitably and immediately entered the
right box. It was thought that this method might serve to break up the
previously developed tendencies toward inadequate forms of response and
so encourage the animal that he would later solve the problem when given
opportunity to select the right box without aid from the experimenter.
But as a matter of fact, while the ratio of right to wrong first choices
was 1 to .67 in the series preceding this change of method, it was 1 to
1.50 in the first series following its use. There is no satisfactory
evidence that Julius profited by this experience, though as a matter of
fact he did succeed in making his best daily record, eight right to two
wrong choices, on August 4, after 1190 trials.

The curve of learning for this problem has been plotted and is presented
in figure 19. It is of course incomplete and it is offered only to
indicate the extreme irregularity in performance.


_Problem 1a. First at the Right End_

It was decided on August 19 that the further continuation of the work of
Julius on problem 2 was not worth while. He had become much discouraged,
and although willing to work for food, gave no indications whatever of
improvement and seemed to have exhausted his methods. It seemed wise
instead of giving up work with him in the multiple-choice method to
return to a form of problem 1. We may designate it as problem 1a. The
right box is definable as the first at the right end of the series
instead of the first at the left end as in the original problem 1. It
was thought possible that Julius might quickly solve this problem by a
process similar to that used for problem 1.

Work was begun on problem 1a, August 20, and for six successive days two
series of trials per day were given, the settings for which as well as
the resulting choices are given in table 10. Most notable in these
results is the large number of cases in which Julius chose first the
second box from the right end of the series, or in other words that box
which had been the right one in problem 2. Contrary to expectation, he
showed no inclination to abandon this tendency to choose the second from
the right end, and the ratio of right to wrong choices changed in the
direction opposite from expectation, beginning with 1 to 4 and ending on
the sixth day with 0 to 20.

It was obviously useless to continue the experiment further since Julius
had given up his attempts to locate the right box in the first choice
and was apparently satisfied to discover it by a process of trial and
error. He had, it would seem, satisfied himself that the problem was
insoluble. These results obtained in problem 1a constitute a most
interesting comment on the effects of problem 2 on the orang utan.
Behavior similar to that which he developed well might have been
obtained from a child of three to four years placed in a like situation
and forced to strive, day after day, to solve a problem beyond its
ideational capacity.

In many respects the most interesting and to the experimenter the most
surprising result of this long series of observations with Julius was
the lack of consistent improvement. It seemed almost incredible that he
should continue, day after day, to make incorrect choices in a
particular setting while choosing correctly in some other setting which
from the standpoint of the experimenter was not more difficult.



TABLE 10

Results for Orang utan in problem 1a


========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========
        |    No.    |     S.1      |     S.2      |     S.3      |     S.4      |     S.5      |     S.6      |     S.7      |     S.8      |     S.9      |     S.10     |   |   |   |   | Ratio
  Date  |    of     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   1.2.3.4    | R | W | R | W |   of
        |  trials   |     5.63     |   1.2.3.4    |   6.7.8.9    |   2.3.4.5    |  3.4.5.6.7   |    1.2.3     |   5.6.7.8    |     1.2      |  2.3.4.5.6   |    5.6.7     |   |   |   |   | R to W
--------+-----------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+---+---+---+---+--------
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
 August |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   20   |    1- 10  | 6            | 3.4          | 6.7.8.9      | 4.5          | 6.7          | 3            | 7.8          | 2            | 5.5.6        | 6.7          | 3 | 7 |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |   11- 20  | 5.6          | 3.4          | {7.8.7.8     | 4.5          | 6.7          | 2.3          | {7.6.7.7     | 2            | 5.6          | 6.7          | 1 | 9 | 4 |16 | 1: 4.00
        |           |              |              | {8.7.8.9     |              |              |              | {6.7.7.8     |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   21   |   21- 30  | 5.6          | 3.4          | {7.8.7.6     | 4.5          | 6.7          | 2.3          | 7.8          | 2            | 5.6          | 5.7          | 1 | 9 |   |   |
        |           |              |              | {8.7.9       |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |   31- 40  | 5.6          | 3.4          | 7.7.6.8.9    | 4.5          | 6.7          | 3            | 6.7.8        | 2            | 6            | 6.7          | 3 | 7 | 4 |16 | 1: 4.00
   23   |   41- 50  | 5.6          | 3.4          | 7.8.9        | 4.5          | 6.7          | 2.3          | 6.7.8        | 2            | 5.6          | 5.6.7        | 1 | 9 |   |   |
    "   |   51- 60  | 5.6          | 3.4          | 7.8.9        | 4.5          | 6.7          | 2.3          | 6.8          | 2            | 5.6          | 6.7          | 1 | 9 | 2 |18 | 1: 9.00
   24   |   61- 70  | 5.6          | 3.4          | 6.8.9        | 4.5          | 5.7          | 2.3          | 6.7.8        | 1.2          | 5.6          | 6.7          | 0 |10 |   |   |
    "   |   71- 80  | 5.6          | 3.4          | 6.7.8.9      | 4.5          | 5.7          | 2.3          | 5.7.8        | 2            | 5.6          | 6.7          | 1 | 9 | 1 |19 | 1:19.00
   25   |   81- 90  | 5.6          | 3.4          | 6.7.8.9      | 5            | 5.6.7        | 2.3          | 7.8          | 1.2          | 5.6          | 4.5.6.7      | 1 | 9 |   |   |
    "   |   91-100  | 5.6          | 3.4          | 6.7.8.9      | 3.4.5        | 6.6.7        | 2.3          | 6.7.8        | 1.2          | 5.6          | 6.7          | 0 |10 | 1 |19 | 1:19.00
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
   26   |  101-110  | 5.6          | 3.4          | {6.7.8.8     | 3.5          | 5.6.7        | 2.3          | 5.6.7.6.7.8  | 1.2          | 5.6          | 6.7          | 0 |10 |   |   |
        |           |              |              | {6.7.6.9     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              | {6.7.8.8     |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
    "   |  111-120  | 5.6          | 2.3.4        | {6.7.8.7     | 3.4.5        | 5.6.7        | 2.3          | 7.8          | 1.2          | 5.6          | 4.5.6.7      | 0 |10 | 0 |20 | 0:20.00
        |           |              |              | {6.7.9*      |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
        |           |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |              |   |   |   |   |
========+===========+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+==============+===+===+===+===+========


[Footnote *: Aided by experimenter.]



The evidence suggests that in this young orang utan ideational learning
tended to replace the simpler mode of problem solution by trial and
error. Seemingly incapable of solving his problems by the lower grade
process, he strove persistently, and often vainly, to gain insight. He
used ideas ineffectively. Animals far lower in intelligence (e.g., the
pig), surpass him in ability to solve these relational problems because
they use the method of elimination by trial consistently and
effectively. Julius, in these experiments, made a poor showing because
his substitute for trial and error is only slightly developed. Would he
have succeeded better with the same problems if mentally mature?

There are many important features of the results which, for lack of
space, have not been indicated or discussed. They can be developed from
later comparative studies of the data, for in the tables appear all of
the essential facts of response apart from those mentioned in the text.



IV

RESULTS OF SUPPLEMENTARY TESTS OF IDEATIONAL BEHAVIOR


1. Julius, _Pongo pygmaeus_


_Box Stacking Experiment_

In addition to the multiple-choice experiments which have been described
in detail in the previous section, it was possible to conduct certain
less systematic tests of ideational behavior in the monkeys and the
orang utan. From the technical standpoint these tests were relatively
unsatisfactory because only inexactly describable. But their results are
in many respects more interesting, if not also more important, in the
light which they throw on ideation than are those previously presented.
First, in order of time, comes a test which may be designated as the box
stacking experiment. The method will now be described in connection with
an account of the behavior of Julius as contrasted with that of a child
of three years and four months of age.

In the large central cage labelled Z, figure 12, which was twenty-four
feet long, ten feet wide, and ten to twelve feet deep, the following
situation was arranged. From the center of the wire covering of the
cage, a banana was suspended on a string so that it was approximately
six feet from the floor, five feet from either side of the cage, and
twelve feet from either end. From all approaches it was far beyond the
reach of Julius, since it was impossible for him to climb along the wire
roof and thus reach the string. Two boxes were placed on the floor of
the cage several feet from the point directly under the banana. The one
of these boxes was heavy and irregular in shape, as is shown in figures
21, 23 and 24 of plate V. Its greatest height was twenty-one inches; its
least height, eighteen inches; its other dimensions, twelve and sixteen
inches respectively. The smaller and lighter box measured twenty-two by
twelve by ten inches. According to the experimenter's calculations, the
only way in which Julius could obtain the banana was by placing the
smaller box upon the larger and then climbing upon them.

At 10 a.m. on March 5, Julius was admitted to the large cage, and the
banana was pointed out to him by the experimenter. He immediately set
about trying to get it, and worked diligently during the whole of the
period of observation, which, because of the unfinished condition of
some of the cages, was limited to slightly over ten minutes. Within this
period he made upward of a dozen fairly well directed attempts to obtain
the food. Chief among them were three attempts to reach the banana from
different positions on the left wall of the cage (as the experimenter
faced the laboratory); two attempts to reach it from different positions
on the right wall; two from the large box in positions nearly under the
banana; two from the large box with the aid of the experimenter's hand;
and one from the distant end of the cage(?). There occurred, also, less
definite and easily describable efforts to get at the reward.

On account of the unfinished condition of the cages, the experimenter
had to remain in the large cage with Julius during the test. This
interfered with the experiment because the animal tended both to try to
escape and to get the experimenter to help him with his task.
Particularly interesting is the latter sort of behavior. After the orang
utan had made two or three futile attempts to obtain the food he came to
the experimenter, who was standing in one corner of the cage, took him
by the hand, and led him to a point directly under the banana. He then
looked up toward the banana, grasped the experimenter's arm, raised it,
and then tried to pull himself up. He was not allowed to get the food by
climbing up on the experimenter. A few minutes later, he again led the
experimenter toward the banana, but receiving discouragement in this
activity, he proceeded to devote himself to other methods.

Apart from the distractions which have been mentioned above, Julius's
attention to the food was surprisingly constant. Whatever his position
with respect to it, he seemed not for an instant to lose his motive, and
to whatever part of the cage he went and whatever he did during the
interval of observation was evidently guided by the strong desire to
obtain the banana. Frequently he would look directly at it for a few
seconds and then try some new method of reaching it. His gaze was
deliberate and in the handling of the boxes he accurately gauged
distances. Several times he succeeded in placing the larger box almost
directly under the banana, and repeatedly he located that portion of the
side wall from which he could most nearly reach the coveted prize.



EXPLANATION OF PLATE V

Orang utan, Julius, obtaining banana by piling boxes
or by using pole

FIGURE 21.--Julius in act of setting larger box on end.

FIGURE 22.--Placing smaller box on larger.

FIGURE 23.--Balancing on larger box preparatory to reaching for banana.

FIGURE 24.--Balancing and reaching to the utmost.

FIGURE 25.--Standing on three boxes (after stacking them) and
reaching for reward.

FIGURE 26.--Lifting smaller box up toward banana.

FIGURE 27.--The act of stacking the boxes.

FIGURE 28.--Sequel to figure 27.

FIGURE 29.--Box and pole experiment. Pushing the second pole
into the box.

FIGURE 30.--Pushing pole into box.

FIGURE 31.--Enjoying the reward of success.



From my notes I quote the following comment on the results of the
initial experiment: "Despite all that has been written concerning the
intelligent behavior of the orang utan, I was amazed by Julius's
behavior this morning, for it was far more deliberate and apparently
reflective as well as more persistently directed toward the goal than I
had anticipated. I had looked for sporadic attempts to obtain the
banana, with speedy discouragement and such fluctuations of attention as
would be exhibited by a child of two to four years. But in less than ten
minutes Julius made at least ten obvious and well directed attempts to
reach the food. There were also wanderings, efforts to obtain aid from
the experimenter, and varied attempts to escape from the cage."

Before proceeding further with the description of the behavior of Julius
in the box stacking test, I shall describe for contrast the behavior of
a boy three years four months of age when confronted with a situation
practically identical with that which the ape was given an opportunity
to meet. For the child, the banana was suspended, as previously
described, from the roof of the cage. The same two boxes were placed on
the floor at considerable distances from the banana, and in addition, a
light stick, about six feet long, and a piece of board, the latter by
accident, were on the floor. The child was asked to get the banana for
Julius, and he eagerly and confidently volunteered to do so.

His behavior may best be described by enumeration of the several
attempts made. They include (1) placing the larger box nearly under the
banana and reaching from it. (2) Standing of the larger box on end with
resulting failure because the child could not stand on the sloping edges
of the top of the box. (3) The larger box was turned on its side and the
lighter box drawn up opposite it and stood on end. The child then
mounted the larger box and from it stepped to the top of the smaller.
But the boxes had not been placed beneath the banana, and when the child
reached for it, he found himself several feet away from his prize. (4)
The boxes were moved to a position nearly under the banana and another
futile attempt was made to reach it without placing the smaller box on
top of the larger one, the only position from which the child could
readily obtain it. (5) The piece of board was placed on top of the
larger box and from this height the child again reached upward. (6) The
six-foot stick was taken up and an attempt was made to strike the banana
and thus dislodge it, but it was too securely fastened to be obtained
thus. (7) Attention shifted to other things, and the child played for a
time with the board. Reminded of the banana by the experimenter, he
again tried method (3). (8) He again used the stick on the banana. (9)
The effort to knock the prize to the floor having failed, he became
discouraged and said that he must go home. (10) When told that Julius
was very hungry and wanted the banana, he repeated efforts similar to
those described in (3) and (6).

Up to this time the observations had covered a period of twenty minutes.
The child was now taken from the cage and allowed to play about for
fifteen minutes. Asked then whether he would go back and try to get the
banana, he replied, "No, 'cause I don't want to get it," thus indicating
his discouragement with the situation. When taken into the cage, he,
nevertheless, made the additional attempts indicated below: (11) Use of
one of the boxes. (12) He remarked, "Now I know, I'll get it," and after
so saying, repeated (3). (13) Failing, he turned to me and said, "I
could get it if I was on your head," but he did not, as Julius had done,
lead me to the proper place and try to reach the banana by climbing up
or by urging me to lift him. (14) Later, he played in the boxes,
apparently forgetful of his task. Finally he remarked: "I'll get the
banana," but he made no attempt to do so, and instead, watched the
monkeys intently. Thereafter, he showed no further interest in the
solution of the problem, and the experiment, after a total period of
fifty-five minutes, was discontinued.

Comparison of the behavior of the ape with that of the child indicates a
greater variety of ideas for the latter. Julius gauged his distances
much more accurately than the child, attended more steadily, and worked
more persistently to obtain the reward, but he did not so nearly
approach the idea of stacking the boxes as did the child, for the
latter, in placing the board on one of the boxes, exhibited in
ineffective form the idea which should have yielded the solution of the
problem.

The child was given no further opportunity to work at the problem,
whereas Julius, as I shall now describe, continued his efforts on
subsequent days under somewhat different conditions. On Wednesday, March
10, the banana was suspended as formerly, and three boxes, all of them
small and light enough to be readily handled by the ape, were placed in
distant parts of the cage. The six-foot stick which had been present in
the test with the child, but not in the first test with Julius, was also
placed in the cage.

Julius was allowed to work for about an hour. As formerly, he was
sufficiently hungry to be eager to get the food and evidently tried all
of the possible ways which occurred to him. Chief among these were (1)
the use of the various boxes separately or in pairs in very varied
positions but never with one upon another,--the only way in which the
banana could be reached; (2) climbing to various points on the sides of
the cage, with infrequent attempts to reach the banana. Usually his eyes
saved him the vain effort.

Unlike the child, Julius paid little attention to the six-foot stick.
Two or three times he took it up and seemingly reached for the banana,
but in no case did he try persistently to strike it and knock it from
the string. It is but fair, however, to remark that such an act is very
difficult for the young orang utan, as compared with the child, because
of the weakness of the legs and the awkwardness of striking from a
sitting posture. As previously, the steadiness of attention and the
persistence of effort toward the end in view were most surprising. At
one time Julius walked to the end of the cage and there happened to see
one of the monkeys eating. He watched intently a few seconds and then
hastened back to the banana as if his task had been suggested to him by
the sight of the feeding animal. Most interesting and significant in
this behavior was the suddenness with which he would turn to a new
method. It often looked precisely as though a new idea had come to him,
and he was all eagerness to try it out.

On March 11, Julius was given another opportunity to obtain the banana
by the use of the three boxes. Although he used them together he made no
effort to place one upon another. Certain of his methods are shown in
plate V, especially by figures 21, 23 and 24.

This experiment was continued on April 2 under yet different conditions,
for this time only two boxes were placed in the cage, the one of them
the heavy, irregularly-shaped box and the other the smaller, lighter one
originally used. On the end of the heavier box had been nailed a two by
two inch wooden block in order to increase the difficulty in using this
box alone. As previously, Julius made varied attempts to obtain the
banana, but on the whole his interest and attention seemed somewhat
weaker than previously and there were indications of discouragement
because of repeated failures.

He handled the boxes conspicuously well, and it seemed at times that he
would certainly succeed in placing the one upon the other and in
reaching the food.

After one series of attempts from the sides of the cage and from the
large box, he deliberately turned away from the box and neatly executed
a somersault on the floor of the cage, as much as to say, "I am
disgusted with the whole situation." Again, later on the same day, after
falling from the top of the larger box, which tilted over very easily,
he rolled himself into a ball, and childlike, played with his feet. An
additional evidence of his changed affective attitude toward his task,
especially in connection with definite failures, appeared in his rough
handling and biting of the boxes. When most impatient, he worked very
roughly.

Julius was allowed to work for the reward from thirty to ninety minutes,
or, as a rule, until he had become completely discouraged on April 3, 5,
6, 7, 8, 9 and 13. His behavior was interesting and significant, but
nothing new appeared except that his willingness to work gradually
disappeared, and on April 13, although previously hungry, he made only a
single attempt to obtain the banana and then paid no further attention
to it.

The prolonged and varied efforts to obtain the banana were due in a
measure at least to three accidental successes. Thus on April 2, 3 and
again on the 5th, by fortunate combinations of circumstances, he
succeeded in getting the banana, contrary to the intention of the
experimenter.

Although active at first on April 6, he soon wearied of his task and
quit work. The same was true on April 7, and again on the 8th and 9th.
On these days, although hungry, he did not care to enter the large cage
and worked only a few minutes each day, seldom making more than two or
three half-hearted attempts to obtain the banana. His attitude toward
the task had changed completely, in that hopelessness had taken the
place of eager expectancy. By the 13th of April he had so nearly given
up voluntary efforts to solve the problem that it seemed worth while to
test his ability to get the idea by watching the experimenter. For this
purpose the following test of imitation was made.

On the morning of April 14, having placed a banana in the usual
position, I took Julius into the large cage, dragged the two boxes to
the proper position beneath the banana, placed the smaller one upon the
larger one and then climbed up on them to show the ape that I could
reach the banana. I then stepped down and gave him a chance to climb on
the boxes. He did so immediately and obtained the food.

Another piece of banana was supplied, the boxes were placed in distant
corners of the cage, and fifteen minutes were allowed Julius so to place
them that he could obtain his reward. He gave no indications of having
profited by my demonstration, but worked with the boxes singly, usually
with the larger one. On April 16, with the banana in position and the
two boxes also in the cage, Julius was admitted and allowed to work for
five minutes, but again without success. I then placed the boxes
properly for him and he immediately climbed up and got the banana. While
he was eating, the boxes were carried to distant corners of the cage and
another banana placed in position. Now thirty minutes were allowed him
for unaided work on the problem. As formerly, the larger box was used
repeatedly and attempts to reach from the side of the cage appeared, but
there was no tendency to try to use the two boxes together. He worked
fairly persistently, however, and showed clearly the stimulating and
encouraging effect of aid from the experimenter. Once more, on April 17,
Julius was taken into the cage and allowed to watch me place the boxes
in proper position. He then climbed up and obtained the desired food.
After the bait had been renewed and the boxes displaced, he immediately
tried to use the larger one, then he reached for the small one as though
to use both together. But the impulse died out and he turned again to
the larger box as usual, standing it on end, and persistently trying to
balance himself on it. Nothing else of special interest happened during
the interval of unaided effort.

Similarly, I placed the boxes for the ape on April 19, allowed him to
get the banana and then gave him opportunity to try for himself after
the boxes had been displaced. This time he immediately reached for the
smaller box and moved it about a little, thus indicating a new
association. He next turned to the larger box and worked with it
persistently. Later, he once more worked with the smaller box in an
unusual manner. He repeatedly stood on it, but made no attempt to lift
it or to place it on the larger box. Clearly the usually neglected
smaller box had become associated with the satisfaction of obtaining the
banana. The same method was carried out on April 20. As I placed the
boxes in position beneath the banana, Julius watched with unusual
intentness, and when it came his turn to try to obtain the food by the
use of the boxes, he began at once to work with the smaller box, but as
on April 19, he soon abandoned it and turned to the other. While I was
making note of this particular feature of his behavior, he suddenly
seized the smaller box by two corners with his hands and by one edge
with his teeth, and after a few attempts placed it on top of the larger
box, climbed up, and obtained the banana.

Because of bad weather on April 21, the next test was made on April 22,
with everything as usual. Unaided, the ape was given an opportunity to
obtain the coveted reward, while I stood ready to obtain records of his
behavior with my camera. He wasted no time, but piled the smaller box on
top of the larger one immediately, and obtained his reward. As soon as
opportunity was offered, he repeated the performance. The same thing
happened on April 23 and several succeeding dates.

Julius had got the idea, and the only further improvement possible was
in skill in manipulating the boxes.

One of the curious performances which appeared during the imitative
period is pictured in figure 26, plate V, where the ape is seen lifting
the smaller box into the air. This he did three or four times one day,
raising it toward the banana each time as though he expected thus to
obtain the reward. As he did not go up with the box (according to his
expectation?), he abandoned this method, and looking about, discovered
the larger box in a distant corner. Thereupon, he promptly pulled the
boxes to their proper position beneath the banana, stacked them, and
obtained his food.

After considerable skill had been acquired in the placing of the boxes,
the one upon the other, the height of the banana above the floor was
increased so that three boxes were necessary. Figure 25 of plate V shows
him standing on three boxes and reaching upward, and figures 22, 27 and
28 show various modes of handling the boxes and of reaching from them.
He was not at all particular as to the stability of his perch, and often
mounted the boxes when it seemed to the experimenter inevitable that
they should topple over and precipitate him to the floor. Only once,
however, during the several days of experimentation did he thus fall.

Obviously important is the evident change in the animal's attention on
April 20. He watched with a keenness of interest which betokened a
dawning idea. Before he had succeeded in stacking the boxes, I had
written in my note-book, "He seemed much interested today, in my placing
of the boxes." Interesting, and important also, is the ease and
efficiency with which he met the situation time after time, after this
first success. "Trial and error" had no obvious part in the development
of the really essential features of the behavior. The ape had the idea
and upon it depended for guidance.

Except for the fact that Julius was immature, probably under five years
of age, it is likely that he would have stacked the boxes spontaneously
instead of by suggestion from the experimenter or imitatively.

No unprejudiced psychologist would be likely to interpret the activities
of the orang utan in the box-stacking experiment as other than imaginal
or ideational. He went directly, and in the most business-like way from
point to point, from method to method, trying in turn and more or less
persistently or repeatedly, almost all of the possible ways of obtaining
the coveted food. The fact that he did not happen upon the only certain
road to success is surprising indeed in view of the many ineffective
methods which he used. It seemed almost as though he avoided the easy
method.

It is especially important, in connection with these results, to point
out the risk of misinterpretation of observations on the anthropoid
apes. If they can imitate human activities as readily and effectively as
Julius did in this particular experiment, we can never be sure of the
spontaneity of their ideational behavior unless we definitely know that
they have had no opportunity to see human beings perform similar acts.

Of all the methods of eliciting ideational or allied forms of behavior
used in my study of the monkeys and ape, none yielded such illuminating
results as the box stacking test, and although from the technical
standpoint, it has many shortcomings, as a means to qualitative results
it has proved invaluable.


_Other Methods of Obtaining the Reward_

Some weeks later, I tried to discover how Julius would obtain the much
desired banana when the boxes were absent. I placed in the large cage a
stick about six feet long and an old broom. When admitted, he looked
about for the boxes, but not seeing them, picked up the broom and
placing it with the splints down, beneath the banana, he tried to climb
it, but as it fell over with him, he abandoned this after a few trials,
went to his cage, and picking up some old bags which he used at night as
covers, he dragged them out and placed them on the floor beneath the
banana. He next put the broom upon them and tried to climb up. This
general type of behavior persisted for several minutes, everything
within reach being used as were the bags, as a means of raising him in
the desired direction. Finally, he placed his feet on the broom where
the handle joins the splints, seized the handle near the top with his
hands, drew himself up as far as possible, and then launched himself in
the air and tried to seize the banana. On the third attempt he
succeeded.

Later, he was given a plain stick about five feet long. Figure 32 of
plate VI shows him using this to obtain the banana in the manner
described above. He would grasp it with one or both feet, usually one,
ten to fifteen inches from the floor of the cage, meanwhile holding with
his hands near the top of the stick. He would then, with all his
strength, draw himself up suddenly and jump toward the banana. Often he
came down rather hard on the cement floor, much to his disgust.

Yet another method of obtaining the reward developed a day or two later.
A light red-wood stick about five feet long and an inch in its other
dimensions was the only object in the cage which could possibly be of
use in obtaining the banana. The aim of the experimenter was to discover
whether Julius would use this as a club.

Previously, in connection with the use of the boxes, he had taken up the
same stick two or three times and reached for the banana with it, but in
no case had he struck at it or clearly tried to knock it from the
string, as did the child most readily and naturally. When provided with
this same stick, and it alone, as a means of obtaining the food, he hit
upon the following interesting method. Placing one end of the stick
between a wooden brace and the wire side of the cage, he climbed up to a
level with the banana as is shown in figure 33 of plate VI. Then holding
with one hand and one foot to a timber of the cage and to the stick with
his other foot, he swung outward as far as possible and reached the
banana with his free hand. Having once succeeded by the method, he used
it whenever given an opportunity. It was impossible for him to make the
reach without the use of the small stick, while with it he succeeded
fairly easily and regularly.


_Box and Pole Experiment_

Following the box stacking test, Julius was given an opportunity to
exhibit ideation in another type of experiment. This may be designated
the box and pole test. The conditions are describable thus. A strong
wooden box eighty-four inches long, by four inches wide, by four inches
deep, with open ends, was built with one side hinged. Hasps and padlocks
enabled the experimenter to lock this "lid" after food had been placed
in the center of the box. This box could be placed in the center of the
large cage and there fastened by means of cross bars. It is well shown
in position in figure 29, plate V. Two poles each eight feet long and
approximately one and a half inches in their other dimensions were the
only additional materials in the experiment.

On May 1, Julius was allowed to see the experimenter place a half banana
in this box, close the lid, lock it in position, and securely fasten the
box by means of the cross bars. He was then given opportunity to try to
get the banana. The two poles lay on opposite sides of the box and near
the edges of the cage. Doctor Hamilton and the writer were in the cage
watching. Julius looked into the box through one end, and seeing the
banana, reached for it. He could not obtain it in this way, so he began
to bite at the box and to pull at it with all his strength. During the
fifteen minutes allowed him, he worked at the box in a great variety of
ways, fooling with the locks which had been attached to the hasps as
well as with the cross bars and continually reaching in at the one or
the other end. He was somewhat distracted by the presence of the two
observers and attended rather unsatisfactorily to the task in hand. Not
once did he touch the poles, and it is doubtful whether he even noticed
them. He was not very hungry at this time, and after a few minutes
active work he virtually gave up trying to get the food.

Two days later, on May 3, the box was once more placed in position, this
time with a half banana in the middle and a small piece of banana near
each open end. The two poles lay on the floor of the cage, each several
feet distant from the box. Julius was eager for food. When released he
went immediately to the box, reached in and obtained a piece of banana
from the end nearer the laboratory. He then looked in and saw the piece
near the middle of the box. His next move was to pick up the eight foot
pole and push it into the box, but before pushing it all the way
through, he stopped and began to pull at the box in various ways.
Shortly he returned to the pole and twice thrust it in as far as he
could reach. The first time, after thrusting it all the way through, he
pulled it out and examined the end as though expecting the banana to
come out with it. After a third attempt he looked into the box,
presumably seeing the banana, then turned a backward somersault, came to
the end of the cage, and looked at me. Had it been at all possible, he
would have taken me by the hand and led me to the box as a helper. After
a few seconds, he returned to the pole, pried the lid of the box with
it, then gnawed at the pole. For about five minutes he worked fairly
rapidly and steadily, using the poles, pulling, gnawing, and walking
about.

His next move was to go to the opposite end of the box, look in, take
the piece of banana which was near the opening, then pick up the second
pole, which had not previously been noticed, and after a number of
attempts, push it into and through the box, looking after it and then
pulling it out and looking into the box. Having done this he again came
to my end of the cage, and from there returned to try once more with the
pole which he had first used. He pushed this pole all the way through,
then walked to the other end of the box, looked in and reaching in,
obtained the banana which had been pushed far enough along to be within
his grasp. Figures 29, 30 and 31 of plate V show stages of this process.

Julius had worked twenty-four minutes with relatively little lost time
before succeeding. He had shown almost from the start the idea of using
the pole as an instrument, and his sole difficulty was in making the
pole serve the desired purpose.

The experiment was rendered still more crucial on May 5 by the placing
of the two poles upright in opposite corners of the large cage. For a
few minutes after he entered the cage, Julius did not see them, and his
time was spent pulling and gnawing at the box. Then he discovered one of
the poles, seized it, and pushed it into the box. He tried four times,
then went and got the other pole and pushed it into the opposite end of
the box. Twice he did this, then he returned to the original pole,
bringing the second one with him. He pushed it in beside the first, and
as it happened, shoved the banana out of the opposite end of the box.
But he did not see this, and only after several seconds when he happened
to walk to that end of the box did he discover the banana. The total
time until success was fifteen minutes.

Subsequently the ape became very expert in using the pole to obtain the
banana, and often only a minute or two sufficed for success. It was not
possible for him to direct the stick very accurately, for when he was in
such a position that he could look through the box, he could not work
the stick itself. It was, therefore, always a matter of chance whether
he obtained the banana immediately or only after a number of trials.

Although it is possible that the use of the poles in this experiment was
due to observation of human activities, it seems probable in the light
of what we know of the natural behavior of the anthropoid apes that
Julius would have solved this problem independently of human influence.
It was the expectation of the experimenter that the pole would be used
to push the banana through the box, but as a matter of fact the ape used
it, first of all, to pull the food toward him, thus indicating a natural
tendency which is important in connection with the statements just made.
Subsequently he learned that the banana must be pushed through and
obtained at the farther end of the box. I am not prepared to accept the
solution of this problem as satisfactory evidence of ideation, but I do
know that few observers could have watched the behavior of the orang
utan without being convinced that he was acting ideationally.


_Draw-in Experiment_

An interesting contrast with the box and pole test is furnished by what
may be called the draw-in experiment. This was planned as a simple test
of Julius's ability to use a stick to draw things into his cage from
beyond the wire side. A board was placed, as is shown in figure 34 of
plate VI, with sides to hold a banana, carrot, or some other bit of
food, in position. In the actual test either a carrot or a banana was
placed about two feet from the wire netting and a stick two feet long
was then put into the cage with the ape.

When this situation was first presented to Julius, he looked at the
banana, reached for it, and failing, picked up a bag from the floor of
the cage and tried to push it through the wire mesh toward the banana.
He also used a bit of wire in the same way, but was unable thus to get
the food. As soon as a stick was placed in his cage, he grasped it and
used it in a very definite, although unskillful, way to pull the banana
toward him. He was extremely eager and impatient, but nevertheless
persistent in his efforts, and within five minutes from the beginning of
the first trial, he had succeeded in getting two pieces of banana, using
always his left hand to manipulate the stick. This test was repeated a
number of times with similar results. He had from the first the ability
to use a stick in this way, and the only difficulty with the test as a
means of obtaining evidence of ideational behavior is that the
possibility of imitation of man cannot be certainly excluded.


_Lock and Key Test_

By my assistant it was reported on May 5 that the orang utan had been
seen to place a splinter of wood in a padlock which was used on the
cages and to work with it persistently. It looked very much like
imitation of the human act of using the key, and I therefore planned a
test to ascertain whether Julius could readily and skillfully use a key
or could learn quickly to do so by watching me.

The first test was made on May 15 with a heavy box whose hinged lid was
held securely in position by means of a hasp and a padlock. The key,
which was not more than an inch in length, was fastened to a six inch
piece of wire so that Julius could not readily lose it. With the animal
opposite me, I placed a piece of banana in the box, then closed the lid
and snapped the padlock. I next handed Julius the key. He immediately
laid it on the floor opposite him and began biting the box, rolling it
around, and occasionally biting also at the lock and pulling at it.
During these activities he had pulled the box toward his cage. Now he
suddenly looked up to the position where the banana had been suspended
in the box experiment. Evidently the box had suggested to him the
banana. For thirty minutes he struggled with the box almost
continuously, chewing persistently at the hinges, the hasp, or the lock.
Then he took the key in his teeth and tried to push it into one of the
hinges, then into the crack beneath the lid of the box.

Subsequently I allowed him to see me use the key repeatedly, and as a
result, he came to use it himself now and then on the edge of the box,
but he never succeeded in placing it in the lock, and the outcome of the
experiment was total failure on the part of the animal to unfasten the
lock of his own initiative or to learn to use the key by watching me do
so. I did not make any special attempt to teach him to use the key, but
merely gave him opportunity to imitate, and it is by no means impossible
that he would have succeeded had the key been larger and had the
situation required less accurately coordinated movements. However, it is
fair to say that the evidence of the idea of using the key in the lock
was unconvincing. My assistant's observation was, perhaps, misleading in
so far as it suggested that idea. It may and probably was purely by
accident that the animal used the splinter on the padlock.


2. Skirrl, _Pithecus irus_


_Box Stacking Experiment_

The monkey Skirrl was tested by means of the box stacking experiment
much as Julius had been. On August 23, with a carrot suspended six feet
from the floor of the large cage and three boxes in distant corners, the
animal was admitted and his behavior noted.

The boxes, which were made of light, thin material, ranged in size from
one six inches in its several dimensions to one twenty inches long,
thirteen inches wide, and eleven inches deep. Only by using at least two
of these boxes was it possible for the animal to reach the carrot.

Immediately on admission to the cage, Skirrl began to gnaw at the boxes,
trying with all his might to tear them to pieces. After some thirty
minutes of such effort, interrupted by wanderings about the cage and
attempts to get at the other monkeys, he suddenly went to the largest
box of all, set it up on end almost directly under the carrot, mounted
it, and looked up at the food. It was still beyond his reach and he made
no effort to get it, but instead, he reached from his perch on the big
box for the next smaller box, which was approximately sixteen inches, by
fourteen, by twelve. This he succeeded in pulling toward him, at the
same time raising it slightly from the floor, but his efforts caused the
large box to topple over and he quit work. The experiment was
discontinued after a few minutes, the total period of observation having
been thirty-five minutes.

Skirrl handled the boxes with ease and with evident pleasure and
interest. He also noticed the carrot at various times during the
interval, but his attention was fixed on it only for short periods.

The test was continued on August 24 when, instead of a carrot, a half
banana was used as bait. It was placed only five feet from the floor,
and three boxes were as formerly placed in distant corners of the cage.
When admitted, Skirrl looked at the banana, then pulled one of the boxes
toward it, but instead of mounting, he went to the smallest box and
began to gnaw it. Shortly, he mounted the middle sized box and looked up
toward the banana, but the box was not directly under the bait, and in
any event, it would have been impossible for him to reach it. He next
went to the largest box, gnawed it vigorously, turned it over several
times, and then abandoned it for the middle sized box, from which by
skillful use of his teeth and hands, he quickly tore off one side.

By this time, apparently without very definitely directed effort on the
part of the monkey, all three of the boxes were in the center of the
cage and almost directly beneath the banana. Skirrl climbed up on the
largest box and made efforts to pull the middle sized one up on to it,
the while looking at the banana every few seconds. He did not succeed in
getting the boxes properly placed, and after a time began moving them
about restlessly.

His behavior plainly indicated that hunger was not his chief motive. He
was more interested in playing with things or in working with them than
in eating, and the satisfaction of tearing a box to pieces seemed even
greater than that of food. It is especially noteworthy that when Skirrl
attempts to dismember a box, instead of starting at random, he searches
carefully for a favorable starting point, a place where a board is
slightly loosened or where a slight crack or hole enables him to insert
his hand or use his teeth effectively. Many times during this experiment
he was observed to examine the boxes on all sides in search of some weak
point. If no such weak point were found, he shortly left the box; but if
he did find a favorable spot, he usually succeeded, before he gave up
the attempt, in doing considerable damage to the box.

Following the behavior described above, Skirrl returned to the middle
sized box, placed it on end under the banana, mounted, and looked upward
at the bait, but as it was a few inches beyond his reach, he made no
attempt to get it, but instead, after a few seconds, went to the
smallest box, and finding a weak point, began to tear it to pieces.

Later he rolled what was left of the smallest box close to the other two
boxes, nearly under the banana, and the remainder of his time was spent
gnawing at the boxes and playing with pieces which he had succeeded in
tearing from them. During the remainder of the thirty minute interval of
observation, no further attention was given the bait.

Again, on August 25, the test was tried, but this time with boxes whose
edges had been bound with tin so that it was impossible for the monkey
to destroy them. He spent several minutes searching for a starting point
on the middle sized box, but finding none, he dragged it under the
banana, looked up, mounted the box, but, as previously, did not reach
for the bait because it was beyond his reach. He then played with the
boxes for several minutes. Finally he worked the two smaller boxes to a
position directly under the banana, put the middle sized one on end,
mounted it, and looked at the bait, but again abandoned the attempt
without reaching.

During the thirty minutes of observation he made no definite effort to
place one box upon another. Three times he mounted one or another of the
boxes when it was under the banana or nearly so, but in no case was it
possible for him to reach the bait.

From the above description of this monkey's behavior, it seems fairly
certain that with sufficient opportunity, under strong hunger, he would
ultimately succeed in obtaining the bait by the use of two or more
boxes. For his somewhat abortive and never long continued efforts to
drag two boxes together or to place the one upon the other clearly
enough indicate a tendency which would ultimately yield success. The
possibility of imitation is not excluded, for Skirrl had opportunities
to see Julius and the experimenter handle the boxes.

Because of the other work which seemed more important at the time, this
experiment was not continued further. The results obtained suggest the
desirability of testing thoroughly the ability of monkeys to use objects
as only the anthropoid apes and man have heretofore been thought capable
of using them.


_Box and Pole Experiment_

Skirrl was first tested with the box and pole experiment on August 12.
As in the case of Julius, a half banana was placed in the middle of the
long box and the attention of the monkey was attracted to the bait by
small pieces of carrot placed near each open end. Two poles were placed
near the box on the floor of the cage. When admitted to the cage Skirrl
went almost directly to the ends of the box, took the pieces of carrot
which were in sight, but apparently failed to perceive the bait in the
middle of the box. For a while he played with the locks on the box,
shoved it about, and amused himself with it, showing no interest in
obtaining the food. Later he looked through the box and saw the banana.
He then dragged the box about, apparently trying to get it into his
cage, but he gave no attention to the poles nor did he make any evident
effort to obtain the banana which was easily visible in the center of
the box. The period of observation was only twelve minutes.

On August 24 this experiment was repeated with an important modification
of the apparatus in that the wooden lid of the long box had been
replaced by a wire cover through which the animal could see the bait.
Two poles were as formerly on the floor of the cage, not far from the
box. Skirrl almost immediately noticed the banana and tried to get it by
gnawing at the box. He did not once reach in at the ends of the box, but
he did handle the poles, throwing them about and pounding with them.
There was not the slightest attempt to use them in obtaining the bait.

This experiment was later repeated three times at intervals of a number
of days, but in no case did Skirrl show any tendency to use the poles as
means of obtaining the food.


_Draw-in Experiment_

This also was arranged in the same manner as for Julius, and on each of
five days Skirrl was allowed at least thirty minutes to work for the
bait. Either a banana or a carrot was each day placed on the board well
beyond his reach, and one or two, usually two, small sticks were put
into his cage. Not once during the several periods of observation did
Skirrl make any attempt to use a stick or any other object as a means of
drawing the food to him. Instead, he reached persistently with his arm,
pulled and gnawed at the wires which were in his way, and occasionally
picked up and gnawed or pounded with the sticks in the cage. His
attention every now and then would come back to the food, but it tended
to fluctuate rather rapidly, and in the regular period of observation,
thirty minutes, it is unlikely that he attended to the bait itself for
as much as five minutes. In this respect as well as many others,
Skirrl's behavior contrasts sharply with that of the orang utan.

The results of this experiment indicate the lack in the monkey of any
tendency or ability, apart from training, to use objects as means of
obtaining food. Ways of using objects as tools which apparently are
perfectly natural to the anthropoid apes and to man are rarely employed
by the lower primates.


_Hammer and Nail Test_

One day I happened to observe Skirrl playing with a staple in his cage.
He had found it on the floor where it had fallen and was intently
prodding himself with the sharp points, apparently enjoying the unusual
sensations which he got from sticking the staple into the skin in
various portions of his body, and especially into the prepuce.

A few days later I saw him playing in similar fashion with a nail which
he had found, and still later he was seen to be using a stick to pound
the nail with. This suggested to me the hammer and nail test.

A heavy spike was driven into an old hammer to serve as an
indestructible handle. This hammer, along with a number of large wire
nails and a piece of redwood board, was then placed in the monkey's
cage. Skirrl immediately took up the hammer, grasping the middle of the
handle with his left hand, and with his right hand taking up a nail. He
then sat down on the board, examined the nail, placed the pointed end on
the board, and with well directed strokes by the use of the head of the
hammer drove the nail into the board for the distance of at least an
inch. He then tried to pull it out, but was forced to knock it several
times with the hammer before he could do so.

This performance, during the next few minutes, was repeated several
times with variations. Often the side of the hammer was used instead of
the head, and occasionally, as is shown in figure 8 of plate II, he
seized the hammer well up toward the juncture of the same with the
spike. This figure does justice to the performance. At the moment the
picture was taken, Skirrl's attention had been attracted by a monkey in
an adjoining cage, and he had momentarily looked up from his task, the
while holding nail and hammer perfectly still.

This test was repeated on various days, and almost uniformly Skirrl
showed intense interest in hammer and nails and used them more or less
persistently in the manner described. Occasionally, apparently for the
sake of variety, he would put the blunt end of the nail on the board and
hammer on the point. Again, he would try persistently to drive the nail
into the cement floor, and once by accident, when hammer and nails were
left in his cage over night, he succeeded in making several holes in the
bottom of his sheet iron water pan. There was no doubting the keen
satisfaction which the animal took in this form of activity.

It is impossible to say that the behavior was not imitative of man, for
Skirrl, along with all of the other monkeys, had had abundant
opportunity to see carpenters working. But this much can be said against
the idea of imitation,--no one of the other animals, not excepting the
orang utan, showed any interest whatever in hammer and nails.
Occasionally they would be played with momentarily or pushed about, but
Sobke, Jimmie, Gertie, Julius, although given several opportunities to
exhibit any ability which they might have to drive nails, made not the
least attempt to do so. Evidently we must either conclude that Skirrl
had a peculiarly strong imitative tendency in this direction, or
instead, a pronounced disposition or instinct for the use of objects as
tools. It would seem fair to speak of it as an instinct for mechanical
activity.

Under this same heading may be described Skirrl's reactions to such
objects as a handsaw, a padlock, and a water faucet. The saw was given
to him in order to test his ability to use it in human fashion, for if
he could so expertly imitate the carpenter driving nails, it seems
likely that he might also imitate the use of the saw.

As a matter of fact, he showed no tendency to use the saw as we do.
Instead, he persistently played with it in various ways, at first using
it as a sort of plane to scrape with, later often rubbing the teeth over
a board so that they cut fairly well, but never as effectively as in the
hands of a man. After two or three days' practice with the saw, Skirrl
hit upon a method which is, as I understand, used by man in certain
countries, namely, that of placing the saw with the teeth up, holding it
rigid, and then rubbing the object which is to be sawed over it. This
Skirrl succeeded in doing very skillfully, for he would sit down on the
floor of the cage, grip with both feet the handle of the saw, with the
teeth directed upward, then holding either end in his hands, he would
repeatedly rub a stick over the teeth. In this way, of course, he could
make the saw cut fairly well. But still more to his liking was the use
of a spike instead of a stick as an object to rub over the teeth, for
with this he was able to make a noise that would have satisfied even a
small boy.

Further light is shed on the force of the tendency to imitate man by the
saw test. After Skirrl had been given an opportunity to show what he
could do with the tool spontaneously, I demonstrated to him the approved
human way of sawing. Often he would watch my performance intently as
though fascinated by the sound and motion, but when given the tool he
invariably followed his own methods. Although I repeated this test of
imitation several times on three different days, the results were wholly
negative.


_Other Activities_

One day as Skirrl was being returned to his own cage by way of the
larger cage, he picked up an unfastened padlock and carried it into the
cage with him. For more than an hour he amused himself almost without
interruption by playing with this lock. The things which he did with it
during that time would require pages to describe. His interest in it was
very similar to that which he had exhibited in hammer and nails, saw,
and indeed any objects which he could play with. The lock was pounded in
various ways, bitten, poked with nails, hooked into the wires of the
cage, used to pull on, pounded with a stick, used to hammer on the floor
of the cage with, and in fine, manipulated in quite as great a variety
of ways as a human being could have discovered. Finally it was hooked to
the side of the cage and snapped shut, and as Skirrl was unable to
dislodge it from this position, he shortly gave up playing with it.

At the end of the large cage and just outside the wire netting was a
faucet to which a hose was usually attached. The valve could be opened
by turning a wheel-shaped hand piece. Both Skirrl and Julius learned to
turn this wheel in order to get water to play with, but usually the
former's strength was not sufficient to turn on the water. The latter
could do it readily. The indications are that both animals profited by
seeing human beings turn on the water. This unquestionably attracted
their attention to the faucet, and probably by playing with it they
accidentally happened upon the proper movement. At any rate, Skirrl's
behavior was significant in this connection, for he would pick up the
hose to see if water were flowing, and if it were not, he would throw it
down, go directly to the faucet, and try to turn the wheel. The
association of the wheel with the desired flow of water was therefore
definitely established. Shall we describe the act as ideational? It
seems the natural thing to do.


3. Sobke, _Pithecus rhesus_


_Box Stacking Experiment_

For this test, in the case of Sobke, three light boxes made of redwood
about one-third of an inch thick were used. The smallest, box 1, was six
inches in each direction, the next larger, box 2, was twelve inches, and
the third, box 3, eighteen inches. As in the case of the other animals,
bait, either banana or carrot, was suspended from the middle of the roof
of the large cage at such distance from the floor as to be reached by
the animal only by the use of the boxes.

The first observations on Sobke were made on June 14. The three boxes
had been placed in the form of a pyramid directly under the banana,
which hung about eighteen inches above the uppermost box. Sobke's
attention while in his cage had been attracted to the bait by seeing me
fastening it in position, but when admitted to the large cage, he simply
glanced at it and then wandered about the cage, picking up bits of food
and struggling to get at the other monkeys. This he did for about five
minutes. He then went to the boxes, placed his hands on top of the
bottom one, but did not climb up on it. A few minutes later he returned
to the box again, climbed up, and readily reached the food, which he ate
while resting on boxes 1 and 2.

I now replaced the bait and gave the monkey a second chance to obtain
it. Almost immediately he climbed up as far as the second box, but
although he could reach the banana only from the uppermost box, he
deliberately shoved it off to the ground and sat down upon box 2. As he
was unable to obtain the banana from this, he soon began to gnaw and
pull at it, and as he was succeeding all too well in his efforts to tear
the box to pieces, he had to be returned to his cage.

The most important features of his behavior were, first, his stealthy
and indirect manner, and second, his failure to use other means of
obtaining the bait than that supplied by the observer. Instead of
looking straight at the experimenter, or at the object which he wished
to obtain, he apparently looked and attended elsewhere. For this reason
it was often difficult to decide whether or not he had noticed the bait
or the boxes. Finally I was led to conclude that he usually knew exactly
what was going on and had in his furtive way noted all of the essential
features of the situation, and that his manner was extremely indicative
of his mental attitude of limited trust. Both Julius and Skirrl went to
the opposite extreme in the matter of directness, or as we should say in
human relations, frankness. They would look the experimenter directly in
the eye, and they usually gazed intently at anything, such for example
as the bait, that interested them. Sobke, even when very hungry, instead
of going directly toward the bait, and trying to obtain it, usually did
various other things as though pretending that he had no interest in
food.

On the following day, June 15, the three boxes were again placed nearly
under the banana, but this time the two smaller boxes, numbers 1 and 2,
were pushed to the extreme end of the lower box and so far from the bait
that it could not be reached from box 1. It was necessary then for the
animal to push boxes 1 and 2 along on box 3 until they were nearer the
bait.

Sobke, when admitted to the cage, evidently noticed the banana, but as
formerly, he made no immediate effort to obtain it. After wandering in
search of food and quarreling with the other monkeys for several
minutes, he went to the boxes, pushed the topmost one, number 1, off on
to the floor, and then carried it into his cage where he quickly tore
one side off. He next returned to the large cage, climbed up on box 2,
and he was able, by jumping, to reach and obtain the banana.

As Sobke was very good at jumping, his new method rendered the box
stacking experiment of uncertain value, since it was next to impossible
so to arrange the spatial relations of bait and boxes that he should be
neither discouraged by too great a distance nor encouraged to jump by
too small a distance. Evidently it would be more satisfactory to
simplify the conditions by trying to discover, first of all, whether he
would use a single box as a means of reaching the reward.

In pursuance of this idea, I suspended a piece of bread five feet from
the floor of the cage, and a few feet to one side of it, I placed a box
from which it could be reached, or at least easily seized by jumping.
Sobke shortly walked to a point beneath the bait and leaping into the
air, seized it.

I then replaced the bait, raising it to a height of five feet ten inches
from the floor of the cage. When I had retired, Sobke placed himself in
the proper position beneath, looked up at it, but went away without
jumping for it. During the remaining ten minutes of observation, he paid
no further attention to the bait, having satisfied himself evidently
that it was beyond his reach.

My use of this test was concluded on June 16 when once more I suspended
a piece of bread six feet from the floor and placed a few feet to one
side the eighteen inch box, number 3, from which had the monkey pushed
it to a point directly under the bread, he could have obtained the food
easily. Sobke noticed the food promptly, and from time to time as he
wandered about, he glanced at it out of the corner of his eye, but not
once did he sit down and look at it steadily and directly as Julius and
Skirrl might have done.

In the first twenty minutes of observation the monkey made no attempt
either to use the box or to reach the food by jumping. I then placed the
box directly under the bait, and scarcely had I withdrawn from the cage
before Sobke climbed up on it and looked toward the food. He could not
reach it without jumping, and he made no effort to get it. I had left a
second box in the cage,--one which I had been using as a seat. Sobke now
went to this box, placed his hands on it, looked toward the bait, and
then went to a distant part of the cage. No further indications were
obtained during the remainder of the period of observation of interest
in the boxes as possible means of obtaining the desired food.

It is of course obvious that this experiment was not long enough
continued to justify the conclusion that either Sobke or Skirrl could
not use the boxes or even learn to place one box upon another in order
to obtain the bait. The experiment, like several others which are being
described briefly, was used to supplement the multiple-choice
experiment, and the experimenter's chief interest was to discover the
number and variety of methods which would be used by the animal in
the first few presentations of a situation. It is practically certain
that both of these monkeys would have succeeded ultimately in solving
the problem of obtaining the food had they been left in the cage with a
number of boxes, for Skirrl very early indicated interest in moving the
boxes about, and Sobke showed a tendency in that direction which perhaps
was inhibited partially by his distrust of the experimenter.


_Draw-in Experiment_

For Sobke, as for Julius and Skirrl, the draw-in test was made by
putting food on a shelf outside the cage, beyond the reach of the
animal, and placing in the cage with the animal one or two sticks long
enough to be used for drawing in the bait.

Sobke was first given this test on July 24. He tried persistently to
reach the banana with his hand, seized the box which supported the bait,
shook it, picked up one or other of the sticks, and chewed at it
repeatedly, but not once did he make any move to use a stick to draw the
food toward him.

This experiment was repeated on July 27, 29, 30 and 31, a period of
thirty minutes being allowed on each day for observation. At no time did
Sobke show any inclination to use either a stick or any other object as
a means of reaching the bait. Instead, he confined himself strictly to
the use of hands and teeth.

This test makes it fairly certain that Sobke had no natural tendency to
use objects as tools. In so far as he attended to things about the cage
or laboratory, it seemed to be rather to play with them in a general way
than to use them ideationally or otherwise for definite purposes.

The definitely negative result of the draw-in experiment rendered
needless prolonged observation with the box and pole test, whose results
are now to be presented.


_Box and Pole Experiment_

The eighty-four inch box, previously used for a similar test with
Julius, was presented to Sobke on August 24, the wooden cover having
been replaced by a wire one so that the monkey could readily see the
bait in the middle of the box. Sobke, when admitted to the large cage,
went directly to the box and at once discovered the banana which was
midway between the ends. He evidently desired it. Shortly, he went to
one end of the box and looked in. This he repeated later. He also shook
the box and tried to pull it about and tear it with his teeth, but to
the two poles lying nearby on the floor of the cage he gave not the
slightest attention during a thirty minute period of observation.

The experiment was not repeated because of more important work.


_Other Activities_

In more respects than I have taken time to enumerate in the above
descriptions of behavior, the relations of Sobke to objects differed
from those of Skirrl, and still more from those of Julius. Hammer,
nails, saw, stones, sticks, locks, and various other objects received
relatively little attention from Sobke unless they happened to come in
his way; then they were usually pushed aside with but scant notice.
Rarely he would carry something to the shelf of his cage with him, but
as a rule only to lay it down and attend to something else. Skirrl, on
the contrary, attended persistently to anything new in the shape of a
movable object. He was extremely partial to objects which could be
manipulated by him in various ways, and especially to any thing with
which he could make a noise. His interest in hammer and nails, saw,
locks, etc., seemed never to wane. I have seen him play for an hour
almost uninterruptedly with a hammer and a nail, or even with a big
spike which he could use to pry about his cage. In the absence of
anything more interesting, even a staple or a small nail might receive
his undivided attention for minutes at a time. How important is the
species difference in this connection, I have no means to judge, but if
we may not consider these different modes of behavior characteristic of
_P. rhesus_ as contrasted with _P. irus_, we must conclude that
remarkable individual differences exist among monkeys, for whereas
Skirrl is by nature a mechanical genius, Sobke has apparently no such
disposition. I can imagine no more fascinating task than the careful
analytical study of the temperaments of these two animals. Skirrl's
behavior has importantly modified my conception of genius.



V

MISCELLANEOUS OBSERVATIONS


1. _Right- and left-handedness_

Several years ago Doctor Hamilton reported to me observations which he
had made on preference for the right or left paw in dogs. He has not, I
believe, published an account of his work. Subsequently, Franz observed
a similar preference in monkeys which, according to his report, exhibit
marked tendency to be right-handed, left-handed, or ambidextrous.

My own observations, although they are wholly incidental to my other
work, seem worthy of description at this point. I noted, first of all,
that the orang utan Julius tended to use his left hand. He by no means
limited himself to this, but in difficult situations he almost
invariably reached for food or manipulated objects in connection with
food getting with the left hand. Figures 23 and 24 of plate V, show him
reaching for a banana with the left hand. Likewise, figure 34 exhibits
the use of the left hand in the draw-in experiment.

So marked was Julius's preference for his left hand that I became
interested in observing similar phenomena in the monkeys. Skirrl, when
driving nails, held the hammer with his left hand and the nail with his
right hand. The fact that he never was observed to reverse the use of
the hands is surprising, for other observations indicate that he
preferred the right hand for certain acts.

Stimulated by the obvious left-handedness, in certain connections, of
Julius and Skirrl, I tested the preference of several of the monkeys in
the following simple way. Standing outside the cage I would hold out a
peanut to a hungry animal, keeping it so far from the cage that the
monkey could barely reach it with its fingers. I noted the hand which
was used to grasp the food. Next I varied the procedure by placing the
peanut on a board in order to make sure that I was not definitely
directing the animal's attention.

With Sobke the following results were obtained. In forty trials given on
two different days, he reached for and obtained the food each time with
his left hand. Only by holding the bait well toward the right side of
his body was it possible to induce him to use the right hand. So far as
may be judged from these observations and from others in connection with
the experiments, this animal is definitely left-handed.

With Skirrl the results are strikingly different. As stated above, he
used the hammer consistently with his left hand, but in twenty attempts
to obtain food by reaching, he used his right hand seventeen times and
his left only three times. It was quite as difficult to induce him to
use his left hand for this purpose as it was to induce Sobke to use his
right. We must therefore conclude that Skirrl is right-handed in
connection with certain movements and left-handed in others.

The monkey named Gertie in the reaching experiment consistently used her
left hand, never once using the right.

Jimmie, so far as it was possible to make tests with him, also used his
left hand, but it should be said that the results are unsatisfactory
because he was at the time extremely pugnacious and paid attention to
the experimenter rather than to the food.

Scotty, in the first series of ten trials, used his right hand eight
times, his left twice. In the second series, given the following day, he
used the right hand three times and the left seven times. From this we
should have to infer that he is ambidextrous.

A female _rhesus_ monkey which had been brought to the laboratory only a
few days previously showed a preference for the right hand by the use of
it fourteen times to six.

In connection with these data which are, I should repeat, too scanty to
be of any considerable value, I wish to describe my own experience.
Although naturally left-handed, I am by training right-handed to the
extent of having been able to use my hands in writing and in various
other activities equally well at the age of twelve. I am at present
ambidextrous in that there are many things which I do with equal
readiness and skill with either hand. Delicate, exact, and finely
coordinated movements, such as those of writing and using surgical
instruments, I perform always with my left hand while grosser movements
involving the whole hand or arm, I am rather likely to perform with my
right hand.

It seems not improbable in the light of my own experience that we shall
find some specialization among the lower animals with respect to
preference for right and left hand or arm. I should not be at all
surprised to discover that it is the rule for animals to possess or to
develop readily definite preference for one hand in connection with a
given act of skill and to have quite as definite a preference for the
other hand in connection with a radically different kind of act.


2. _Instinct and emotion_

Of the many presumably instinctive modes of behavior which were
observed, only those which have to do with social relations seem
especially worth reporting. From among them I shall select for
description a few which have already been referred to in connection with
the experimental observations.


_Maternal Instinct_

Aspects of the maternal instinct I had opportunity to observe in Gertie,
who on February 27 gave birth to a male infant, I present below the
substance of a previously published note on her behavior (Yerkes, 1915).

"On February 27 one of the monkeys of our collection gave birth, in the
cages at Montecito, to a male infant. The mother is a _Macacus
cynomolgus rhesus_ (_P. irus rhesus_) who has been described by Hamilton
(1914, p. 298) as 'Monkey 9, Gertie, _M. cynomolgus rhesus_ (_P. irus
rhesus_). Age, 3 years 2 months. (She is now, May 1, 1915, 4 years and 6
months.) Daughter of monkeys 3 and 10. First pregnancy began September,
1913.' The result of this pregnancy was, I am informed, a still-birth.

"The second pregnancy, which shall now especially concern us, resulted
likewise in a still-birth. Parturition occurred Saturday night, and the
writer first observed the behavior of the mother the following Monday
morning. In the meantime the laboratory attendant had obtained the data
upon which I base the above statements.

"At the time of parturition Gertie was in a 6 by 6 by 12 foot out-door
cage containing a small shelter box, with an exceptionally quiet and
gentle male (not the father of the infant) who is designated in
Hamilton's paper as Monkey 28, Scotty.

"My notes record the following exceptionally interesting and genetically
important behavior. On March 1, when I approached her cage, Gertie was
sitting on the floor with the infant held in one hand while she fingered
its eyelids and eyes with the other. Scotty sat close beside her
watching intently. When disturbed by me the mother carried her infant to
a shelf at the top of the cage. Repeatedly attempts were made to remove
the dead baby, but they were futile because Gertie either held it in her
hands or sat close beside it ready to seize it at the slightest
disturbance.

"Especially noteworthy on this, the second day after the birth of the
infant, are the male's, as well as the female's, keen interest in the
body and their frequent examinations of the eyes, as if in attempts to
open them. Often, also, the mother searched the body for fleas.

"Observations were made from day to day, and each day opportunity was
sought to remove the body without seriously frightening or exciting the
female. No such opportunity came, and during the second week the corpse
so far decomposed that, with constant handling and licking by the
adults, it rapidly wore away. By the third week there remained only the
shriveled skin covering a few fragments of bone, and the open skull from
the cavity of which the brain had been removed. This the mother never
lost sight of: even when eating she either held it in one hand or foot,
or laid it beside her within easy reach.

"Gradually this remnant became still further reduced until on March 31
there existed only a strip of dry skin about four inches long with a
tail-like appendage of nearly the same length.

"The male, Scotty, on this date was removed to another cage. Gertie made
a great fuss, jumping about excitedly and uttering plaintive cries when
she discovered that her mate was gone. Whenever I approached her cage
she scurried into the shelter box and stayed there while I was near.
This behavior I never before had observed. It continued for two days. On
April 2, it was noted that she had lost her recently acquired shyness
and she no longer made any attempts to avoid me. As usual, on this date,
she was carrying the remnant about with her.

"The following day, April 3, Gertie was lured from her cage to a large
adjoining compartment for certain experimental observations. After she
had been returned to her own cage the remnant was noticed on the floor
of the large cage. I picked it up. Gertie evidently noticed my act; for
although at a distance of at least ten feet from me, she made a sharp
outcry and sprang to the side of the cage nearest me. I held the piece
of skin (it looked more like a bit of rat skin than the remains of a
monkey) out to her and she immediately seized it and rushed with it to
the shelf at the top of the cage.

"Two days later the remnant was missing, and careful search failed to
discover it in the cage. It is probable that Gertie had carelessly left
it lying on the floor whence it was washed out when the cages were
cleaned. On this date Gertie seemed quieter than for weeks previously.

"Thus it appears that during a period of five weeks the instinct to
protect her offspring impelled this monkey to carry its gradually
vanishing remains about with her and to watch over them so assiduously
that it was utterly impossible to take them from her except by force.

"After reading this note in manuscript, Doctor Hamilton informed me that
Gertie had behaved toward her first still-birth as toward her second.
And, further, that Grace, a baboon, also carried a still-birth about for
weeks.

"I am now heartily glad that my early efforts to remove the corpse were
futile, for this record of the persistence of maternal behavior seems to
me of very unusual interest to the genetic psychologist."


_Fear_

In connection with the multiple-choice experiments Skirrl exhibited what
seemed to be instinctive fear as a result of his unfortunate experience
with nails in the floor of box 1. He seemingly referred his misadventure
to some unseen enemy under the floor, and this in spite of the fact that
he was given abundant opportunity to examine the floor of the box, but
not until after the dangerous nails had been clinched. His long
continued avoidance of the experiment boxes and his still more
persistent hesitancy in entering them, coupled with his almost ludicrous
efforts to see beneath the floor through the holes cut for the staples
on the doors, gave me the impression of superstitious fear of the
unseen. As I watched and recorded his behavior day after day during the
period of most pronounced fear, I could not avoid the thought that the
instinctive fear of snakes had something to do with his peculiar
actions, and although I have never studied either the natural or the
acquired responses of monkeys to snakes, I suspect that lacking such
instinctive equipment, Skirrl would have behaved differently as a result
of the pricks which he received from the nails. It is needless to
redescribe his acquired fear of whiteness as it manifested itself in the
freshly painted apparatus. Accompanying these instructive modes of
response and their emotions are suggestions of peculiarly interesting
problems as well as of modes of attacking them. As a matter of fact,
Skirrl's fear-reactions did much to alter my conception of the
constitution of his mind. I should not have been surprised by the
features of behavior exhibited, but I was by no means prepared for their
persistence, and for the highly emotional attitude toward the particular
situation. Only an organism of complexly constituted nervous system and
fairly highly developed affective life could be expected to respond as
did this monkey. As has been suggested above, I find the appeal to
instinct, modified by experience, a natural mode of accounting for the
unexpected features of Skirrl's behavior.


_Sympathy_

The instinctive playfulness of the young monkey Tiny contrasted most
strikingly with the more serious, if not more sedate, modes of behavior
of the older individuals.

During the greater part of my period of observation Tiny was cage-mate
of Scotty, the most calm and apparently lazy of all the monkeys. Tiny
delighted in teasing Scotty, and her varied modes of mildly tormenting
him and of stirring him to pursuit or to retaliation were as interesting
as they were amusing. Her most common trick was to steal up behind him
and pull the hair of his back, or seize his tail with her hands or
teeth. Often when he was asleep she would suddenly run to him, give a
sudden jerk at a handful of hairs, and leap away. He was surprisingly
patient, and I never saw him treat her roughly in retaliation.

Another of Tiny's favorite forms of amusement was that of trying to stir
up the other monkeys to attacks on one another. She very cleverly did
this by pretending that she herself was being attacked. The instant the
older animals began to show hostility toward one another she would leap
out of the way and watch the disturbance with evident satisfaction. It
was this mode of behavior in the little animal which ultimately provided
opportunity for the observations which I wish now to report as
indicative of sympathetic, possibly I may say altruistic, emotions.

Tiny was confined with Scotty in a cage adjoining the one in which
Jimmie and Gertie were being kept. The cages were separated by wire
netting of half-inch mesh.

One morning as I was watching the behavior of the animals in the several
cages, I noticed Tiny dressing with her teeth a wounded finger. It had
evidently been bitten by one of the other animals, in all probability
either by Jimmie or Gertie. Tiny was trimming away the loose bits of
skin very neatly and cleansing the wound. After working at this task for
a few minutes, she quickly climbed up to the shelf near the top of her
cage, and by rushing to the partition wire between the two cages, she
lured Gertie to an attempted attack on her. Gertie sprang up to the
partition, placed her hands on it, with the fingers projecting through
the meshes, and attempted to seize Tiny's fingers with her teeth. But
the latter was too quick for her, and withdrawing her hands, like a
flash seized in her teeth the middle finger of Gertie's left hand. She
then bit it severely and with all her might, at the same time pulling
and twisting violently, often placing the entire weight of her body on
the finger. Her sharp teeth cut to the bone, and it was impossible for
the larger and stronger monkey to tear away. For several seconds this
continued, then Gertie succeeded in escaping, whereupon she at once
retreated to the opposite end of her shelf and proceeded to attend to
her injured finger. She cried, wrung her hands, and from time to time
placed the finger in her mouth as though in an effort to relieve the
pain. By this time Jimmie's attention had been attracted by the
disturbance and he rushed up to the shelf, and facing Gertie, watched
her intently for a few seconds. The look of puzzled concern on his face
was most amusing. Apparently he felt dimly that something in which he
should have intelligent interest was going on, but was unable wholly to
understand the situation. After watching Gertie for a time and trying to
discover what she was doing, which was rendered difficult by her
tendency to turn away from him, in order to shield her injured finger,
he rushed over to the wire partition and made strenuous efforts to seize
Tiny with his hands and teeth. But although she continued close to the
partition and often crowded against it with face and hands flattened on
the wires, he was not able to get hold of her, and after a few vain
attempts he returned to his mate, and again with evident solicitousness
and the most troubled expression, watched her wringing her hands and
chewing or sucking at her injured finger. Shortly he again returned to
the partition and renewed his attempts to seize the young monkey. Thus
he went back and forth from one place of interest to the other several
times, but being unable to achieve anything at either point, he finally
gave up and returned to his breakfast on the floor of the cage.

I report this incident fully because the behavior of Jimmie was in
marked contrast with the usual behavior of the monkeys. Selfishness
seemed everywhere dominant, while clear indications of sympathetic
emotions were rare indeed. The above is undoubtedly the best evidence of
anything altruistic that I obtained.

It is possible that Tiny's action was retaliatory, but although it is
practically certain that either Gertie or Jimmie inflicted the wound on
her finger, I of course cannot be sure that the spirit of revenge
stirred her to punish Gertie so severely. Jimmie's part in the whole
affair is, however, perfectly intelligible from our human point of view,
and there seems no reason to doubt that he did experience something like
a feeling of sympathy with his mate, coupled with a feeling of
resentment or anger against Tiny.



VI

HISTORICAL AND CRITICAL DISCUSSION OF IDEATIONAL BEHAVIOR IN MONKEYS AND
APES


It is my purpose in this section to indicate the relations of my work on
monkeys and apes to that of other investigators. Although throughout the
report I have used freely the psychological terms idea and ideation, it
has been my aim to describe the behavior of my animals rather than to
interpret it or speculate concerning its accompaniments. Certain acts I
have designated as ideational simply because they seemed to exhibit the
essential features of what we call ideational behavior in man. Further
study may, and probably will, modify my opinion concerning this matter.
It is of prime importance to analyze ideational behavior so that it may
be accurately described and satisfactorily defined in terms of its
distinguishing characteristics. I had hoped to be able to present a
tentative analysis in this report, but the results of my efforts are so
unsatisfactory that I do not feel justified in publishing them.

The terms idea and ideation have been used to designate contents of
consciousness which are primarily representative. Nowhere have I
attempted to indicate different types or grades of ideational behavior
and nowhere have I found it necessary to emphasize differences between
image and idea. In general, the acts which I have called ideational have
been highly adaptive, and the learning processes in connection with
which they have appeared have differed strikingly from those of the
selective sort in their abruptness of appearance.

Extremely interesting and valuable definitions of ideation and
discussions of the characteristics of different sorts of ideas in the
light of original observations on monkeys have been presented by
Thorndike (1901, pp. 1, 2; 1911, p. 174); Kinnaman (1902, p. 200); and
Hobhouse (1915, p. 270). As these authors have contributed importantly
to our knowledge of the behavior of monkeys, their discussions of the
meaning of terms are especially valuable. Serviceable definitions are to
be found, also, in Romanes (1900), Morgan (1906), Washburn (1908), and
Holmes (1911).


_Evidences of Ideation in Monkeys_

Aside from anecdotal and traveller's notes on the behavior of monkeys
and apes we have only a scanty literature. In fact, the really excellent
articles on the behavior and mental life of these animals may be counted
on one's fingers; and not more than half of these are experimental
studies. I shall, in this brief historical sketch, neglect entirely the
anecdotal literature, since my own work is primarily experimental, and
since its results should naturally be compared with those of other
experimenters.

Thorndike (1901), the American pioneer in the application of the
experimental method to the study of mind in animals, published the first
notable paper on the psychology of monkeys. His results force the
conclusion that "free ideas" seldom appear in the monkey mind and have a
relatively small part in behavior. That the species of Cebus which he
observed exhibits various forms of ideation he is willing to admit. But
he insists that it is of surprisingly little importance in comparison
with what the general behavior of monkeys as known in captivity and as
described by the anecdotal writers have led us to expect. It is
important to note, however, that Thorndike's observations were limited
to Cebus monkeys which, as contrasted with various old world types, are
now considered of relatively low intelligence.

In many respects the most thoroughgoing and workmanlike experimental
study of monkeys is that of Kinnaman (1902), who has reported on the
study of various forms of response in _P. rhesus_. He presents valuable
data concerning the learning processes, sensory discrimination, reaction
to number, and to tests of imitation. His results indicate a higher
level of intelligence than that discovered by Thorndike, but this is
almost certainly due to difference in the species observed. Kinnaman
goes so far as to say "We have found evidence, also, of general notions
and reasoning, both of low order" (p. 211).

The contribution of Hobhouse (1915) to our knowledge of the mental life
of monkeys, although in a measure experimental, is based upon relatively
few and unsystematic observations as contrasted with those of Thorndike
and Kinnaman. It appears, however, that Hobhouse's experiments were
admirably planned to test the ideational capacity of his subjects, and
one can not find a more stimulating discussion of ideation than that
contained in his "Mind in Evolution." The results of his tests made with
a _P. rhesus_ monkey are similar to those of Kinnaman, for almost all of
them indicate the presence and importance of ideas.

Watson (1908) in tests of the imitative ability of _P. rhesus_ saw
relatively little evidence of other than extremely simple forms of
ideation. But in contrast with his results, those obtained by Haggerty
(1909), in a much more extended investigation in which several species
of monkey were used, obtained more numerous and convincing evidences of
ideation in imitative behavior. Although this author wholly avoids the
use of psychological terms, seeking to limit himself to a strictly
objective presentation of results, it is clear from an unpublished
manuscript (thesis for the Doctorate of Philosophy, deposited in the
Library of Harvard University) that he would attribute to monkeys simple
forms of ideational experience.

Witmer (1910) reports, in confirmation of Haggerty's results,
intelligently imitative behavior in _P. irus_.

The work of Shepherd (1910) agrees closely, so far as evidences of
ideation are concerned, with that of Thorndike. He obviously strives for
conservatism in his statements concerning the adaptive intelligence of
his monkeys, all of which belonged to the species _P. rhesus_. At one
point he definitely states that they exhibit ideas of a low order, or
something which corresponds to them. Satisfactory evidences of reasoning
he failed to obtain.

Franz's (1907, 1911) studies of monkeys, unlike those mentioned above,
have for their chief motive not the accurate description of various
features of behavior but instead knowledge of the functions of various
portions of the brain. His results, therefore, although extremely
interesting and of obvious value to the comparative psychologist, throw
no special light upon the problem of ideation.

The investigation by Hamilton (1911) of reactive tendencies in _P.
rhesus_ and _irus_ yielded preeminently important data concerning
complex behavior. For the ingenious quadruple-choice method devised by
this observer showed that mature monkeys exhibit fairly adequate types
of response. As Hamilton's interest centered in behavior, he did not
discuss ideation, but this does not prevent the comparison of his data
with those of the present report, and the agreement of his findings with
my own is obvious.

My work contrasts sharply with that briefly mentioned above in that I
applied systematically and over a period of several months an
experimental method suited to reveal problem solving ability.
Previously, the so-called problem or puzzle-box method had been used as
a means of testing for the presence of ideas. For this I substituted the
multiple-choice method. One of the chief advantages of this new method
is the possibility of obtaining curves of learning for the solution or
attempted solution of relational problems of varying difficultness. I am
confident that these curves of learning will prove far more valuable
than such data as are yielded by the puzzle-box method.

The Pithecus monkeys, which I studied intensively, yielded relatively
abundant evidences of ideation, but with Thorndike I must agree that of
"free ideas" there is scanty evidence; or rather, I should prefer to
say, that although ideas seem to be in play frequently, they are rather
concrete and definitely attached than "free." Neither in my sustained
multiple-choice experiments nor from my supplementary tests did I obtain
convincing indications of reasoning. What Hobhouse has called articulate
ideas, I believe to appear infrequently in these animals. But on the
whole, I believe that the general conclusions of previous experimental
observers have done no injustice to the ideational ability of monkeys.
It is clearly important, however, that we always should take into
account the species of animal observed, for unquestionably there are
extreme differences in mental development among the monkeys.

As I view my results in the light of their relations to earlier work, I
am strongly impressed with the importance of the use of improved methods
for the study of complex behavior. The delayed reaction method of
Hunter, the quadruple-choice method of Hamilton, and my multiple-choice
method offer new and promising approaches to forms of activity which
thus far have been only superficially observed.

The ability exhibited by Skirrl to try a method out and then to abandon
it suddenly is characteristic of animals high in intelligence. Most of
the problems which I presented to my animals would be rated as difficult
by psychologists, for as a rule they involved definite relations and
demanded on the part of the subject both perception of a particular
relation and the ability to remember or re-present it on occasion.

I was greatly surprised by the slow progress of the monkeys toward the
solution of these problems. It had been my supposition that they would
solve them more quickly than any lower type of mammal, but as a matter
of fact they succeeded less well than did pigs. Their behavior
throughout the work proved that of far greater significance for the
experimenter than the solution of a problem is definite knowledge of the
modes of behavior exhibited from moment to moment, or day to day. This
is true especially of those incidental or accidental modes of response
which so frequently appeared in connection with my work that I came to
look upon them, the surprises of each day, as my chief means of insight.


_Evidences of Ideation in Apes_

Reliable literature of any sort concerning the behavior and mental life
of the anthropoid apes is difficult to find, and still more rare are
reports concerning experimental studies of these animals. There are, it
is true, a few articles descriptive of tests of mental ability, but even
these are scarcely deserving of being classed as satisfactory
experimental studies of the psychology of the ape. I have the
satisfaction of being able to present in the present report the first
systematic experimental study of any feature of the behavior of an
anthropoid ape.

Among the most interesting and valuable of the descriptions which may be
classed among accounts of tests of mental ability is Hobhouse's (1915)
study of the chimpanzee. The subject was an untrained animal, so far as
stated, of somewhat unsatisfactory condition because of timidity.
Nevertheless, Hobhouse was able to obtain from him numerous and
interesting responses to novel situations, some of which may be safely
accepted as evidences of ideation of a fairly high order.

Similar in method and result to the work of Hobhouse is that of Haggerty
(unpublished thesis for the Doctorate of Philosophy, deposited in the
Library of Harvard University). Haggerty's tests of the ability of young
orang utans and chimpanzees to solve simple problems and to use tools in
various ways yielded results which contrast most strikingly with those
obtained in his experimental study of the imitative tendency in monkeys.
His observations, had he committed himself to anything approaching
interpretation, doubtless would have led him to conclusions concerning
the ideational life of these animals very similar to those of Hobhouse.

Koehler, working in the Canary Islands, has, according to information
which I have received from him by letter, made certain experiments with
orang utans and chimpanzees similar to those of Hobhouse and Haggerty.
His results I am unable to report as I have scanty information
concerning them. They are, presumably, as yet unpublished.

In his laboratory at Montecito, California, Hamilton has from time to
time kept anthropoid apes, but without special effort to investigate
their ideational behavior. He has most interesting and valuable data
concerning certain habits and instincts, all as yet unpublished.

To a congress of psychologists Pfungst (1912) briefly reported on work
with anthropoid apes in certain of the German zoölogical gardens. His
preliminary paper does not enable one to make definite statements
concerning either his methods or such results as he may have obtained
concerning ideational behavior. So far as I know, he has not as yet
published further concerning his investigation.

Möbius (1867) has described interesting observations concerning the
mental life of the chimpanzee. But this, like all of the work previously
mentioned, is rather in the nature of casual testing than thoroughgoing,
systematic, and analytic study.

In addition to the above reports, there are a few concerning the
behavior of apes which have been especially trained for purposes of
exhibition. Most interesting of these is that of Witmer (1909), who
studied in exhibitions and in his own laboratory the behavior of the
chimpanzee Peter. The varied forms of intelligently adaptive behavior
exhibited by this ape convinced Witmer of ideational experience and even
of an approach to reasoning. In his brief report he expresses especial
interest in the possibility of educating this "genius among apes" to the
use of language.

A chimpanzee named Consul was observed several years ago by Hirschlaff
(1905), and his tricks were interestingly described from the pedagogical
standpoint.

Similar in character is Shepherd's (1915) brief description of the stage
behavior of Peter and Consul, both chimpanzees. It is impossible to
determine from the account whether these animals are the same as were
observed by both Witmer and Hirschlaff. As no reference is made in
Shepherd's paper to other descriptions of the behavior of these animals
and as he adds nothing to what had already been presented, the reader
obtains no additional light on ideation.

I have mentioned only samples of the articles on trained anthropoids.
All are necessarily descriptions of the behavior of individuals who had
been trained not for psychological purposes but for the vaudeville
stage, and although such observations unquestionably have certain value
for comparative psychology, it is well known that unless an observer
knows the history of an act, he is not able to evaluate it in terms of
intelligence and is especially prone to overestimate its value as
evidence of ideation.

There remain studies of the apes, dealing primarily with behavior and
mental characteristics, which are slightly if at all experimental and
deserve to be ranked as naturalistic accounts. Such is, for example, the
book of Sokolowski (1908), in which attention is given to the
characteristics of young as well as fairly mature specimens of the
gorilla, chimpanzee and orang utan.

The various publications of Garner (1892, 1896, 1900) deal especially
with the language habits of monkeys and apes, but observations bearing
on ideation are reported.

Wallace (1869) describes certain features of the behavior of an infant
orang utan whose mother he shot in Borneo. He also reports observations
concerning the behavior of adult orang utans, many specimens of which
were shot by him during his travels.

Early in the last century, Cuvier (1810) interested himself in studies
of the intellectual characteristics of the orang utan, and his data,
taken with those of Wallace, Sokolowski, and others similarly interested
in the natural history of mind, give one a valuable glimpse of the life
of the anthropoid ape.

Finally, the data brought together by Brehm (1864, 1875, 1888) in his
famous Tierleben; by Darwin (1859, 1871) in "The Origin of Species," and
other works, by Romanes (1900), especially in his books on mental
evolution, by C. Lloyd Morgan (1906) in his several works on comparative
psychology, and by Holmes (1911) in his discussion of the evolution of
intelligence, contribute not unimportantly to our all too meagre
knowledge of the mental life of the anthropoid apes.

My own results, viewed in the light of what one may learn from the
literature, stand out as unique because of the method of research. Never
before, so far as I have been able to learn, has any ape been subjected
to observation under systematically controlled conditions for so long a
period as six months. Moreover, my multiple-choice method has the merit
of having yielded the first curve of learning for an anthropoid ape.
This fact is especially interesting when one considers the nature of the
particular curve. For so far as one may say by comparing it with the
curves for various learning processes exhibited by other mammals, it is
indicative of ideation of a high order, and possibly of reasoning. I do
not wish to exaggerate the importance of my results, for as contrasted
with what might be obtained by further study, and with what must be
obtained if we are adequately to describe the mind of the orang utan,
they are meager indeed.

Especially noteworthy, as evidences of ideation, in the results yielded
by the multiple-choice method are (1) the use by the orang utan of
several different methods in connection with each problem; (2) the
suddenness of transition from method to method; (3) the final and
perfect solution of problem I without diminution of the initial errors;
(4) the dissociation of the act of turning in a circle from that of
standing in front of a particular box.

To these features of behavior others of minor importance might be added.
But as they have been sufficiently emphasized in the foregoing detailed
descriptions, I need only repeat my conclusion, from the summation of
evidence, that this young orang utan exhibited numerous free ideas and
simple thought processes in connection with the multiple-choice
experiment. His ultimate failure to solve the second problem is
peculiarly interesting, although in the light of other features of his
behavior by no means indicative of inferior intelligence.

The various supplementary experimental tests which I employed are in no
wise importantly distinguished from those used by other observers. The
box stacking experiment has, according to my private information, been
used by Koehler. It is obviously important that such tests be applied in
the same manner to individuals not only of the different genera of
anthropoid apes, but of different ages, sex, and condition of training.

The box stacking experiment, although it yielded complete success only
as a result of suggestion on my part, proved far more interesting during
its progress than any other portion of my work. In connection with it,
the orang utan exhibited surprisingly diverse and numerous efforts to
meet the demands of the situation. It is fair to characterize him as
inventive, for of the several possible ways of obtaining the banana
which were evident to the experimenter, the ape voluntarily used all but
two or three, and one of these he subsequently used on the basis of
imitation.

Had Julius been physically and mentally mature, my results would
undoubtedly have been much more impressively indicative of ideas, but
even as matters stand, the survey of my experimental records and
supplementary notes force me to conclude that as contrasted with the
monkeys and other mammals, the orang utan is capable of expressing free
ideas in considerable number and of using them in ways highly indicative
of thought processes, possibly even of the rational order. But
contrasted with that of man the ideational life of the orang utan seems
poverty stricken. Certainly in this respect Julius was not above the
level of the normal three-year-old child.

In common with other observers, I have had the experience of being
profoundly impressed by the versatility of the ape, and however much I
might desire to disprove the presence of free ideas and simple reasoning
processes in the orang utan, I should feel bound to accept many of the
results of my tests as evidences of such experience.

I have attempted to indicate briefly the historical setting of my
investigation. I propose, now, in the concluding section, to look
forward from this initial research and to indicate as well as I may in a
few words the possibilities of results important for mankind from the
thorough study of the monkeys and anthropoid apes.



VII

PROVISION FOR THE STUDY OF THE PRIMATES, AND ESPECIALLY THE MONKEYS AND
ANTHROPOID APES[1]

[Footnote 1: Much of the material of this section was published
originally in _Science_ (Yerkes, 1916).]


I should neglect an important duty as well as waste an opportunity if in
this report I did not call attention to the status of our knowledge
concerning the monkeys and apes and present the urgent need of adequate
provision for the comparative study of all of the primates.

Although for centuries students of nature have been keenly interested in
the various primates, the information which has been accumulated is
fragmentary and wholly inadequate for generally recognized scientific
and practical needs. There is a voluminous literature on many aspects of
the organization and lives of the monkeys and apes, but when one
searches in it for reasonably connected and complete descriptions of the
organisms from any biological angle, one, is certain to meet
disappointment.

Concerning their external characteristics we know much; and our
classifications, if not satisfactory to all, are at least eminently
useful. But when one turns to the morphological sciences of anatomy,
histology, embryology, and pathology, one discovers great gaps, where
knowledge might reasonably be expected. Even gross anatomy has much to
gain from the careful, systematic examination of these organisms. With
still greater force this statement applies to the studies of finer
structural relations. Little is known concerning the embryological
development and life history of certain of the primates, and almost
nothing concerning their pathological anatomy.

Clearly less satisfactory than our knowledge of structure is the status
of information concerning those functional processes which are the
special concern of physiology and pathology. Certain important
experimental studies have been made on the nervous system, but rarely
indeed have physiologists dealt systematically with the functions of
other systems of organs. There are almost no satisfactory physiological
descriptions of the monkeys, anthropoid apes, or lower primates.



SUB-DIVISIONS OF THE ORDER PRIMATES

_Order_ _Sub-orders_      _Families_

          ,- a. PROSIMII (Lemurs and Aye-Ayes)
          |
          |                       ,-  i. Hapalidae (Marmosets)
          |                       |  ii. Cebidae (Howling Monkeys,
PRIMATES -+                       |       Tee Tees, Squirrel Monkeys,
          |                       |       Spider Monkeys, and Capuchin
          |                       |       Monkeys)
          `- b. ANTHROPOIDEA ... -+ iii. Cercopithecidae (Baboons
                                  |       and Macaques)
                                  |  iv. Simiidae (Gibbons, Orangs,
                                  |       Chimpanzees, and Gorillas)
                                  `-  v. Hominidae (Man)




When we turn to the science of genetics we meet a similar condition, for
the literature reveals only scattered bits of information concerning
heredity in the primates. No important experimental studies along
genetic lines have been made with them, and such general observations
from nature as are on record are of extremely uncertain value. Were one
to insist that we know nothing certainly concerning the relation of
heredity in other primates than man, the statement could not well be
disputed.

Occasionally in recent years students of human diseases have employed
monkeys or apes for experimental tests, but aside from the isolated
results thus obtained, extremely little is known concerning the diseases
peculiar to the various types of infra-human primates or the significant
relations of their diseases to those of man.

Next in order of extent to our morphological knowledge of these
organisms is that of their behavior, mental life, and social relations.
But certainly no one who is conversant with the behavioristic,
psychological and sociological literature could do otherwise than
emphasize its incompleteness and inadequacy. For our knowledge of
behavior has come mostly from naturalistic observation, scarcely at all
from experimentation; our knowledge of social relations is obviously
meager and of uncertain value; and finally, our knowledge of mind is
barely more than a collection of carelessly drawn inferences.

This picture of the status of scientific work on the primates, although
not overdrawn, will doubtless surprise many readers, and even the
biologist may find himself wondering why we are so ignorant concerning
the lives of the organisms most nearly akin to us, and naturally of
deepest interest to us. The reasons are not far to seek. Most scientific
investigators are forced by circumstances to work with organisms which
are readily obtained and easily kept. The primates have neither of these
advantages, for many, if not most of them, are expensive to get and
either difficult or expensive to keep in good condition. Clearly, then,
our ignorance is due not to lack of appreciation of the scientific value
of primate research but instead to its difficultness and costliness.

Strangely enough, the practical importance of knowledge of the primates
has seldom been dwelt upon even by those biologists who are especially
interested in it. It is, therefore, appropriate to emphasize the
strictly human value of the work for which I am seeking provision.

During the past few years it has been abundantly and convincingly
demonstrated that knowledge of other organisms may aid directly in the
solution of many of the problems of experimental medicine, of
physiology, genetics, psychology, sociology, and economics. In the light
of these results, it is obviously desirable that all studies of
infrahuman organisms, but especially those of the various primates,
should be made to contribute to the solution of our human problems.

To me it seems that thoroughgoing knowledge of the lives of the
infrahuman primates would inevitably make for human betterment. Through
the science of genetics, as advanced by experimental studies of the
monkeys and anthropoid apes, practical eugenic procedures should be more
safely based and our ability to predict organic phenomena greatly
increased. Similarly, intensive knowledge of the diseases of the other
primates in their relations to human diseases should contribute
importantly to human welfare. And finally, our careful studies of the
fundamental instincts, forms of habit formation, and social relations in
the monkeys and apes should lead to radical improvements in our
educational methods as well as in other forms of social service.

Along theoretical lines, no less than practical, systematic research
with the primates should rapidly justify itself, for upon its results
must rest the most significant historical or genetic biological
descriptions. It is beyond doubt that genetic psychology can best be
advanced to-day by such work, and what is obviously true of this science
is not less true of all the biological sciences which take account of
the developmental or genetic relations of their events.

In view of the probable values of increasingly complete accounts of
primate life, it seems far from extravagant to insist that the securing
of adequate provision for systematic and long continued research is the
most important task for our generation of biologists and the one which
we shall be least excusable for neglecting. Indeed, when one stops to
reflect concerning the situation, it seems almost incredible that the
task has not been accomplished.

Some ten years ago Professor John B. Watson (1906) entered a plea for
the founding of a station for the experimental study of behavior. He
made no special mention of work with the monkeys and apes, but it is
clear from the problems which he enumerates that he would consider them
most important subjects for observation. Professor Watson's plea has
apparently been forgotten by American biologists, and it seems not
inappropriate to revive it at this time. For surely we have advanced
sufficiently along material and scientific lines during the last ten
years to render possible the realization of his hope.

To my knowledge, only one definite attempt has thus far been made to
gain special provision for the study of the primates. Somewhere about
the year 1912 there was established on Tenerife, one of the Canary
Islands, a modest station for the study of the anthropoid apes. I have
already referred to it briefly on page 1. The plan and purpose of this
station, which is of German origin, have been presented briefly by
Rothmann (1912). From personal communications I know that a single
investigator has been in residence at the station since its founding and
that psychological and physiological results of value have been
obtained, but no published reports have come to my attention.

When I first heard of the existence of the German anthropoid station I
naturally thought of the possibility of coöperative work, but the events
of the past two years have rendered the chances of cooperation so remote
that it now seems wholly desirable and indeed imperative to seek the
establishment of an American station, which, unlike the German station,
shall provide adequately not only for the study of the anthropoid apes
but for that of all of the lower primates. It should be the function of
such a station or research institute (1) to bring together and correlate
all the information at present available; (2) to fill in existing gaps
observationally and thus complete and perfect our knowledge of these
organisms; (3) to seek to bring all available information to bear upon
the problems of human life.

Hitherto the unsatisfactoriness of progress has been due to the lack of
a definite plan and program. Every investigator has gone his own way,
doing what little his personal means and opportunity rendered possible.
The time has at last come when concerted action seems feasible as well
as eminently desirable. I am therefore offering a plan and program
which, if wisely developed, should lead ultimately to fairly complete
and practically invaluable knowledge of the lives of all of the
primates. There should be provided in a suitable locality a station or
research institute which should offer adequate facilities (1) for the
maintenance of various types of primate in normal, healthy condition;
(2) for the successful breeding and rearing of the animals, generation
after generation; (3) for systematic and continuous observation under
reasonably natural conditions; (4) for experimental investigations from
every significant biological point of view; (5) for profitable
cooperation with existing biological institutes or departments of
research throughout the world.

The station should be located in a region whose climate is highly
favorable to the life of many of the lower primates as well as to that
of man. Such a location is by no means easy to find. Because of my
intense interest in the subject, I have, during the past five years,
prospected in various parts of the world for a satisfactory site. I
shall now attempt to indicate the chief requirements and also the
foremost advantages and disadvantages of several regions which have been
considered. It is first of all requisite that the climate be such as to
agree with the organisms to be studied and such, also, as to render
their breeding normal and dependable. Second in importance is its
satisfactoriness for the life and scientific productiveness of the
observer. While certain tropical localities would meet the first
requirement perfectly, they would prove extremely unsatisfactory for
research activity. It therefore seems essential to find a region whose
climate shall reasonably meet the needs of the experimenter while
adequately meeting those of the animals to be studied.

A further factor which has important bearing upon the productiveness of
the observer is the degree of isolation from civilization and from other
scientific work. No scientist can long work effectively, even in a
reasonably healthy and stimulating climate, if entirely cut off from
similar interests and activities. It is therefore desirable, if at all
possible, to discover a location in the midst of civilization and with
reasonably good opportunities for scientific associations.

With these several desiderata before us, I shall call attention to a
number of possible sites for a station, several of which I have visited.
Southern California, and especially the portion of the State between
Santa Barbara and San Diego, promises fairly well. It is definitely
known that certain, if not all, species of monkey will breed there
fairly satisfactorily, and although it has not yet been demonstrated,
there is no reason to suppose that in certain regions the anthropoid
apes might not also be kept in perfect health and successfully bred. The
main advantages of this general region are (a) a climate which promises
to be reasonably satisfactory for many if not all of the primates; (b)
admirable climatic conditions for investigators; (c) wholly satisfactory
scientific and cultural environment for the staff of a station. The most
significant disadvantages are (a) a temperature, which is at times a
trifle too low for the comfort of certain of the monkeys and apes. It is
by no means certain, however, that they would not usually adapt
themselves to it. (b) The necessity of importing all of the animals and
of having to rely upon successful acclimatization. Of course it is to be
assumed that importation would be necessary only at the outset of such
work, since the animals later should replenish themselves within the
confines of the station.

Florida offers possibilities somewhat similar to those of southern
California, but as I have not had opportunity to examine the conditions
myself, I can say only that in view of such information as is available
the advantage seems to be greatly in favor of the latter.

Cuba, Jamaica, Porto Rico, and for that matter, several of the West
Indies, offer possible sites for a successful station. I have reasonably
intimate personal knowledge only of the conditions in Jamaica. The major
advantages in the West Indies are (a) suitable climatic conditions and
food supply for the animals; and (b) reasonably satisfactory climatic
conditions for the staff. These are, however, more than counterbalanced
in my opinion by the following serious disadvantages: (a) the relative
isolation of the investigators from their fellow scientists; (b) the
necessity of importing all of the animals originally used; (c) the risk
of destruction of the station by storms.

It is definitely known that anthropoid apes as well as monkeys can be
successfully kept, bred, and reared in the West Indies. During the past
year, on the estate of Doha Rosalia Abreu, near Havana, Cuba, a
chimpanzee was born in captivity. A valuable account of this important
event and of the young ape has been published by Doctor Louis Montané
(1915). It therefore seems practically certain that regions could be
found readily on Jamaica, Porto Rico, or smaller islands, which would be
eminently satisfactory for the breeding of apes.

There are obvious reasons why an American station for the study of the
primates should be located on territory controlled by the United States
Government, and if a tropical location proves necessary, it would
probably be difficult to find more satisfactory regions, aside from the
inconveniences and risk of importation and the relative isolation of the
investigators, than are available on Porto Rico.

I have not seriously considered the possibility of locating an American
station on the continent of Africa, for although two of the most
interesting and important of the anthropoid apes, the gorilla and the
chimpanzee, are African forms, while many species of monkey are either
found there or could readily be imported, it has seemed to me that the
islands of the West and East Indies and the portions of the United
States referred to above are much to be preferred over anything
available in Africa.

In the East, Borneo, the Philippine Islands, and Hawaii are well worth
considering. Borneo is the home of the gibbon and of at least one
species of orang utan, and in addition to these important assets, it
presents the advantages of (a) a wholly suitable climate and food supply
for monkeys and apes; and (b) climatic conditions for investigators
which, I am informed by scientific friends, are nearly ideal. For
investigators the most serious disadvantage here, as in all other parts
of the East, would be the isolation from other scientific work and
workers.

The possibilities of Central America I considered several years ago when
it seemed to me possible that work might profitably be done with monkeys
and apes on the Canal Zone. The advantages are (a) a climate which
promises fairly well for the animals; and (b) reasonable accessibility
from the United States. The disadvantages are (a) a far from ideal
climate for long continued scientific work; and (b) an environment which
from the cultural and scientific point of view leaves much to be
desired.

Were a permanent psycho-biological station for the study of the primates
to be established in southern California, it would, even though wholly
satisfactory conditions for the breeding, rearing, and studying of the
animals were maintained, furnish more or less inadequate opportunity for
the observation of the animals under free, natural conditions. It would
therefore be necessary, to supplement the work of such a station by
field work in Borneo, Sumatra, Africa, India, South America, and such
other regions as the species of organism under consideration happen to
inhabit.

Considering equally the needs of the experimenter and the demands of the
animals, it seems to me reasonable to conclude that southern California
should be definitely proved unsuitable before a more distant site were
selected. For the information which I have been able to accumulate
convinces me that it would in all probability be possible successfully
to breed and keep the primates there, and it is perfectly clear that in
such event the output of a station would be enormously greater because
of the more favorable conditions for research than in any tropical
region or in a more isolated location.

Assuming that satisfactory provision in the shape of a scientific
establishment for the study of the primates in their relations to man
were available, the following program might be followed: (1) Systematic
and continuous studies of important forms of individual behavior, of
social relations, and of mind; (2) experimental studies of physiological
processes, normal and pathological, and especially of the diseases of
the lower primates, in their relations to those of man; (3) studies of
heredity, embryology, and life history; (4) research in comparative
anatomy, including gross anatomy, histology, neurology, and pathological
anatomy.

Each of these several kinds of research should be in progress almost
continuously in order that no materials or opportunities for observation
be needlessly wasted. Because of the nature of the work, it would be
necessary to provide, first of all, for those functional studies which
demand healthy and normally active organisms, whose life history is
intimately and completely known. This is true of all studies in
behavior, whether physiological, psychological, or sociological.
Simultaneously with behavioristic observations and often upon the same
individuals, genetic experiments might be conducted. This would be
extremely desirable because of the relatively long periods between
generations. After the usefulness of an animal in behavioristic or
genetic inquiries had been exhausted, it might be made to render still
further service to science in various experimental physiological, or
medical inquiries. And finally, the same individual might ultimately be
used for various forms of anatomical research. Thus, it is clear that
the scientific usefulness of a lemur, a monkey, or an ape might be
maintained at a high level throughout and even beyond the period of its
life history.

The program thus briefly sketched would provide either directly or
indirectly for work on every aspect of primate life. Especially
important would be the intimacy of interest and cooperation among
investigators, for the comparative method should be applied consistently
and to the limit of its value. The results of various kinds of
observation should be correlated so that there should ultimately emerge
a unitary and practically valuable account of primate life, to replace
the patchwork of information which we now possess.

Because of the costliness of maintaining and breeding the monkeys and
apes, it is especially desirable that the several kinds of research
mentioned above should be conducted. Indeed, it would seem inexcusably
wasteful to attempt to maintain a primate or anthropoid station for
psychological observations alone, or for any other narrowly limited
biological inquiry.

Furthermore, the station should be permanent, since for many kinds of
work it would be essential to have intimate knowledge of the life
history and descent of an individual. With the lower primates, a
generation might be obtained in from two to five years; with the higher,
not more frequently, probably, than from ten to fifteen years. It
therefore seems not improbable that the value of the work done in such a
station would continue to increase for many years and would not reach
its maximum short of fifty or even one hundred years.

A staff of several highly trained and experienced biologists would be
needed. The following organization is suggested as desirable, although,
as indicated below, not necessarily essential in the beginning: (1) An
expert especially interested in the problems of behavior, psychology,
and sociology, with keen appreciation of practical as well as of
theoretical problems; (2) an assistant trained especially in comparative
physiology; (3) an expert in genetics and experimental zoology; (4) an
assistant with training and interests in comparative anatomy, histology,
and embryology; (5) an expert in experimental medicine, who could
conduct and direct studies of the diseases of man as well as of the
lower primates and of measures for their control; (6) an assistant
trained especially in pathology and neurology.

To this scientific staff of six highly trained individuals there should
be added a business manager, a clerical force of three individuals, a
skilled mechanician, a carpenter, and at least four laborers.

The annual expenditures of an institute with such a working staff, would
in southern California, approximate fifty thousand dollars. It would
therefore be necessary that it have an endowment of approximately one
million dollars.

In the absence of this foundation it would, of course, be possible to
make a reasonably satisfactory beginning on the work which has been
outlined in the following less expensive manner. A working plant might
be established, on ground rented or purchased at a low figure, for about
ten thousand dollars; the salary of a director, assistants, a clerical
helper, and combined mechanic and laborer might be estimated at the same
figure; the cost of animals and of maintenance of the plant would
approximate five thousand dollars. Thus, we should obtain as an estimate
of the expenditures for the first year twenty-five thousand dollars.
Without expansion, the work might be conducted during the second year
for fifteen thousand dollars, and subsequently it might be curtailed or
expanded, resources permitting, according as results achieved and in
prospect justified.

An institute established on such a modest basis as this still might
render largely important scientific service through its own research and
through organized cooperation with other existing research
establishments. Thus, for example, supposing that behavioristic,
psychological, sociological, and genetic inquiries were conducted in the
institute itself, animals might be supplied on a mutually satisfactory
basis to institutes for experimental medicine, for physiological
research, and for anatomical studies. Under such conditions, it is
conceivable that extremely economical and good use might be made of all
the available primate materials. But it is not improbable that even
coöperative research would prove on the whole more profitable, except
possibly in the case of morphological work, if investigators could
conduct their studies in the institute itself rather than in distant
laboratories. In any event, the idea of coöperation should be prominent
in connection with the organization of a research station for the study
of the primates. For thus, evidently, scientific achievement in
connection with these important types of animal might be vastly
increased over what would be possible in a single relatively small
institution with a limited and necessarily specialized staff of workers.

Despite the fact that biologists generally recognize the importance of
the work under consideration and are eager to have it done, it is
perfectly certain that we shall accomplish nothing unless we devote
ourselves confidently, determinedly and unitedly, with faith, vision,
and enthusiasm, to the realization of a definite plan. Our vision is
clear,--if we are to gather and place at the service of mankind adequate
comparative knowledge of the life of the primates and if we are to make
this possible harvest of scientific results count for human betterment,
we must bend all our efforts to the establishment of a station or
institute for research.



VIII

BIBLIOGRAPHY



BREHM, A. Tierleben.
  1888.

COBURN, C.A. and YERKES, R.M. A study of the behavior of the crow,
  1915.   _Corvus Americanus_ Aud. by the multiple-choice method.
          _Journal of Animal Behavior_, vol. 5, 75-114.

CUVIER, FREDERIC. Description d'un orang-outang, et observations sur
  1810.   ses facultées intellectuelles. _Annales du Museum d'Histoire
          naturelle_, vol. 16, 46-65.

DARWIN, C. Origin of species.
  1859.

  1871. The descent of man, and selection in relation to sex.

ELLIOT, D.G. A review of the primates. New York.
  1913.

FRANZ, S.I. On the functions of the cerebrum: the frontal lobes.
  1907.   _Archives of Psychology_, no. 2, 1-64.

  1911. On the functions of the cerebrum: the occipital lobes.
          _Psychological Monographs_, vol. 13, 1-118.

  1913. Observations on the preferential use of the right and left
          hands by monkeys. Journal of Animal Behavior, 3, 140-144.

GARNER, R.L. The speech of monkeys. London.
  1892.

  1896. Gorillas and chimpanzees. London.

  1900. Apes and monkeys; their life and language. Boston and London.

HAGGERTY, M.E. Imitation in monkeys. _Journal of Comparative Neurology_
  1909.   _and Psychology_, vol. 19, 337-455.

HAMILTON, G.V. A study of trial and error reactions in mammals.
  1911.   _Journal of Animal Behavior_, vol. 1, 33-66.

  1914. A study of sexual tendencies in monkeys and baboons. _Journal_
          _of Animal Behavior_, vol. 4, 295-318.

HIRSCHLAFF, L. Der Schimpanzee Konsul. _Zeit. f. päd. Psy_., vol. 7, 1.
  1905.

HOBHOUSE, L.T. Mind in evolution. London.
  1915.

HOLMES, S.J. Evolution of intelligence. New York.
  1911.

HRDLICKA, A. Anatomical observations on a collection of orang skulls
  1907.   from western Borneo; with a bibliography. _Proceedings of
          the United States National Museum_, vol. 31, 539-568.

KINNAMAN, A.J. Mental life of two _Macacus rhesus_ monkeys in captivity.
  1902.   _American Journal of Psychology_, vol. 13, 98-148, 173-218.

LASHLEY, K.S. and WATSON, J.B. Notes on the development of a young
  1913.   monkey. _Journal of Animal Behavior_, vol. 3, 114-139.

MÖBIUS, K. Zur psychologie des Schimpanse. _Zool. Garten_., vol. 8,
  1867.   279-280.

MONTANÉ, L. Un chimpancé Cubano. Havana, _El Siglo XX_.
  1915.

MORGAN, C.L. Introduction to comparative psychology. London.
  1906.

PFUNGST, O. Zur Psychologie der Affen. _Ber. über d. V. Kongress f._
  1912.   _exp. Psychol_., 200-205.

ROMANES, G.J. Mental evolution in animals. New York.
  1900.

ROTHMANN, M. Ueber die errichtung einer Station zur psychologischen
  1912.   und hirn[?] physiologischen Erforschung der Menschenaffen.
          _Berliner klinische Wochenschr_., Nr. 42.

SHEPHERD, W.T. Some mental processes of the rhesus monkey.
  1910.   _Psychologic Monographs_, vol. 12, 1-61.

  1915.   Some observations on the intelligence of the chimpanzee.
          _Journal of Animal Behavior_, vol. 5, 391-396.

SOKOLOWSKY, A. Beobachtungen über die Psyche der Menschenaffen.
  1908.   Frankfurt a. M.

THORNDIKE, E.L. The mental life of the monkeys. _Psychological_
  1901.   _Monograph_, vol. 3, 1-57.

  1911.   Animal intelligence. New York. 1911.

WALLACE, A.R. The Malay Archipelago. London.
  1869.

WASHBURN, M.F. The animal mind. New York.
  1908.

WATSON, J.B. The need of an experimental station for the study of
  1906.   certain problems in animal behavior. _Psychological_
          _Bulletin_, vol. 3, 149-156.

  1908.  Imitation in monkeys. _Psychological Bulletin_, vol. 5,
         169-178.

  1909.  Some experiments bearing upon color vision in monkeys.
         _Journal of Comparative Neurology and Psychology_, vol. 19,
         1-28.

WITMER, L. A monkey with a mind. _Psychological Clinic_, vol. 3, 179-205.
  1909.

  1910.  Intelligent imitation and curiosity in a monkey. _Psychological_
         _Clinic_, vol. 3, 225-227.

YERKES, R.M. The study of human behavior. _Science_, vol. 39, 625-633.
  1914.

  1910.  Maternal instinct in a monkey. _Journal of Animal Behavior_,
         vol. 5, 403-405.

  1916.  Provision for the study of the monkeys and apes. _Science_,
         vol. 43, 231-234.

YERKES, R.M. and COBURN, C.A. A study of the behavior of the pig
  1915.  _Sus scrofa_ by the multiple-choice method. _Journal of_
         _Animal Behavior_, vol. 5, 185-225.